Thread was locked by
a moderator
  • Oct 31, 2024
    Allen Iverson

    Cole has never been on Drake or Kendrick level in any way but perception. Surely not commercially. It's not worth going back and forth about. It hasn't been close.

    Defo just trolling, i respect i

  • Oct 31, 2024
    ·
    1 reply
    Ghetto Lenny

    285k now.

    @fader see what I mean, 145k just with vinyl/cd bundles. I doubt HUT hits that. Then 145k from streaming in 4 days. With a full 7 days he woulda done at least 180k. HUT probably isn't reaching those streaming numbers either. we'll see though
    got a feeling HUT is gonna be like 22 songs

  • Oct 31, 2024
    ·
    1 reply

    Tyler selling 145k vinyls/cds is crazy impressive considering Trav sold 142k of them, Trav is/was seen as "that guy", but Tyler outselling is wild

    Tyler's merch in the bundles is f***ing ugly as hell too whilst Travis's was actually nice

  • Oct 31, 2024
    ·
    1 reply
    mangotflu

    HUH? You've said countless times on here that THe Weeknd has grown a lot since AH. Now you're saying he's past his prime? HUH

    So are you also saying Travis is past his commercial prime then?

    It's bullshit to me cause even the newer artists aren't touching any of those 2018~ numbers. Streaming numbers have only grown for 10+ year old music, anything else and s***s tragic.

    You don't think anything could have happened between 2018 and 2024 that damaged Travis' commercial appeal?

  • Oct 31, 2024
    rip armani x

    You don't think anything could have happened between 2018 and 2024 that damaged Travis' commercial appeal?

    That definitely damaged it but I'd honestly still say Trav has grown since Astroworld was released personally, at least a bit

  • Oct 31, 2024
    ·
    1 reply
    mangotflu

    Tyler selling 145k vinyls/cds is crazy impressive considering Trav sold 142k of them, Trav is/was seen as "that guy", but Tyler outselling is wild

    Tyler's merch in the bundles is f***ing ugly as hell too whilst Travis's was actually nice

    Huh? Utopia did 250K in pure sales first week.

    And without shipping delays, it would’ve cleared 738K total first week, meaning the first week sales number would’ve been 492K if everything shipped on time

  • Oct 31, 2024
    ·
    2 replies
    mangotflu

    @fader see what I mean, 145k just with vinyl/cd bundles. I doubt HUT hits that. Then 145k from streaming in 4 days. With a full 7 days he woulda done at least 180k. HUT probably isn't reaching those streaming numbers either. we'll see though
    got a feeling HUT is gonna be like 22 songs

    HUT is definitely reaching this lmao

  • Oct 31, 2024
    TheFader

    Huh? Utopia did 250K in pure sales first week.

    And without shipping delays, it would’ve cleared 738K total first week, meaning the first week sales number would’ve been 492K if everything shipped on time

    250k in pure but 110k of that was digitals, he only did 240k bundles, less than tyler

  • Oct 31, 2024
    TheFader

    HUT is definitely reaching this lmao

    AH didn't even reach those streaming numbers lol, we'll see tho

  • Oct 31, 2024
    ·
    1 reply
    TheFader

    HUT is definitely reaching this lmao

    Stop setting Abel up

  • Oct 31, 2024
    ·
    1 reply
    jack johnson

    Stop setting Abel up

    I’m not setting him up, but I’m also not a delusional hater

  • Oct 31, 2024
    ·
    1 reply
    TheFader

    I’m not setting him up, but I’m also not a delusional hater

    In the US, hip hop has more dedicated listeners/fans than pop artists currently. Pop has more casual listeners, especially male pop singers

    (I'm talking about acts like Tyler The Creator, Travis and Carti not random rappers)

    And Tyler is at his peak currently.

    I don't think HUT will be bigger than this Tyler album in the US...

  • Oct 31, 2024
    ·
    edited
    ·
    2 replies
    jack johnson

    In the US, hip hop has more dedicated listeners/fans than pop artists currently. Pop has more casual listeners, especially male pop singers

    (I'm talking about acts like Tyler The Creator, Travis and Carti not random rappers)

    And Tyler is at his peak currently.

    I don't think HUT will be bigger than this Tyler album in the US...

    This couldn’t be further from the truth. As far as new albums go, pop has been absolutely demolishing rap this year.

    There really hasn’t been many huge mainstream rap albums this year (last year as well).

