why did they give it a 0
Resplendent moments – like a second’s burst of sunshine through dark storm clouds – are so rare that by the time you emerge on the other side, they’re all but forgotten. ... But by involving Manson, West has made this impossible. Donda leaves a sour taste that no number of good beats, gospel choirs or church organs will cleanse. Zero stars.
The state of music journalism in 2021
Independent gave it a zero???
The reviewer was complaining more about Kanye linking up with Manson and DaBaby than the actual album
this being panned by critics is hilarious since it’s OBJECTIVELY better than TLOP
goes to show how much they reviewed his personality when they dissected his music prior to 2018
also dont quote me cause TLOP does not have this
!https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=yblfMrUeiP4Hows it objectively better than tlop if i like tlop more
P4K probably giving him an 7 or so. They love d***riding Kanye, and they have a reputation of being contrarian.
pitchfork are his main d***riders. man on a dud spree and they still gave jik 7+. like its listenable album or something
why did they give it a 0
There was not a second of enjoyable music on it, no cap
0/10 is a fair and good score for a professional journalist to give
holy s*** these critics barely talk about the album on they reviews 💀💀
Kanye coulda dropped College Dropout and these people would have still gave it a 0 talking about “yeah the songs are good but DID U SEE MARILYN MANSON SMHH F*** KANYE”
It's funny cause Ye tweeted Bill Cosby Innocent and TLOP still got a 9. It's definitely performative at this point and that's gross.
P4K probably giving him an 7 or so. They love d***riding Kanye, and they have a reputation of being contrarian.
they hate kanye ever since the maga era (deservedly so) so this getting a 6 at best from them
Hows it objectively better than tlop if i like tlop more
Bro said "objectively" like music isn't all subjective lmao
Why are all the reviews dissecting Kanye personality instead of actually about the album?
yeah maybe 10 years ago lmao
In the last ten years the lowest score they give a Kanye album was 7.1.
They gave that to ye and that album was legitimately ass.
independent.co.uk/author/roisin-oconnor
y this cr ackerman reviews a kanye album
they hate kanye ever since the maga era (deservedly so) so this getting a 6 at best from them
Even during all that the lowest score he got was 7.1
can't stand strong women...? What?
Is Kim Kardashian not an extremely widely known woman?
I know what you mean but 'extremely widely known woman' is so funny
'Misogynist? They do know his wife's a WOMAN right?'
Way I see it thi is that Manson should never have been involved, guy's a rapist who sucks, but saying the album's particularly misogynistic in content besides his presence doesn't really seem to be based on anything actually in the album
In the last ten years the lowest score they give a Kanye album was 7.1.
They gave that to ye and that album was legitimately ass.
welp they about to light his ass on fire now
Not that reviews matter but this would obviously have better reception if he didn’t feel the need to go out of his way to put horrible people on his album for no reason
Not sure why itt people are shocked just cause you don’t care about Manson doesn’t other people don’t
To be clear the 0 rating is wack but come on. You gotta take a step back and see how corny it looks if you’re not already a Kanye stan