Thread was locked by
a moderator
  • Oct 12, 2025

    All we saying is that Taylor doesn’t come close to the record without variants, which is an objective truth. Idk why niggas are pushing back so hard against that

  • Oct 12, 2025
    ·
    1 reply
    TheFader

    To the same extent as Taylor? No.

    Releasing three versions of your album and releasing 34 versions of your album are not the same thing whatsoever

    yes they do this is just blatant lying lmao. olivia, sabrina, gracie, gaga charli definitely do it. care whenever it suits your narrative i guess

  • Oct 12, 2025
    halleys comet

    yes they do this is just blatant lying lmao. olivia, sabrina, gracie, gaga charli definitely do it. care whenever it suits your narrative i guess

    None of them released 34 versions of the same album in its opening week. Sorry, but that’s just not something that happened.

  • Oct 12, 2025

    @jakura source it

  • Mafia Boss

    you dumb af if you think viet has that pull. So many drake fans have been banned.

    They got banned because what they did was egregious

    And regardless most of them literally just came back not even a couple weeks ago

  • Oct 12, 2025
    ·
    1 reply
    Mafia Boss

    How many variants do you think would be a fair equivalence?

    The equivalence isn’t between amount of variants dropped really. T swift has the same amount of variations for TTPD and Showgirl, the only difference is that she is even bigger now and gained even more fans after finishing her tour last year, hence more people buying her stuffs.

    I’m sure other popgirls have similar amount of variants but they’re just not selling because they’re not as big.

  • Oct 12, 2025

    swift cracking 4M w this trash ass album has me on the floor man what are white girls

  • Oct 12, 2025

    ngl she might be the greatest scammer of all time, this is some cult like scamming on a scientology typa bullshit timing

  • Oct 12, 2025

    them girls don’t even know it, they truly think that buying that 15th special edition of a song where swift talks abt getting d*** from kelce is a must buy

  • Oct 12, 2025
    ·
    1 reply
    kasich2028

    The equivalence isn’t between amount of variants dropped really. T swift has the same amount of variations for TTPD and Showgirl, the only difference is that she is even bigger now and gained even more fans after finishing her tour last year, hence more people buying her stuffs.

    I’m sure other popgirls have similar amount of variants but they’re just not selling because they’re not as big.

    She never clears 2M+ without variants.

  • Oct 12, 2025
    ·
    edited
    ·
    2 replies
    TheFader

    To the same extent as Taylor? No.

    Releasing three versions of your album and releasing 34 versions of your album are not the same thing whatsoever

    Other pop girls literally do have 30+ variants too, and most of t swift’s variants are iTunes ones.

    It doesn’t even matter though, cus again - the fact that she can make this record possible at all (through variants) when pure sales is dead, is props to her and her fandom size. It’s the ultimate demonstration of the scale and power of her stardom, it’s not something to diss.

    this is the mindset swift fans need to adopt.

  • Oct 12, 2025
    Mafia Boss

    thats just the vinyls 😭

    https://twitter.com/PopClocked/status/1975636209730019659

    she f***ed up the game
    even as a numbers guy i dont care anymore

  • Oct 12, 2025
    ·
    1 reply

    Global debut:

    “25” — 5,7 million

    “The Life of a Showgirl” — 5,3 million

  • Oct 12, 2025
    ·
    1 reply
  • Oct 12, 2025
    halleys comet

    yikes you didnt even respond to my last post lol. keep moving the goal posts though

    should she had removed her album from streaming platforms for months, would that had been a good equivalent for you? wouldve been the same metric for the Adele comparisons

    I'm not moving any goal posts and you can't compare Taylor Swift using the same tactics as artists who aren't 1/20 as big as she is. She has a much bigger fanbase than all her female counterparts so it makes sense when they resort to borderline unscrupulous tactics to boost their first week numbers. They actually need to do that to gain leverage with their labels.

    Taylor is already the biggest artist in the world. She doesn't need to do any of that but she does it anyways.

    What she's doing is the equivalent of the Beatles scoring #1 hits like candy (during their 7-year run when they scored 20 #1 hits on the Hot 100, a record that still hasn't been broken 6 decades later) while the entire industry could barely get a #1 and still abusing every loophole so they could be even more successful. It's unnecessary, pathetic and will always get called out because she's like I said, the biggest artist in the world so when she does s*** like that, it's even more obvious.

  • Oct 12, 2025

    big WIN ☺️

  • Oct 12, 2025
  • Oct 12, 2025
    ·
    1 reply

    So what’s her first week numbers if u remove physicals

  • Oct 12, 2025
    ·
    1 reply
    kasich2028
    · edited

    Other pop girls literally do have 30+ variants too, and most of t swift’s variants are iTunes ones.

    It doesn’t even matter though, cus again - the fact that she can make this record possible at all (through variants) when pure sales is dead, is props to her and her fandom size. It’s the ultimate demonstration of the scale and power of her stardom, it’s not something to diss.

    this is the mindset swift fans need to adopt.

    No they did not

    Y’all keep saying this with no source or proof whatsoever.

    You can’t show another artist (except for Cardi) that released 30+ versions of a new album WITHIN ITS OPENING WEEK.

  • Oct 12, 2025
    ·
    1 reply
    burymeinecko

    So what’s her first week numbers if u remove physicals

    500K

  • Oct 12, 2025

  • Oct 12, 2025
    ·
    1 reply
    jack johnson

    Global debut:

    “25” — 5,7 million

    “The Life of a Showgirl” — 5,3 million

    Imagine having to release 34 versions and still falling short of the global record

  • Oct 12, 2025
    TheFader

    500K

  • Oct 12, 2025

    had to double check the numbers what the f***?

  • Oct 12, 2025
    thegreatdivine
    https://twitter.com/chartdata/status/1977461136938197156
Thread was locked by
a moderator