Both released s*** debuts — Mac improved a ton and hopefully Jack will too.

Jack will never reach the level of Mac respectfully

Y’all need to stop with that

I mean this isn't true

That's What They All Say was not s***.

Blue Slide Park really not that bad either, just corny frat rap.

crazy how it’s almost been a year since his last album and first class came out lmao

tbh hes prob just not that smart of a guy where he knows how to extrapolate this to something "deep" or structural i give him credit for at least trying to do something "challenging" vs just making generic agnostic pop music, which he could have chosen to do instead

The verdict is in: recycle bin classic

Mac is an influence, Jack wears influences on his sleeve

that’s the difference here

they dont love it

There are no bad songs on this album. Wow

ambitious

Most sensible take

regardless of your thoughts its hard to argue that this isnt better than his last output

jackers we won and we back

BSP was like a side detour from the real type of music Mac was making though, something no one ever mentions and seems to have been mostly memoryholed in music discussion circles

BSP was 2011 and was a moment in his career...he wasn't a frat rapper, he took a detour to do frat rap when he signed to a label.
by the time, BSP came out the already had KIDS, BDE, and I Love Life released, all of which were completely different and are far more in line with what people consider "good" music from him (KIDS especially, since the others were like half and half). Macadelic was then less than 6 months after BSP.

If anything BSP & the "frat rap" half of BDE were a detour from his career and not something he grew out of.

i know the reception got some in here upset

Jacks debut was great now that I look back at it

It Can't Be is literally a white boy anthem

when racist twitter gets ahold of this one it's over

cant listen to ggg i got a homie named kevin and i cant help but think he cookin him

the jokes write themselves on this one

I wasnt looking for creativity. Just an interesting story and jack delivered that and ended it with a beautiful conclusion

he needs to never try and do pop rap ever aagain

russ is so obnoxious man

song fire though

Come over and we can listen to that one together

i'm sorry i'm not buying this middling over correction of an album

This is what most of his music is like