Kanye West - My Beautiful Dark Twisted Fantasy

VOTE HERE
VOTE HERE
VOTE HERE
VOTE HERE
VOTE HERE

Official Reviews Thread:
ktt2.com/shoud-ya-boy-bring-back-kttcritic-64373

113 people responded to the thread with detailed reviews of the album. I would like to thank everyone that answered the response questions; your participation is much appreciated.

Overall Rating of My Beautiful Dark Twisted Fantasy - 1091/1130

That was good for an average of 97/100, which indicates Universal acclaim.

Expectations:

109 out of the 113 reviews (96.46%) said that the album met or exceeded expectations.

Overall Production Rating:

The total score for production was 1102.5/1130

The average score was 98/100

Overall Lyrical Performance:

The total score for lyrical-performance was 1062/1130

The average score was 94/100

Overall Microphone/Vocal Performance:

The total score was 1078.5/1130

The average score was 95/100

FAVORITE TRACK ON THE ALBUM

The most common response for favorite track was Devil in a New Dress with 29 votes. Second was Runaway with 28 votes, and third was Gorgeous with 16 votes.

LEAST FAVORITE TRACK ON THE ALBUM

The most common response for least favorite track was Blame Game with 34 votes. Second was Hell of a Life with 18 votes, and third was So Appalled with 15 votes.

FAVORITE GUEST ON THE ALBUM
The most common response for favorite guest was Rick Ross with 37 votes. Second was Pusha T with 29 votes.

Is the album in your Top 1/5/10 list of best Hip-Hop albums of all-time?

49 of 113 respondents thought the album was the greatest hip-hop album, or about 49.36%.
34 of 113 respondents said that the album was in their top 5.
17 of 113 respondents said that the album was in their top 10.

"I want to collect reviews from KTT members and calculate a consensus for the feelings and reactions towards to the album. I will score the album and show results after 30 or more responses come through."

Once we get a good number of reviews in they will be averaged and scored. Serious inquiries please.

Guidelines:

• There will be a GoogleForms link for each review. Use that to answer the questions. THE ANSWERS YOU POST IN THIS THREAD WILL NOT COUNT TOWARDS THE SCORE.
• Trolls will be ignored.

POST YOUR ANSWERS HERE:
forms.gle/447szZGBvczo3naz9
forms.gle/447szZGBvczo3naz9
forms.gle/447szZGBvczo3naz9
forms.gle/447szZGBvczo3naz9
forms.gle/447szZGBvczo3naz9

Final Rating? (1-10)
Did the album meet your expectations? (Yes/No)
Rate the album's production (1-10)
Rate the album's lyrics/songwriting (1-10)
Rate the rapper's microphone/vocal performance on the album (1-10)
Favorite track?
Least favorite track?
Favorite guest artist?
Is MBDTF in your Top 1/5/10 list of best Rap albums OAT? (1/5/10/No)

10
Yes
10
9.5
10
Devil in a New Dress
Monster
Rick Ross
Top 5

legendary album

Should’ve been able to skip “worst song” for this one tbh

Also should have had option for greatest album of any genre of all time

10
Yes
10
10
9
DIAND
So Appalled
Nicki
Top 5

Final Rating? (1-10) 10
Did the album meet your expectations? (Yes/No) Yes
Rate the album's production (1-10) 10
Rate the album's lyrics/songwriting (1-10) 9
Rate the rapper's microphone/vocal performance on the album (1-10) 10
Favorite track? All of the Lights
Least favorite track? Hell of a Life
Favorite guest artist? So close between Nicki & Ricky. Nicki
Is MBDTF in your Top 1/5/10 list of best Rap albums OAT? (1/5/10/No) #1

done

so appalled* not appauled

voted

Final rating 10/10
Met my expectations
Production 10
Lyrics 10
Vocal performance 10
Fav song: Runaway
Least fav: Blame Game
Fav guest: Bon Iver
Top 5 rap album OAT

if this was on it it would be 11/10

Perfect scores in every category the hardest part was having to pick a “least favorite song” cause they’re all 10s

10s across the board

bump

@op youre legally required to expose anyone who votes “no” to the last question

quite a few no's so far smh

10
Yes
10
9.5
10
Best track is Runaway but my fav is Dark Fantasy
Least fav So Appalled
Bon Iver
Best hip hop album OAT. Top 10 album ever

10/10 everything

I love these

Just made me realize how 10/10 the album is

Prod & lyrics 10/10

Only thing I think held it back is some of the features

Best verse: rick Ross
Fav song: it was between AOTL, DIAND, & HOAL.......I picked AOTL

bump

which features?

Tbh gorgeous is my least fav track
I don’t like the beat and I don’t like Cudis part cuz he just uses the melody of the beat

But I also don’t like some of the features on so appalled it’s another one I don’t usually listen to.

Rest of album is amazing