You get six choices (we don't count post-Layne output in this thread):

Facelift
Sap
Dirt
Jar of Flies
s/t
MTV Unplugged

Dirt is my answer

I’d go with Dirt as well. Jar of Flies probably would be my second choice.

yeah JOF would be second for me, as well. But unplugged is close

made this thread cuz im binging the Layne part of their discography again

who where

facelift or dirt

listening to facelift rn, Layne on Love Hate Love is

only heard Dirt s/o San Andreas

Jar of Flies is on its level. Give it a listen.

Probably dirt. But jar of flies I like more personally

Dirt is the only album I know well tbh

I've listened to the rest of the discog before but I don't really remember it

my rankings:

Dirt
JOF
MTV Unplugged
Facelift
S/T
Sap

Self-titled

IN ok ill check it out

Dirt for sure

it took me a minute to really dig that one ngl. The production is super sludgy and layne's voice is kind distorted. But I f*** with it a lot now especially Sludge Factory and Frogs

Jar of Flies is crazy good

yeah first few times I heard it I didn’t like it as much as the others. Over time though it’s become my favorite. I love the production on it.

rotten apple is their best intro honestly, which is saying something cuz I love Them bones

Loving all the 90s alt discussion we’re having on here lately btw

its much more interesting than talking about kanye's latest dumb rant fs

In for later

Facelift probably their most dated release. But Layne f***ing destroys that record. His vocals are