Thread was locked by
a moderator
  • Jul 18, 2021
    ·
    2 replies
    WESLEYS THEORY

    Up From The Ashes should've been the intro to JIK, not Every Hour. Sorry that's just how I feel.

    Song gets so boring after like 3 listens, and I feel like it doesn’t do its job as an opener. I think Every Hour at least does that.

    LA Monster super boring too

  • Jul 18, 2021
    Tvmim

    Giving Sunday Service choir the opening spotlight on the album after touring with them all year >>>>>>

    They got Jesus is Born, I'm trying hear as much Ye as possible on a Ye solo album.

    UP FROM THE ASHES INTO THE SKY
    :​

  • Jul 18, 2021
    ·
    2 replies
    Hi-C
    · edited

    I actually disagree hardcore.

    • No Church in the Wild - 9/10 song easily

    • Lift Off - honestly I think this song is pretty good despite it having s***ty rap verses, probably rate it like a 7 (Beyonce hard carries)

    • Niggas in Paris - 10/10 easily

    • Otis - Another 10/10

    • Gotta Have It - again, 10/10 (this easily one of the best 3 track stretches in either entire discog)

    • New Day - This song from a rap perspective probably one of the better tracks. Don't love it but objectively an 8/10

    • That's My B**** - probably like a 7/10, beat, chorus and bridge carries I think

    • Welcome to the Jungle - this song probably like a 6.5, Swizzy kinda ruins it. Not a bad song from a rap perspective but I think the beat and hook are mid

    • Who Gon Stop Me - probably a 8.5 or 9/10

    • Murder to Excellence - 10/10 easy

    • Made in America - Frank carries a bit and Ye has a good verse, outro is really good too 8/10

    • Why I Love You - probably worst track, 5.5/10, not terrible but easily the worst song in my eyes

    • Illest Motherfucker Alive - this like a 6.5

    • H.A.M - 10/10

    • Primetime, beats by Dion - Def an 8

    • The Joy: 10/10

    You take away Illest Motherfucker alive, Why I Love You, and Welcome to the Jungle and its damn near a flawless albums. There are classics with many more misses. I just think the amount of 10s on this album easily make it classic worthy. And again, factoring in the collab aspect, I think it gets a boost for that reason

    id say take away welcome to the jungle and who gon stop me and its 10/10

  • Jul 18, 2021

    2019-2020 Push feature run was great

  • Jul 18, 2021
    ·
    1 reply
    Hi-C

    Goddamn it Goo don't you start hopping on this train too

    That verse was misplaced bro. What was the point of it? Dope verse but didn't fit at all. Explain to me bc I could be wrong ya know

  • Jul 18, 2021
    ·
    1 reply
    Noir

    I still really like the chorus to Water

    Verses were AWFUL

    hands on is a favorite of mine

    I think the production is unreal. the song is so strange

  • Jul 18, 2021
    ·
    1 reply
    Goo

    Only 1 verse from each per song

    Pusha's verse had nothing to do with the subject of the song

    Cudi and Ye never traded bars. Felt detached from each other

    Reborn hook repeats 100 times with no change or progression

    Idk some songs needed more meat/structure

    Also it was just an EP.

    Crazy amount of nonsense in this post. "No tradong of bars..." this aint your generic hip hop collab bud. They had incredible chemistry on every song. Reborn repetition literally ties into the theme of the song lol

  • Jul 18, 2021
    eversince

    hands on is a favorite of mine

    I think the production is unreal. the song is so strange

    Agreed on the production, it's like a really weird 2007-2009 outtake

  • Jul 18, 2021
    ·
    1 reply

    I get the allure for KSG, but defending JIK, and especially Ye, as 'great' albums is a little far-fetched. Hope Donda is a return to form in some way, even a TLOP-level project would be a blessing at this point.

  • Jul 18, 2021
    Hi-C

    If niggas start turning on Push because of one verse, imma lose it

  • Jul 18, 2021
    best poster

    I get the allure for KSG, but defending JIK, and especially Ye, as 'great' albums is a little far-fetched. Hope Donda is a return to form in some way, even a TLOP-level project would be a blessing at this point.

    They are ass

  • Jul 18, 2021

    JIK >
    God Is >>>>>

  • Jul 18, 2021

    Maybe he didn't want to rap to complex on a Pop Smoke song but yea the verse was mid.
    It would've been better if they cut out the Martinez intro (or put it at the end) and the Push verse. Ye's part as an intro is fine

  • Jul 18, 2021
    ·
    1 reply

    I see nothing but incredible work in ye, ksg, and JIK

  • Jul 18, 2021
    Everything

    Crazy amount of nonsense in this post. "No tradong of bars..." this aint your generic hip hop collab bud. They had incredible chemistry on every song. Reborn repetition literally ties into the theme of the song lol

    Well I disagree 💀

  • Jul 18, 2021

    I know Push Verse was ass on the new Pop Smoke album and some Drake fans are having a ball s***ting on him, but let's not forget Push had the best rap verse of the year hands down on Palmolive. That s*** was amazing.

    Need Madpush so bad.

  • Jul 18, 2021
    ·
    1 reply
    Abyss

    WTT is a classic collab album.. No collab album topped the scale WTT had.

    Black star is way better

  • Jul 18, 2021
    ·
    1 reply
    WESLEYS THEORY

    Which part?

    his verse on fire but he pulls it off well lol

  • Jul 18, 2021
    ·
    1 reply
    new

    his verse on fire but he pulls it off well lol

    Which verse?

  • Jul 18, 2021
    ·
    1 reply
    NewCopeJustDropped

    Black star is way better

    Thats why i didn't say its the best collab. I talked about the scale and the impact

  • Jul 18, 2021

    bruh gave why i love you a 5.5

  • NeonNigga23

    id say take away welcome to the jungle and who gon stop me and its 10/10

    You not dissing who gonna stop me …no. That ain’t happening . 😒

    Whooooo gonna stop me now

  • Jul 18, 2021
    CLB RAHUL

    What Would Meek Do, right?

    What Would Meek Do is underrated because of the scoopity poop s***. Ye killed his verse

  • Zaywop 💊
    Jul 18, 2021
    ·
    1 reply
    Maga Law

    Pusha was due for a miss

    It's alright

    My hating ass hearing that wack ass Pusha verse

  • Jul 18, 2021

    no f***ing wayyyyyyy

1
...
55
56
57
...
99
Thread was locked by
a moderator