Title, I had more fun playing 1 than 2

RDR1 was more fun for sure. I wish Rockstar would explore the movement / shooting mechanics from Max Payne 3. RDR2 was slower paced, but I did like what they did with the story. Just took too long to get there

No

Just no

RDR2 most overhated game oat

RDR2 a masterpiece

A solid screensaver of a horse running/10

Max Payne was hella underrated. Had a blast playing that even did a second play through and I never do that

S*** was boring af to play everything else is A1

Debatable but RDR2 open world was flawless

Red dead 2 was basically a movie with some interaction. I feel like there was so little for actual enjoyable game in there. Just follow along and press some buttons every so often. Masterpiece of a story though

Here to say God of War (2018) most overrated game of the decade

RDR2 whole ass snoozefest bro

played RDR1 as a kid and RDR2 as an adult. I think RDR2 is a near perfect game and not boring in the slightest to me, really enjoyed RDR1 at the time too but I should go back and play it now maybe.

I appreciated every second I played

Only downside for me was loading times (base PS4)

Also I would like more clothes in the game

And the shooting is maybe not top tier but its still good enough...

I prefer RDR2’s shooting better than let’s say Witcher 3’s combat and even Skyrim’s

Is RDR2 fun I've never played. Good story is a plus IG but it's not why I play games

Hey man that s*** is fire

Why do you think it's overrated

This! I was bored playing that s*** too. I only got through like 3 hrs and was like nah im good on this

even with all the gameplay downfalls of rdr2 the story and world makes it up for me

they’re both amazing

This. But giving it to RDR2 due to story + exploration (maybe cuz i played it just to get to #2 )

it was too slow paced for me being use to GTA online

Yes

RDR2 is the GOAT rockstar game, dont care what anybody says.

2 s***s on 1

RDR1 a classic but nah. RDR2 is better in literally every way.