Br00ses

2y

Oh that's cool it seemed like you didn't like him because of some of your posts

ghostyyy

2y

Cant wait for Destroy Lonely vs Sade

Sunroof

2y

classical trombone performance

i just dont understand what u mean when bob dylan very clearly is able to construct rhythm and harmony in his music and has plenty of songs that follow a certain form or not. like i thought u were just trolling at first but now im confused u have a weird view on what music is and isnt

ghostyyy

2y

Cant wait for Destroy Lonely vs Sade

mr get dough

2y

That would be a tie

mr get dough

2y

I don’t like the culture around his fanbase nothing against him really

Br00ses

2y

I think this has all been a misunderstanding and liking whatever you want it is good

Music is a beautiful thing and having your own unique taste is special

So basically bob is better

stayhealthy2

2y

im not saying that he isn't a musician i'm saying that he's hardly a musican. Yes there is rhythm and harmony and melody in his music but he doesn't have any kind of identity in any of those things. the art of what he does is fundamentally non musical which is why his legacy is also not musical really.

I'm about to be maybe a little bit hyperbolic and kinda goofy. it's pretty much impossible to make a bob dylan type beat because he's not doing anything musically distinctive to be recognizable. there's a lot of other artists this applies to but they're hopefully making some musical choices vocally. bob dylan isn't. he's hardly singing and he's not rapping over the most dime a dozen backing music which he's not always making. im not saying he has no talent but his talent isn't really musical.

ghostyyy

2y

I fw sade heavy but lone might edge em out

Like it we’re being fr

ghostyyy

2y

I fw sade heavy but lone might edge em out

Like it we’re being fr

ghostyyy

2y

Cant wait for Destroy Lonely vs Sade

RRRBBB

2y

Roger Daltrey vs Drake next pls

mr get dough

2y

Yeah I’m not really taking away from Bob’s greatness, i wouldn’t agree with some of the slander on his name itt

And I do think he has more classic albums for his base, and was a prolific songwriter in his prime

I just strongly dislike when people act like if you don’t rank a white artist who honestly NOBODY in our culture listens to like that or grew up on his s*** prolly got into it later, over MJ people act like ur being ignorant or have a lesser opinion than them.

MJ was a great vocalist, performer, song writer, hands on producer etc and has several absolutely classic albums under his belt. If you like Bob Dylan more thats cool everybody got they own taste but just being pretentious like it’s obvious that dylan is better or that black people have even close to the same reverence for him is just annoying imo and led to this thread

No disrespect to Dylan’s artistry or influence itself

stayhealthy2

2y

im not saying that he isn't a musician i'm saying that he's hardly a musican. Yes there is rhythm and harmony and melody in his music but he doesn't have any kind of identity in any of those things. the art of what he does is fundamentally non musical which is why his legacy is also not musical really.

I'm about to be maybe a little bit hyperbolic and kinda goofy. it's pretty much impossible to make a bob dylan type beat because he's not doing anything musically distinctive to be recognizable. there's a lot of other artists this applies to but they're hopefully making some musical choices vocally. bob dylan isn't. he's hardly singing and he's not rapping over the most dime a dozen backing music which he's not always making. im not saying he has no talent but his talent isn't really musical.

stayhealthy2

2y

sorry homie but if you put bob in a room with erroll garner he looks like an audience member

rise zero

2y

Are you trolling cause this is so incredibly dumb

Aruji

2y

yeah I get that.

That's the impression I get from reading many of these posts.

However, I'd agree that it's difficult to separate the cultural impact both artists made from their music.

I'd like to say not to knock on MJ's artistry. That's the field I think where he's overrated. Convince me otherwise but I think that Dylan's intuitions were more fundamental and game-changing than MJ's.

G Roy

2y

we'll fr do that who do u wanna represent

HURRYUPSONIC

2y

damn Bob rep didn't drop we are the world? big L

Elric

2y

You taking out of your anus, Sheamus