It a 7/10 for me idk . Havent listened in awhile tho

We are not going to disrespect kiss

Opening trio is insane I’ll say that

Nah im gnna fight bcause how r ppl calling this album weak? 9 songs in and nothing below a 9/10

This is like the middest of mid pop to me. Sounds like if an AI made a Carly album.

She's dropped nothing but 10s in her last 4 projects so not that upset. Still some banger songs on this

Even loneliest time sounds good right now

I hated this song

Ehat happened

She picked some weird singles but I still shouldn't have doubted

yes I do think of you when im with someone else

Half these songs don’t even sound like Carly, what are you talking about

What AI would make Shooting Star in an attempt to recreate Carly

like every song on here and love a few

got all i can ask from a carly album

Bonus tracks

Just started, this will be my first Carly album I’ve listened to

So nice the first song im kinda meh at but im sure itll grow

Chorus on anxious is gonna be crazy I know it

Did you finish it before posting it? That instrumental goes crazy in the second half

This is like the most obvious progression in sound after something like Dedicated

Anxious f***ing hell

I'm a top 3 Carly stan on this site lol

This isn't v good by her standards

And she progressed because she’s an artist not an AI lol

Hopefully it grows on you, this is everything I wanted

no one cares how big of a stan u r , opinions still opinions

Oh this is calm relaxing pretty

surrender my heart holy s***

Confession: I thought Dedicated Side B was super weak and her only kinda miss since Kiss, it actually drives me nuts when people say it’s better than Dedicated lol

I’m way back on the bandwagon now though

Bonus tracks are great too

Swap out Joshua Tree and Beach House for Anxious and Keep Away and I have my perfect track list

Carly is radiant and fills me with joy.