Thread was locked by
a moderator
  • Oct 24, 2023

    5 albums in the top 20

  • Oct 24, 2023
    ·
    1 reply
    shaleirose

    I never said it wasn’t?

    The initial question was whether Graduation belongs in the tier with GRODT or the tier with Views & Carter 3.
    It’s pretty obvious to me that it belongs in the former category

    It fits with Views and Carter 3 to me, but to each their own

  • Oct 24, 2023
    ·
    1 reply
    Mmm Hmm

    If Drake been selling 500k+ since he started idk why'd u think that shouldn't be the expectation for him

    It's ridiculous to have those expectations for him 15 years into his career when he's closer to the end of his career than the beginning of it.

  • Oct 24, 2023

    from 13 weeks at #1 to 1

  • Oct 24, 2023

    Some of you guys are too much

  • Oct 24, 2023
    Elemental

    Yeah I know it’ll do well because of pure overall. I’m more focused on the streaming aspect of the album tho because it seems like hardly any albums have held up streaming wise this year. Only albums that have had some real longevity are that peso pluma and morgan wallen albums that I can think of

    My current projection is 350-400M US streams.

  • Mmm Hmm 😆
    Oct 24, 2023
    ·
    1 reply
    thegreatdivine

    It's ridiculous to have those expectations for him 15 years into his career when he's closer to the end of his career than the beginning of it.

    How is it unrealistic

    When he keeps selling that well consistently

    He's the only anomaly

    Even the fans like you always project he will do insane numbers everytime

  • Oct 24, 2023
    ·
    2 replies
    Mmm Hmm

    If Drake been selling 500k+ since he started idk why'd u think that shouldn't be the expectation for him

    Doesn’t really seem that achievable in the streaming era anymore unless you have months worth of preorders

  • Oct 24, 2023
    ·
    2 replies
    Vibe

    It fits with Views and Carter 3 to me, but to each their own

    I don’t see how at all lmao

    One has a handful of mega-singles and is regarded as one of the greatest rap albums of all time, just like GRODT

    The other two are high selling classics with maybe 1 or 2 smash singles on each

  • Oct 24, 2023
    ·
    1 reply
    shaleirose

    I don’t see how at all lmao

    One has a handful of mega-singles and is regarded as one of the greatest rap albums of all time, just like GRODT

    The other two are high selling classics with maybe 1 or 2 smash singles on each

    Graduation is not at GRODT level and Views has the same reach

  • Oct 24, 2023
    shaleirose

    I don’t see how at all lmao

    One has a handful of mega-singles and is regarded as one of the greatest rap albums of all time, just like GRODT

    The other two are high selling classics with maybe 1 or 2 smash singles on each

    It's just the brain damaged drake stans

  • Oct 24, 2023
    ·
    1 reply
    Vibe

    Graduation is not at GRODT level and Views has the same reach

    How is Graduation not on GRODT level lmao

    On every metric it’s performed better longevity wise.

    It has just as many huge singles as GRODT does.

    And the critical/fan reception was just as good if not better.

    I just don’t see at all how you think that those two albums are on different levels of status

  • Mmm Hmm 😆
    Oct 24, 2023
    ·
    1 reply
    Elemental

    Doesn’t really seem that achievable in the streaming era anymore unless you have months worth of preorders

    Drake sold like 600k with clb (2021)

    And her loss did 400k and it's a Collab (2022)

    Dogs just did 400k as well (2023)

    He dropped bout 200k since his last solo but people were waiting for clb for awhile.

    His next solo will either do 400k again or 500k if he comes with a hit

  • Oct 24, 2023
    ·
    1 reply
    shaleirose

    How is Graduation not on GRODT level lmao

    On every metric it’s performed better longevity wise.

    It has just as many huge singles as GRODT does.

    And the critical/fan reception was just as good if not better.

    I just don’t see at all how you think that those two albums are on different levels of status

    Graduation was not operating on the same playing field as GRODT in 2003. The difference between them is staggering

  • Oct 24, 2023
    ·
    1 reply
    Mmm Hmm

    How is it unrealistic

    When he keeps selling that well consistently

    He's the only anomaly

    Even the fans like you always project he will do insane numbers everytime

    It's ridiculous when he's still having the biggest album debuts 15 years in and some people here jump in to call it a flop, an underperformance, etc. Him and Eminem are the two rap anomalies when it comes to commercial performance. No one else has their longevity in that regard.

    Still, he's at the point in his career where people should be appreciating that he's still putting up massive numbers, not criticizing his numbers (that are bigger than everyone else's btw) and nitpicking at how/why it isn't bigger.

    Him and Taylor Swift are the upper-echelon elite of their generation with regards to commercial performance. They've outdone every single one of their peers and are now only in competition with legends and all-time records. I don't compare them with anyone else, that's for sure.

  • Oct 24, 2023
    Elemental

    Doesn’t really seem that achievable in the streaming era anymore unless you have months worth of preorders

    His numbers are crazier because they're like 95% streaming.

