Two different games. I know that. Which one you like better.

Both 10/10 on first play through when they first came out. But I was able to go back to RDR2 a couple of years later and really enjoy a second run. Tried to play the Witcher 3 again when the PS5 update dropped and it felt so dated, couldn’t get into the gameplay again.

Witcher 3 for me

RDR2

both are great but rd2's world feels more alive & organic

all the question marks on witcher's map makes me not wanna explore it

and the combat on controller feels like im playing QWOP idk how i beat this s*** 8 years ago

RDR2 made me cry soooo

RDR2 easily

RDR as I never played Witcher 3

That being said, RDR has no replayability

Rdr2 by a landslide

RDR2's movement, while not Mario-level dynamic and responsive, feels realistic and weighty, and I enjoy that a lot

The Witcher 3 just feels bad to move around in for me, on a basic level the traversal is unrewarding, so I quit early, RDR2 completely gripped me though

I love Witcher 3 but RDR 2 is the greatest game of all time

They're literally my two favorite RPG's.

RDR 2 aged better tho so I gotta go with it.

But both are amazing.

witcher 3

i'm obsessed with rdr2 rn but still only on Chapter 2.
Should I try Witcher

i’m over here on my 3rd playthrough

also witcher 3 is incredibly overrated so there’s that

I definitely enjoyed witcher 3 more

why

I think I enjoyed the world setting and questlines more in Witcher. Great dialogue and side quests were fun too. And I thought the banter from Geralt was fun too. Faster gameplay compared to RDR 2 as well, which I find very slow and clunky. I havent played RDR2 since release but I dont feel any need to go back and replay it.

Still think RDR 2 is a great game tho and understand why most people would prefer it to Witcher 3.

same lol

I think I've tried witcher 3 like 4 times and have never gotten more than a few hours in, I just hate how it plays

Same except I only tried once maybe twice

typed a whole essay then i deleted it bc it doesn’t even matter rdr2 is just goated lol

like lowkey the only open world game worth playing in last few years is rdr2 and zelda and they’re opposite side of the spectrum

narrative focus of red dead is insane u get to see a great american cowboy movie and a f***ing d’angelo song is like in one of the most pivotal scenes

zelda is ultimate players choice game until something else comes along

elden ring looks phenomenal to the fromsoftware ppl and def S tier

witcher 3 already feels a decade old ngl