Hard to choose some of these categories but I guess I’m ok with my list
real for that prince of persia 2008 shoutout, might have to go back and replay it

Didn’t do repeats or the whole thing would’ve been Part 2
Great list
Baldur's Gate is not overrated tho

Used best combat as best gameplay and needs a remake as needs a remaster
Also didn't really know what to put in Not my thing so i just put the latest game i had zero expectations for going into and pleasantly surprised me

godlike list, so many classics. you can play quake 3 nowadays in your browser, i pop in for a couple of matches every few days.
also spot on for serious sam 2 for being overhated. yeah its wacky, but at least it had its own identity, which was like ratchet and clank on acid. they went the opposite way and overcorrected afterwards with 3, which was so dour and glib. almost had first encounter as my nostalgia game
godlike list, so many classics. you can play quake 3 nowadays in your browser, i pop in for a couple of matches every few days.
also spot on for serious sam 2 for being overhated. yeah its wacky, but at least it had its own identity, which was like ratchet and clank on acid. they went the opposite way and overcorrected afterwards with 3, which was so dour and glib. almost had first encounter as my nostalgia game
serious sam is underrated lowk, also good eye on catching that at all because i couldnt think of any other game to put there wondering if anyone will get that it got super s*** on when it came out 20 years ago. i was thinking fallout 4 belongs there too but i guess everyone is fine with it now
we must commit 

How you gonna show so much love for 2 and then say 1 is overrated
anyways which antagonist from 2 is your favorite? Game full of great ones, Nihilus was mine

I wanted to put red dead/shadow of the colossus for best story + uncharted 2/3 for personal impact but I didn’t want any repeats so

Don’t care to rank all of these. Tried to mostly go games that aren’t coming up yet
No game needs a remake, end remaster/remakeslop today. Play white knuckle NOW
How you gonna show so much love for 2 and then say 1 is overrated
anyways which antagonist from 2 is your favorite? Game full of great ones, Nihilus was mine
cus most ppl hail 1 then sneak diss 2 in the same breath for its bugs/unfinished release but none of that negatively impacted my experience and the latter still outdoes its predecessor on virtually every level; granted i played 1 with some idea of the twist but thats wat comes w hinging impact on reveals.
kreia is probly my favorite of all time, but there's such a rich symbolic poetry between the trio that any one of them is a good pick

I wanted to put red dead/shadow of the colossus for best story + uncharted 2/3 for personal impact but I didn’t want any repeats so
Real for gh3 biggest impact