Thread was locked by
a moderator
  • Justin Herbert is more skilled than Mahomes. Better arm. Just as mobile. More accurate.

    Mahomes no look gimmick got him an INT vs the Chargers.

    I鈥檇 also say Herbert is a top 3 QB. His rookie season is all that more impressive considering how the other rookies did last year and are doing this year.

  • Oct 2
    1 reply

    Kyler>Justin

  • Jon

    Kyler>Justin

    No.

  • Mahomes, Herbert and Kyler will be the top 3 from the new generation

  • Oct 2
    1 reply

    I definitely think Mahomes benefited from how stacked that offense was his first 2 years, but I think I'd still pick him. Herbert will be a top 5 QB for a long time though

  • Oct 2
    1 reply

    Alright let鈥檚 dissect the delusion @op
    1. Mahomes wasn鈥檛 responsible for that pick, te had a very catchable ball right in his face and dropped it
    2. No way Herbert is top 3. It鈥檚 his second f***ing year, and let鈥檚 not forget he just lost to the cowboys. (Which mahomes wouldn鈥檛 let happen)
    3. Mahomes, Rodgers, and Russell Wilson are all better quarterbacks than Herbert

  • Stop the cap

  • Oct 2
    1 reply
    easy

    I definitely think Mahomes benefited from how stacked that offense was his first 2 years, but I think I'd still pick him. Herbert will be a top 5 QB for a long time though

    Allen and Ekeler are stacked

  • Oct 3
    1 reply

    In

    Hubert that nigga

  • Oct 3
    1 reply
    DrizzyTaughtMe

    Alright let鈥檚 dissect the delusion @op
    1. Mahomes wasn鈥檛 responsible for that pick, te had a very catchable ball right in his face and dropped it
    2. No way Herbert is top 3. It鈥檚 his second f***ing year, and let鈥檚 not forget he just lost to the cowboys. (Which mahomes wouldn鈥檛 let happen)
    3. Mahomes, Rodgers, and Russell Wilson are all better quarterbacks than Herbert

    Liked until the final 2 parts. Seek god. That鈥檚 all I have to say.

  • Lu The Ruler

    Allen and Ekeler are stacked

    O-line was s*** last season. Also had a horrible coach and he still went off.

  • Oct 3
    1 reply
    NobodyWins

    Liked until the final 2 parts. Seek god. That鈥檚 all I have to say.

    Are you really saying Herbert is better than Rodgers? What's next he's better than Brady?

    Herbert is nice, but mans isn't even better than Joe Burrow

  • Oct 3
    1 reply
    Lu The Ruler

    Are you really saying Herbert is better than Rodgers? What's next he's better than Brady?

    Herbert is nice, but mans isn't even better than Joe Burrow

    He鈥檚 better than Burrow for sure. Top 3 QB.

    Official ranking:
    1. Tom Brady
    2. Herbert
    3. Mahomes
    4. Kyler
    5. Rodgers

  • Oct 3
    1 reply

    Big Herb is definitely on his way to running the AFC so I respect this thread

  • Jay34

    In

    Hubert that nigga

  • Oct 4
    1 reply
    NobodyWins

    He鈥檚 better than Burrow for sure. Top 3 QB.

    Official ranking:
    1. Tom Brady
    2. Herbert
    3. Mahomes
    4. Kyler
    5. Rodgers

    Horrible order

  • Lu The Ruler

    Horrible order

    It鈥檚 the right order

  • Certified Marty

    Big Herb is definitely on his way to running the AFC so I respect this thread

    Real

  • BUMP

  • Bump :)

Thread was locked by
a moderator