  • Elemental

    If everyone keeps underperforming streaming wise does that mean we got to start lowering the expectations? Like maybe these type of numbers will just be the new norm going forward

    bundle merchants like trav/taylor and the way the numbers are presented makes it harder than it looks to separate the expectations

    but they should be lowered but you know how people get

  • Oct 24, 2023
    ·
    1 reply
    Vibe

    Graduation was not operating on the same playing field as GRODT in 2003. The difference between them is staggering

    Graduation released 9 years before streaming and is currently #49 in Top Streaming Albums on Billboard and is also the 20th highest streamed rap album of all time on Spotify, ahead of GRODT.

    Gradutaion is also currently #62 on the Billboard 200, in its’ 268th week on the chart. GRODT is #172 on the same chart, in its’ 195th week.

    If GRODT is actually the bigger album, why has it not done better numbers in the streaming era?

  • Oct 24, 2023
    ·
    1 reply
    shaleirose

    Graduation released 9 years before streaming and is currently #49 in Top Streaming Albums on Billboard and is also the 20th highest streamed rap album of all time on Spotify, ahead of GRODT.

    Gradutaion is also currently #62 on the Billboard 200, in its’ 268th week on the chart. GRODT is #172 on the same chart, in its’ 195th week.

    If GRODT is actually the bigger album, why has it not done better numbers in the streaming era?

    Because Kanye continued his career after 2007 and appeals to the younger generation

    What does Thriller stream in this day and age? Grad is bigger than Thriller because of that?

  • Mmm Hmm 😆
    Oct 24, 2023
    ·
    1 reply
    thegreatdivine

    It's ridiculous when he's still having the biggest album debuts 15 years in and some people here jump in to call it a flop, an underperformance, etc. Him and Eminem are the two rap anomalies when it comes to commercial performance. No one else has their longevity in that regard.

    Still, he's at the point in his career where people should be appreciating that he's still putting up massive numbers, not criticizing his numbers (that are bigger than everyone else's btw) and nitpicking at how/why it isn't bigger.

    Him and Taylor Swift are the upper-echelon elite of their generation with regards to commercial performance. They've outdone every single one of their peers and are now only in competition with legends and all-time records. I don't compare them with anyone else, that's for sure.

    The thing with Drake is

    He's built up so much of a rep where he will always get play no matter what as long as the music isn't mysterious or massively different like HNVM or demo tapes was.

    His core regardless

    He will always sell above 300k
    Even when he puts out horrible singles like way 2 sexy clb came thru with 600k

    Even a very divisive single like slime
    Got him 400k

    Drake doesn't really need a smash anymore because he's Drake

    As long as he puts out jack of all trades music he will stay in his anomaly bag

    I wouldn't put em with Drake at all

    Em selling less than 300k and that was in 2020

    He's not hitting 300k + anymore unless he has a certified smash

    But prob has a guaranteed 150k fanbase

  • Oct 24, 2023
    ·
    1 reply
    Vibe

    Because Kanye continued his career after 2007 and appeals to the younger generation

    What does Thriller stream in this day and age? Grad is bigger than Thriller because of that?

    Thriller is currently #81 on the Billboard 200, 19 spots behind Graduation and 91 spots ahead of GRODT.

    Graduation is the 91st highest streamed album ever on Spotify, with 4.7 billion streams.

    GRODT is the 136th highest streamed album ever on Spotify, with 3.980 billion streams.

    And Thriller, which came out 41 years ago, is the 139th highest streamed album ever on Spotify, with 3.948 billion streams.

    Which leads me back to my original point, of Graduation, by every conceivable metric, being the closest thing we have to a Thriller in rap music.

  • Oct 24, 2023
    ·
    1 reply
    Mmm Hmm

    Drake sold like 600k with clb (2021)

    And her loss did 400k and it's a Collab (2022)

    Dogs just did 400k as well (2023)

    He dropped bout 200k since his last solo but people were waiting for clb for awhile.

    His next solo will either do 400k again or 500k if he comes with a hit

    Maybe, but i’m not expecting him to do 500k+ with streaming only ever again. The music industry is volatile asf, times have changed a lot since 2021. Even before FATD dropped I knew the album was gonna do Her Loss numbers just basing it off how the music climate has been this year

  • Oct 24, 2023
    ·
    1 reply
    shaleirose

    Thriller is currently #81 on the Billboard 200, 19 spots behind Graduation and 91 spots ahead of GRODT.

    Graduation is the 91st highest streamed album ever on Spotify, with 4.7 billion streams.

    GRODT is the 136th highest streamed album ever on Spotify, with 3.980 billion streams.

    And Thriller, which came out 41 years ago, is the 139th highest streamed album ever on Spotify, with 3.948 billion streams.

    Which leads me back to my original point, of Graduation, by every conceivable metric, being the closest thing we have to a Thriller in rap music.

    GRODT and Thriller streaming this closely to Grad just shows the power that they have, being that Kanye has had more time to continue his career in this day and age and further establish relevance

  • CKL TML 🌺
    Oct 24, 2023
    ·
    1 reply
    shaleirose

    Please name me the 4 huge singles on Views.

    Hotling Bling
    One Dance
    Controlla
    Too Good

  • Oct 24, 2023
    ·
    2 replies
    CKL TML

    Hotling Bling
    One Dance
    Controlla
    Too Good

    Hotline Bling is a bonus song that was released a year before the album came out, but sure.

    One Dance, yes.

    Controlla is big but not on the level of any of the four big singles from Graduation.

    And Too Good absolutely not.

Thread was locked by
a moderator