Iāll never willingly spin a song with any ai vocal whatsoever.
But theyāre different circumstances
That carti feature writer/ghostwriter still wrote and recorded the carti verse before his ai voice changer was put on it. The beat was still made by Pharrell. It has real weeknd writing and recording on it. It was structured weeknd and his team. Itās a real song with a dumbass ai carti feature
Fenix song was entirely ai generated. They typed in some prompts and this song was spat out.
Perhaps letting weeknd off the hook is part of the slippery slope and direction that lead to rubbers being a massive song but theyāre still different cases. I would judge someone a lot more for spinning rubberz than I would for spinning timeless
You canāt cherrypick whats okay and whats not though (i mean you can lol) but thats the whole thing with this AI debate lmao
until its an artist you (not you but the AI critical consumer) like, any AI use = soulless talentless hack who is trying to replace artist and it generally is assumed its all generative prompt to final product use
Lmao niggas wasnt splitting all these atoms for Timbaland but we gonna do it for Carti and Weeknd bc they still presumably have a lot of dope s*** left to make vs Timbo who been cold AI aside and post ādefconā Kanye
Lmao niggas wasnt tryna have no nuance at first
I donāt like the weeknd and Iāve never once put on the weeknd carti song. Who the hell are u people talking to itt! Brain broken people
Lmaooo what about Carti? š
& Im speaking in general to the premise that when Kanye was voice dubbing a year or two ago or Timbo generally just endorsing it, it was ābooo AI badā now niggas wanna split atoms for certain niggas or scenarios lmao
I said the same thing in the Chad Hugo Tierra Whack thread where niggas just glossed over them using Ai scenes for the Music Video vs niggas being completely ready to throw away Alchemist and Badu legacies for their AI cover art
Niggas cherry picking lol its either all or nothing. The actual answer is its hundreds of ways to use AI and the only thing that should be frowned upon is type prompt > generated material > straight to release (as opposed to it just being an asset in something larger you created) ; but niggas gotta wait for their fav to cosign that lol
Lmaooo what about Carti? š
& Im speaking in general to the premise that when Kanye was voice dubbing a year or two ago or Timbo generally just endorsing it, it was ābooo AI badā now niggas wanna split atoms for certain niggas or scenarios lmao
I said the same thing in the Chad Hugo Tierra Whack thread where niggas just glossed over them using Ai scenes for the Music Video vs niggas being completely ready to throw away Alchemist and Badu legacies for their AI cover art
Niggas cherry picking lol its either all or nothing. The actual answer is its hundreds of ways to use AI and the only thing that should be frowned upon is type prompt > generated material > straight to release (as opposed to it just being an asset in something larger you created) ; but niggas gotta wait for their fav to cosign that lol
I have absolutely no attachment to carti. Not one of my artists. Probably have less total listens on the last carti album than there is songs on it. Iām not sure if there have been ai carti defenders itt that youāre somehow attaching to me, but your words may be better placed with them.
In terms of throwing out whole artists legacies, thatās obviously dumb. I think we should dislike the ai things and like the non ai things if theyāre good.
I think one of the most disrespectful parts of the song no one ever mentions is that he threw in those adlibs like if he wanted to convince us a rapper made this himself
AI made that track, sureābut I still have ears. If a song sounds good, it sounds good. People judge music by how it makes them feel, not by whether a human or a model arranged the notes. āAI cookedā is just another way of saying the end result exceeded expectations.
Telling someone to āstfuā because they like a song is a weird substitute for having an actual opinion. If you think the song is trash, explain why. Was the flow bad? Were the lyrics weak? Was the production generic? Thatās a conversation. āStfuā is just admitting you donāt have an argument.
Music has always evolved with technology. People said synthesizers would ruin music. Then Auto-Tune. Then digital production. Now AI. Every generation acts like the newest tool is the apocalypse until it becomes normal. Whether AI ends up dominating or not, pretending good music canāt come from it is just closing your ears before you even hit play.
Iām not saying AI is replacing artists or that every AI song is amazing. Most of them are garbage. But every once in a while one actually slaps, and Iām not going to pretend otherwise just because it was made differently. I care about the output more than the process.
If your standard is āI refuse to enjoy this because AI touched it,ā thatās your choice. My standard is much simpler: does it sound good? If the answer is yes, Iām adding it to the playlist. I donāt need permission from the internet to enjoy a three-minute song.
So no, I wonāt āstfu.ā Iāll keep saying when something is fire, whether it was made with a guitar, a laptop, or an AI model. You donāt have to agree with my taste, but telling me to stop talking because you disagree is a lot less convincing than just making a better argument.
nah this mf funny as s***
The fact people heard his old songs and then this and defended this is still wild.
With that being said... And the grammy for the best music prompt goes to...
This is one of the rare cases where 85% of ppl were very stupid and didnāt believe this
Canāt believe there was any folk believing this wasnāt AI
He has confirmed that it is AI
f*** this lying b****
what a f***ing idiot
"No sirrrrr, recorded same as all music I do ā¼ļøā¼ļøā¼ļø Only difference Is auto tune reverb and me using my fake uk accent lol, "PLASTIC SMILES ON SUNSET BLVD" iykyk š¤£š¤£š¤£š¤£"
Shoreline mafia stans running that hater cope LOST
shoreline mafia stans is a terrifying concept of a sentence
has anyone reminded him he didn't record anything at all and that treblo made everything? he probably doesn't even remember by now since he's completely ed
anything that reminisces the 80s music or visuals imma just assume its AI from now on its literally the lowest hanging fruit and honestly you're dumb if you liked this even before the drama
anything that reminisces the 80s music or visuals imma just assume its AI from now on its literally the lowest hanging fruit and honestly you're dumb if you liked this even before the drama
they were in here talking about SONG OF THE SUMMER
LMAOOOOOOOOO