Reply
  • Updated Sep 13, 2020

    Kendrick Lamar - Good Kid, M.A.A.D City

    VOTE HERE
    VOTE HERE
    VOTE HERE
    VOTE HERE
    VOTE HERE

    Official Reviews Thread:
    ktt2.com/shoud-ya-boy-bring-back-kttcritic-64373


    67 people responded to the thread with detailed reviews of the album.

    Overall Rating of Good Kid, M.A.A.D City - 617.5/670

    That was good for an average of 92/100, which indicates Universal acclaim.
    Most common response rating was 10

    Expectations:

    63 out of the 67 reviews (94.03%) said that the album met or exceeded expectations.

    Overall Production Rating:

    The total score for production was 598.5/670

    The average score was 89/100
    Most common response rating was 10

    Overall Lyrical Performance:

    The total score for lyrical-performance was 634.5/670

    The average score was 95/100
    Most common response rating was 10

    Overall Microphone/Vocal Performance:

    The total score was 624/670

    The average score was 93/100
    Most common response rating was 10

    FAVORITE TRACK ON THE ALBUM

    The most common response for favorite track was Money Trees with 25 votes. Second was Sing About Me, I'm Dying of Thirst with 20 votes.

    LEAST FAVORITE TRACK ON THE ALBUM

    The most common response for least favorite track was Real with 38 votes. Second was Compton with 8 votes. Third was Swimming Pools (Drank) with 7 votes.

    FAVORITE GUEST ON THE ALBUM

    The most common response for favorite guest was Jay Rock with 43 votes. Second was Drake with 13 votes.

    LEAST FAVORITE GUEST ON THE ALBUM

    The most common response for least favorite guest was Dr Dre with 22 votes. Second was Anna Wise with 19 votes.

    Is the album in your Top 1/5/10/20/30 list of best Hip-Hop albums of all-time?

    5 of 67 respondents thought the album was the greatest hip-hop album, or about 1.18%.
    8 of 67 respondents said that the album was in their top 5.
    16 of 67 respondents said that the album was in their top 10.
    19 of 67 respondents said that the album was in their top 20.
    10 of 67 respondents said that the album was in their top 30.
    9 of 67 respondents did not have the album in their top list.


    "I want to collect reviews from KTT members and calculate a consensus for the feelings and reactions towards to the album. I will score the album and show results after 30 or more responses come through."

    Once we get a good number of reviews in they will be averaged and scored. Serious inquiries please.


    Guidelines:

    • There will be a GoogleForms link for each review. Use that to answer the questions. THE ANSWERS YOU POST IN THIS THREAD WILL NOT COUNT TOWARDS THE SCORE.
    • Trolls will be ignored.

    POST YOUR ANSWERS HERE:
    forms.gle/bSRd9nwfGCoCxfCXA
    forms.gle/bSRd9nwfGCoCxfCXA
    forms.gle/bSRd9nwfGCoCxfCXA
    forms.gle/bSRd9nwfGCoCxfCXA
    forms.gle/bSRd9nwfGCoCxfCXA

    Final Rating? (1-10)
    Did the project meet your expectations? (Yes/No)
    Rate the album's production (1-10)
    Rate the album's lyrics/songwriting (1-10)
    Rate the rapper's microphone/vocal performance on the album (1-10)
    Favorite track?
    Least favorite track?
    Favorite guest artist?
    Least favorite guest artist?
    Is the project in your Top 1/5/10/20/30 list of best Rap projects OAT? (1/5/10/20/30/No)

  • KEV 💨
    Sep 11, 2020

    big classic

  • Sep 13, 2020
    ·
    edited

    Kendrick Lamar - Good Kid, M.A.A.D City (92)

    67 people responded to the thread with detailed reviews of the album.

    Overall Rating of Good Kid, M.A.A.D City - 617.5/670

    That was good for an average of 92/100, which indicates Universal acclaim.
    Most common response rating was 10

    Expectations:

    63 out of the 67 reviews (94.03%) said that the album met or exceeded expectations.

    Overall Production Rating:

    The total score for production was 598.5/670

    The average score was 89/100
    Most common response rating was 10

    Overall Lyrical Performance:

    The total score for lyrical-performance was 634.5/670

    The average score was 95/100
    Most common response rating was 10

    Overall Microphone/Vocal Performance:

    The total score was 624/670

    The average score was 93/100
    Most common response rating was 10

    FAVORITE TRACK ON THE ALBUM

    The most common response for favorite track was Money Trees with 25 votes. Second was Sing About Me, I'm Dying of Thirst with 20 votes.

    LEAST FAVORITE TRACK ON THE ALBUM

    The most common response for least favorite track was Real with 38 votes. Second was Compton with 8 votes. Third was Swimming Pools (Drank) with 7 votes.

    FAVORITE GUEST ON THE ALBUM

    The most common response for favorite guest was Jay Rock with 43 votes. Second was Drake with 13 votes.

    LEAST FAVORITE GUEST ON THE ALBUM

    The most common response for least favorite guest was Dr Dre with 22 votes. Second was Anna Wise with 19 votes.

    Is the album in your Top 1/5/10/20/30 list of best Hip-Hop albums of all-time?

    5 of 67 respondents thought the album was the greatest hip-hop album, or about 1.18%.
    8 of 67 respondents said that the album was in their top 5.
    16 of 67 respondents said that the album was in their top 10.
    19 of 67 respondents said that the album was in their top 20.
    10 of 67 respondents said that the album was in their top 30.
    9 of 67 respondents did not have the album in their top list.

  • Sep 30, 2020

    Well deserved