Donda Chant N/A / 10
Jail 6/10
God Breathed on This 6/10
Off the Grid 9/10
Hurricane 9/10
Praise God 7/10
Jonah 8/10
Ok Ok 7/10
Junya 7.5/10
Believe What I Say 8/10
24 7/10
Remote 7/10
Moon 8/10
Heaven and Hell 10/10
Donda NA/10
KMSA 6/10
Jesus is Lord 8/10
New Again 7/10
Tell The Vision 3/10
Lord I Need You 7/10
Pure Souls 8/10
Come To Life 8/10
No Child Left Behind 7/10
Jail pt 2 7/10
Ok Ok pt 2 6/10
Junya pt 2 7/10
Jesus Lord pt2 7/10

Overall the album is a solid 7.5/10

Thank you for reading

Share your review ITT

KTT2 isn't going to like this one

10/10

10

Too early but my first impression is that the songs are great, the sequencing is a bit random but that might be the point. I'm not going to give a numerical ranking but It's a really good album.

Donda Chant - 5/10 as a song but it's a skit so whatever
Jail - 10/10
God Breathed - 8/10
Off The Grid - 10/10
Hurricane - 9/10
Praise God - 9/10
Jonah - 8/10
Ok Ok - 8/10
Junya - 9/10
BWIS - 11/10
24 - 9/10
Remote - 9/10
Moon - 10/10
H&H - 10/10
Donda - 6/10 bc no verses like why bro
KMSA - 8.5/10 i'm probably in the minority here but i liked the ye hook more
Jesus Lord - 11/10
TTV - 5/10 it's worse censored lmao
LINY - 10/10 beautiful taco bell kfc moment
Pure Souls - 11/10
CTL - 10/10
NCLB - 7/10 need the version with more ye from the vegas listening party

Overal: idk like an 8.5-9/10 kanye's the goat, this is easily his best work since AT LEAST tlop, yeezus stays on top tho

this. kinda like a tupac album

for me its TLOP level. above jik and ye, but below his immaculate first six albums

it has high highs but sometimes sputters around. just like TLOP. above average album, but it placed among the greatest disco of all time - of the greatest artist of all time - its good for 8th, or 7th tops.

thats no diss. its more about his first six than anything. Donda, for a dude this late in his career to put out a work like this, its simply incredible

So far it's sounding better than TLOP and Yeezus but it might just be because of the high from it releasing today.

9.5/10. Cut Pop Smoke track and it might be perfect. Its long yet it feels short Donda breathed on dis

it's his best album since 2016 on all fronts. i'd place those two in the same tier, but he did a way better job holding his own against all the features on TLOP than he did here

rapping leaves alot to be desired and the amount of tracks will def affect the replay value, but the music itself is good enough to make up for it somewhat. overall id prolly give it a 7/10

good album but sits comfortably in his bottom 3, only above ye and jik

Album is a 10

7-8/10 his best album in a minute

10

op what do you give Pablo/ye/jik jw

solid 8 or 9; can't even begin to think of how it compares with the rest of his discography but it's obviously leagues better than JIK and ye (I like both of them but lets be honest). this gives me the same feeling TLOP gives, and that's my second favorite kanye record. I gotta see how I feel in 2 months

not OP but I give

TLOP 10
ye 9.5
JIK 9

Jail 8/10
God Breathed on This 7/10
Off The Grid 10/10
Hurricane 9/10
Praise God 9/10
Jonah 8/10
OK OK 9/10
Junya 8/10
Believe What I Say 10/10
24 10/10
Remote 7/10
Moon 10/10
Heaven and Hell 8/10
KMSA 8/10
Jesus Lord 10/10
New Again 7/10
Pure Souls 10/10
Come To Life 10/10
NCLB 10/10

It's a 9/10 album

An honest review would be something like

It's a good album off first listen, not a day has passed yet even

We'll let it simmer for a while

It's a great album. Something unexpected after the last 2 efforts.

BRO this s*** blows his last 3 albums out the water. easy 8 for me and will bump this in the whip for sure. also come to life might be top 10 best ye song ever

i like it but y’all can’t rate an album in a day and have it be genuine. it’s like HOV said

Overall, best album since TLOP easily and one of Kanye’s top 3 potentially .
Solid 9/10 album

Donda Chant - N/A/10
Jail - 8/10
God Breathed 10/10
Off the Grid 10/10
Hurricane 8/10
Praise God 9/10
Jonah 8/10
Ok ok 8/10
Junya 8/10
Believe what I say 10/10
24 10/10
Remote Control 10/10
Moon 10/10
Heaven and Hell 10/10
Donda 9/10
KMSA 9/10
Jesus Lord 10/10
New Again 10/10
Tell the Vision 6/10
Lord I Need You 10/10
Pure Souls 10/10
Come to Life 10/10
NCLB 9/10

When are y'all gonna learn that numerical ratings never work

Album of Life/10

I give it a 7-7.5/10 off first impressions. It’s his best since TLOP (excluding KSG) by far, but i can’t help but feel like again, it was done at the last minute. If Ye was on it more I think I’d rate it higher. Some filler and forgettable tracks but the standouts are really really good. Jail and BWIS are almost too good for this album imho. Hearing it a few times from listening party rips kinda hurt my initial listening of the album too.