From best to worst

God tier:
1. Moon
2. Pure Souls

Good/Great:
3. I Know God Breathed On This
4. Praise God
5. No Child Left Behind
6. Donda
7. Life Of The Party
8. Welcome To My Life

Mid:
9. Heaven & Hell
10. Remote Control
11. Hurricane
12. South Carolina
13. 24
14. New Again

Trash:
15. I Made It
16. Junya Watanabe

that "im losin my family" jawn got potential to be an all timer, top 3 s***

Thats welcome to my life i think

put that in god tier then stop the cap

i know we all got our own opinions and tastes but i'm curious as to how to you put a song that has don toliver crooning on it as god tier but not the ye song where hes putting his emotions about losing his family on full blast

Cause it aint finished (i guess)

The 2 in god tier really the only 2 that seem to be finished lmao

God Tier

Pure Souls
Jonah

Good

Praise God
24
South Carolina
Junya
Moon

Mid

Don't Abandon Your Family
Guess Who's Going To Jail
I Know God Breathed On This
No Child Left Behind

Trash

Remote
We Made It
Hurricane
New Again

It sucks cuz I think there's a lot of potential in some of these songs like Hurricane and New Again but he just manages to f*** it up hard. And half these songs need proper verses from Kanye

this is one of the worst rankings ive seen for Donda

From Best to Worst

God tier

1. Moon
2. Pure Souls
3. Jail

Great

4. I Know God Breathed On This
5. Praise God
6. No Child Left Behind (Potential)
7. I'm Losing my Family
8. This is the Glory
9. Junya (Potential)
10. Remote (Potential)
11. New Again (Potential)

Okay

12: Shoulder to lean on (cool but should at least get a ye verse)

Mid

13. 24 / We gonna be okay (only because its so needlessly long)

Trash

14. Hurricane (Replace with a different version plz)
15. We made it (Delete from Donda)

Current Rating: 3/10

how can you have 8 songs in great and 3 bangers and tell me its 3/10

f*** outta here

dumb ass fans

im assuming you werent in the Donda thread then

my actual ranking is 8/10

Why mmmm mmmm mmm

cuz you said junya is trash tier

Yeah that s*** trash and catchy at the same time

Expect more from a Ye album tho. As a promotional single it would be aight

Is guess whos going to jail the real name?

Apparently real name is just "Jail"

this might be a wildly unpopular opinion but,

moon is overrated. yall only like it because don toliver sounds nice on it which is fine but the song literally goes nowhere

praise god literally one of the best sounding trap song i ever heard and cdq isn’t even out. how could that not be god tier?

I really didn't know the track list when I was watching the stream.

Which one is "Pure Souls"?

The one with Roddy

No Ye verse yet

New again and heaven or hell are god tier WTF

Moon would be pretty nice if it had a ye verse or some more vocals but yea it really just is a extended Hurricane outro/interlude track.

How in the f*** is new again trash. What

HIIIIII with a bunch of I’s or
HEYYYYYY with a bunch of Y’s

The club feel? The Autotune vocals melodies? Nice flow. That s*** can be a hit

losing my family top 1 not even close

God tier
1. Moon
2. Pure Souls
3. Jail
4. New Again
5. Shoulder to Lean On
6. I know God Breathed on This
8. No Child Left Behind
9. I’m losing My Family
10. remote (so much potential)
11. hurricane (just fix the s***ty ye verse and ending and it’s GOATed)

Ehh
12 This is the Glory
13 Junya (Basic as f***. Delete)
14 Praise God (I like it but it also feels kinda basic… potential for sure though.)
15 24 - kinda weak. Cut it
16 We made it (Delete from Donda)