    Among the highest selling albums this year, there are only four rap albums in the Top 30. We Don’t Trust You, For All the Dogs, Utopia, and American Dream. Two of those released last year.

  • Oct 31, 2024
    ·
    1 reply
    TheFader

    This couldn’t be further from the truth. As far as new albums go, pop has been absolutely demolishing rap this year.

    There really hasn’t been many huge mainstream rap albums this year (last year as well).

    Among the highest selling albums this year, there are only four rap albums in the Top 30. We Don’t Trust You, For All the Dogs, Utopia, and American Dream. Two of those released last year.

    Hip hops acts like Drake, Tyler, Travis and even Carti get more attention in the first week than most pop acts

    In the long run, it's a different story

  • Oct 31, 2024
    jack johnson

    Hip hops acts like Drake, Tyler, Travis and even Carti get more attention in the first week than most pop acts

    In the long run, it's a different story

    I agree with this. I’ve said this for years, that’s why Gunna ended up outselling Dawn FM.

    I’m just saying I think HUT will very easily surpass 140K in streaming units (which is what Tyler is estimated to get)

  • Oct 31, 2024
    ·
    2 replies
    TheFader

    DAMN. did 603K. Cole has never come anywhere near that.

    490k is very close to 600k though …

  • Oct 31, 2024
    ·
    1 reply
    TheFader

    This couldn’t be further from the truth. As far as new albums go, pop has been absolutely demolishing rap this year.

    There really hasn’t been many huge mainstream rap albums this year (last year as well).

    Among the highest selling albums this year, there are only four rap albums in the Top 30. We Don’t Trust You, For All the Dogs, Utopia, and American Dream. Two of those released last year.

    This isn't true at all lol, there has been no demolishing when it comes to DEDICATED fans, the people who listen first week, people who take weeks/months to listen to songs/albums are casuals, like no s*** pop music is gonna do better longterm than rap

    We Don't Trust You did 245k streaming sales first week, no pop artist has come close to that except Taylor

    even this Tyler album is set to outstream Billie & Ariana's albums with only 4 days

  • SWAN 💜
    Oct 31, 2024

    pop is dead as far as hype goes but it’s somehow very alive on the charts

  • Oct 31, 2024

    Damn so Tyler sold more than Eminem, good for him, lol.

  • Oct 31, 2024
    Ghetto Lenny

    285k now.

    congrats to Tyler but bundle game going crazy out here huh, especially the Halsey numbers

    dont hate the player, hate the game - at the same time this shows the incredible support from their fan base, which is why Taylor is at the top of the game

  • Oct 31, 2024
    ·
    1 reply
    mangotflu

    This isn't true at all lol, there has been no demolishing when it comes to DEDICATED fans, the people who listen first week, people who take weeks/months to listen to songs/albums are casuals, like no s*** pop music is gonna do better longterm than rap

    We Don't Trust You did 245k streaming sales first week, no pop artist has come close to that except Taylor

    even this Tyler album is set to outstream Billie & Ariana's albums with only 4 days

    If all you care about is first week sales, which it seems like you do, then I guess.

    But pop music has been completely commercially wiping rap music in the mainstream for the past two years

  • Oct 31, 2024
    ·
    1 reply
    mfp93

    490k is very close to 600k though …

    "very close" lol

    490k to 600k isn't "very" close. 580k would be very close to 600k

  • Oct 31, 2024
    mov

    "very close" lol

    490k to 600k isn't "very" close. 580k would be very close to 600k

    The person was trying to compare the off season numbers to damn , so I had to remind him Cole was close to 600k . I hear you but there’s context

  • Oct 31, 2024
    ·
    1 reply
    TheFader

    If all you care about is first week sales, which it seems like you do, then I guess.

    But pop music has been completely commercially wiping rap music in the mainstream for the past two years

    Globally you mean? because that definitely isn't the case in the US

    Even Future & Metro's first collab album is doing as well as Billie's album and better than Ariana's album

  • Oct 31, 2024
    ·
    1 reply
    mangotflu

    Globally you mean? because that definitely isn't the case in the US

    Even Future & Metro's first collab album is doing as well as Billie's album and better than Ariana's album

    Out of the top 30 best selling albums in the US this year, there are only four rap albums.

    We Don’t Trust You
    For All the Dogs
    Utopia
    American Dream

    Two of them released last year.

Thread was locked by
a moderator