Thread was locked by
a moderator
  • Dec 23, 2021
    thegreatdivine

    I don't know how the man y'all call the GOAT can make that claim when he's been ducking putting in the work for almost 5 years now.

    In the time Kendrick has been away, Eminem has dropped 3 albums, 4 if you include the 16-track deluxe version of MTBMB:
    Revival (2017)
    Kamikaze (2018)
    Music to be Murdered By (2020)
    Music to be Murdered By (Deluxe) 2020
    And another album is allegedly dropping next year.

    In the same time, Nas has dropped:
    Nasir (2018)
    The Lost Tapes 2 (2019)
    King's Disease (2020)
    King's Disease 2 (2021)
    Magic (2021) Out Tonight

    How are you calling this man the greatest of a generation when he's not actively competing in what are the prime years of his career and his peers are putting in the work and even legends who are 12-15 years older than him are outdoing him in work ethic?

    Are we now rewarding laziness in rap/hip-hop?

    I remember you was conflicted

  • Dec 23, 2021

    Kendrick

  • Dec 23, 2021
    ·
    1 reply
    thegreatdivine

    I agree with the critical acclaim take and how no one was ever gonna give it a bad or even mixed review, especially considering when it dropped but it's also one of the greatest rap albums of all time so lol.

    So you think his process gave us one of the greatest rap albums of all time and yet you here complaining he's taking too long to drop another one

    Stfu and enjoy greatness

  • Dec 23, 2021

    A lot of text itt

  • Dec 23, 2021
    kenneth branagh

    the uncomfortable truth is Kendrick releasing an album deeply centered around race relations during a time of peak racial tension for the first time in social media era, with a backdrop of black music from funk to jazz to contemporary hip hop, is literally bulletproof to music criticism from "white" publications (Rolling stone/p4k/etc etc), you couldnt give it a bad review upon release,

    it's exactly what the journalists said in their retrospective one year later

    https://hiphopdx.com/news/id.37916/title.kendrick-lamars-to-pimp-a-butterfly-one-year-anniversary-celebrated-by-genius#

    Think imma put this somewhere in the top 10 worst posts ive seen on both sites

  • Dec 23, 2021
    Joe Jigga Biden

    I counted it since I counted stuff like collision course for jay

    But that wasn't a soundtrack album and it had Jay on every song lol.

  • math fifty

    Anyone saying "critic bait" is a racist im deadass serious

    It’s reverse psychology because they want to be entitled to great black art that surpasses them in a genre they look at as inferior

  • Dec 23, 2021
    Worldpremiere_

    Lets be honest man. We all know kendrick is gonna come with an amazing ass album. He literally changed into a completely different person since damn dropped. I think thats why he did that show encapsulating his entire career. Esp since he was clearly going thru some of his worst life experiences during the making of DAMN.

    he out here riding beach cruisers, meditating and doing psychedelics now bro. he aint that same kendrick. He got a lil daughter now. What im saying is, he took the time out to live life and grow after dropping like 7 classics. Thats what GOATS do

    Fair enough.

  • The amount of mental gymnastics and personal criteria's that y'all create, then try to push as the general consensus, all in order to justify your hate for a particular artist on this site is beyond ridiculous.

  • According to @kenneth_branagh and the handful of Black journalists stuck writing for white publications for a check they are referencing, Black artists are no longer allowed to make Black music that celebrates Blackness or references racism in America without it being "critic bait" because white critics are supposedly "not allowed" to say anything negative about it.

  • Dec 23, 2021
    ·
    1 reply
    vagabonds

    didn't even read the rest of the op as soon as i read the username

    i can already tell it's a "drake is the undisputed goat" thread in disguise lmk if im right

    She really don’t know s*** about music other than Drake’s discography and doesn’t even ride for his best work. I truly don’t get it but it’s okay.

  • GKMC and DAMN are just as acclaimed as TPAB.

  • Dec 23, 2021
    ·
    1 reply
    SignedTwice

    So you think his process gave us one of the greatest rap albums of all time and yet you here complaining he's taking too long to drop another one

    Stfu and enjoy greatness

    He dropped Section.80, GKMC and TPAB in a 5-year span. He doesn't need 5 years to make a good album lmao.

  • Dec 23, 2021
    ·
    1 reply
    vagabonds

    y'all are too far gone man

    he basically saying Kendrick hypnotised reviewers into giving him 10/10

  • Dec 23, 2021
    vagabonds

    didn't even read the rest of the op as soon as i read the username

    i can already tell it's a "drake is the undisputed goat" thread in disguise lmk if im right

  • Dec 23, 2021
    ·
    3 replies

    Problem with the discourse is that everyone has to be a GOAT, but if you narrow the definition of GOAT to what it should be then Kendrick's argument is weakened. Kendrick fans can lean on Eminem, Drake, J Cole etc. but if we're talking Greatest Of All Time his long break has to go against him

  • Dec 23, 2021
    ·
    1 reply

    quality not quantity

  • Dec 23, 2021
    DREAM OF FLY HIGH

    he basically saying Kendrick hypnotised reviewers into giving him 10/10

    cant make this s*** up

  • Dec 23, 2021
    Einfinet

    “ Doesn't matter how good or bad the albums are.”

    Lol

    Spoken like a true Drake groupie

  • Dec 23, 2021
    ·
    1 reply
    thegreatdivine

    He dropped Section.80, GKMC and TPAB in a 5-year span. He doesn't need 5 years to make a good album lmao.

    Artists aren't machines

  • Dec 23, 2021
    ·
    1 reply

    Quality over Quantity.

  • Dec 23, 2021
    Senior Intern

    Problem with the discourse is that everyone has to be a GOAT, but if you narrow the definition of GOAT to what it should be then Kendrick's argument is weakened. Kendrick fans can lean on Eminem, Drake, J Cole etc. but if we're talking Greatest Of All Time his long break has to go against him

    i don't get why his break goes against him

  • Dec 23, 2021
    Senior Intern

    Problem with the discourse is that everyone has to be a GOAT, but if you narrow the definition of GOAT to what it should be then Kendrick's argument is weakened. Kendrick fans can lean on Eminem, Drake, J Cole etc. but if we're talking Greatest Of All Time his long break has to go against him

    naahh man. It really doesnt. in a current top 5, work ethic matters. But in terms of actual GOAT ? Only ur albums matter.

    i cant say d angelo is mid just cause he only dropped 3 albums

  • Dec 23, 2021

    GKMC and TPAB are still two of the best rap albums of all time, no matter how much whining on ktt2 you do!!!!

  • Dec 23, 2021
    Senior Intern

    Problem with the discourse is that everyone has to be a GOAT, but if you narrow the definition of GOAT to what it should be then Kendrick's argument is weakened. Kendrick fans can lean on Eminem, Drake, J Cole etc. but if we're talking Greatest Of All Time his long break has to go against him

    Can you elaborate on last part lol

1
...
11
12
13
...
52
Thread was locked by
a moderator