Em would probably say Hov too

Hov, better discog.

Classics:

Eminem:
Sslp
Mmlp
Tes

Good albums:

Relapse
8 mile

Average to horrendous:
Encore
Mmlp2
Kamikaze
Mtbmb
Recovery
Revival

Anecdote: best verses in hip hop history(renegade) and most successful rap artist of all time. Also never lost a beef.

Jay-Z:

Classics:
Rd
Bp
Tba

Good albums
4:44
American Gangster

Average to bad:
That one with Beyoncé
Vol.1-3
Blueprint 2-3
Kingdom Come

Anecdote: Eminem has the best verses in his discography and he lost a beef to nas.

Jay-Z has way more longevity but eminem had a much higher peak. All personal preference.

Jay cause he listenable

He always lists Biggie Pac and often Nas above him but not Hov

Anyway the answer is Hov easily

Eminem ofc

Hov,because he is the only rapper that has aged like fine wine

Em fell out of my goat list

Hov is the GOAT

Hov the best of all time

Em the best of all time to whites

Obviously Hov

Marshall Garvey Hendrix ofc

Hov is lowkey trash he just stayed relevant

Jay z

Eminem doesn't crack my top 5

HOV but Em ain't too far behind

If you pick em i already know what you look and act like and I'm not a fan

Em not even top 50-100. It’s unacceptable to leave Hov out of any top ten

I would add Devil's Night to Em's good albums list, he carried that project. And also the BME EP.

I would also add WTT and 4:44 to Jay's classics, and that Jay E trash to his bad albums since that s*** was obvioulsy a collabo album.

Em btw, but Jay is my nº2

I deemed my white friend racist because he kept saying Eminem lol