This is a combination of first and foremost talent, numbers and success in today's game along with to a lesser degree accolades and career success to break any close ties. This list is for the 32 starters without injuries.

1. Tom Brady
2. Patrick Mahomes

3. Russell Wilson

4. Drew Brees

5. Aaron Rodgers

6. Phillip Rivers
7. Matt Ryan
8. Carson Wentz
9. Deshaun Watson

10. Dak Prescott

11. Lamar Jackson
12. Ben Roethlisberger

13. Cam Newton

14. Nick Foles
15. P***star Jimmy
16. Jared Goff
17. Kirk Cousins

18. Matthew Stafford

19. Jacoby Brissett
20. Josh Allen
21. Kyler Murray

22. Baker Mayfield

23. Sam Darnold
24. Derek Carr

25. Jameis Winston

26. Marcus Mariota
27. Mitchell Trubisky
28. Joe Flacco
29. Andy Dalton
30. Case Keenum / Dwayne Haskins
31. Josh Rosen
32. Daniel Jones

Your top 3 is way off but otherwise pretty fair.

Rodgers, Brees, and Mahomes are top 3.
Watson better than Wentz.

Cam is way too high. He should be bottom tier at this point.

Josh Allen should be bottom tier.

Derek Carr should Foles-Stafford tier.

is that aaron carter in ur avy?

Agree with #32

Watson and Wentz are neck and neck but I think Wentz has a better IQ and can do more from the pocket

I like Josh Allen he has a huge arm and is mobile he's just behind a s*** line

Derek Carr is a scrub post that playoff season

Still have some faith in Cam I won't hold his stubbornness against him he's been playing hurt the last we saw of him, he has the ability to take over a game my reasoning for his placement

Yes

less s*** line and more slow reads in Allen's case imo.

I thought the same about Carr but he's looked really good in the games I watched this year (Denver, Indy, and Houston) which made me reevaluate my opinion on him. Maybe I just saw the outliers.

Ryan is better than Rivers

brees (if he is the same as he was pre injury)
russ
mahomes
Rodgers

brady
etc

in what world is Daniel Jones worse than f***in Josh Rosen

I'm a diehard patriots fan and gotta say Brady shouldn't be in the top three. Purely based on talent and athletisism, it should be Mahomes, Rodgers, and Wilson. Then Brees, Watson, Rivers and Wentz probably before Brady. Definitely in top 10 overall but for a different reason.

Brady is best technical (cliche to say) "system quarterback" but that's because he throws it where the receiver should be, not where they are. Usually when he misses it's because his recievers don't get to the spot in the play in time or over run.

The whole game manager segement isn't far off either. He's the perfect vessel for Belichick's game calling but at the same time, he's the most consistent passer when hitting those spots/following the plan too. I don't think Belichick could just plug in this format with another QB and think they can't fully succeed to this level if they were separate.

Stopped at Brady at 1

Imagine

Watson
Dak

Wentz

Ryan/Rivers

You cant put Rivers and Ryan above the others with they records today. Rivers about to gt benchd

Mariota isn’t a starting quarterback

Trash list top to bottom, only agree with Russ and Mahomes being in top 3.

this nigga said Deshaun Watson and Wentz are neck and neck lmfaooooo

That’s not outrageous to say

🥱

Wentz is a gassed game manager and gets carried by his running game and isnt a winning QB

im a Wentz hater, but....what run game? lmao

Averages 250 passing yards/game in his career with 4.9% TD% on his attempts doesn’t say game manager, and wins aren’t solely attributed to a QB

The one year our running game was even halfway consistent was 2 years ago lol

where would teddy go on the list