JJ set the things up, Rian took them in the direction he wanted to and then JJ was like "wtf no"

How was y’all audience reaction to Rey parents reveal? I had people either giggling or sighing

Do y'all think Ben should've been in the final shot with Luke and Leia?

Rian literally shattered almost every possible good ending lol. If you can give a satisfying conclusion to this 50 year old saga without straying from his vision give it right now

edited

If not him why not Anakin

Yeah it was a lot of sighs if I remember correctly

y’all really lack imagination if you believe this

okay Terrio jr still waiting for an answer

Instead of getting creative JJ resorted to online fan theories and retconning the most divisive Star Wars Movie so everyone who didn’t like it would suck his d***

I think for that specific scene it wouldn't have made much sense for Anakin to be there, though I wish he was in the film, or the trilogy in some capacity other than a voice.

But Ben not being there just feels a bit odd. It would've made it even more like the ROTJ ending but it would've been nice imo.

I was disappointed han wasn't in there. The first father figure in her life and started her journey and he wasn't even there

you want me to write an elongated fan script to answer your dumbass statement?

what you said was inane

I agree

And it’s like I wanted Anakin in that specific shot, but come to think of it would’ve been nice to get the whole Skywalker family together

babu frik should have been there

One positive i will give this movie this was a goat alien

Chewie still goat

His reaction to Leia’s death

TFA always bothered me when Leia hugged Rey (who she had literally never met before) and not hugged chewie about Han Solo’s death.

learn how to read dumbass

TLJ doesn't retcon anything from TFA where did that complaint even come from

You basically asked for one when you asked for someone to wrap up a whole f***ing saga with Rians vision. Any answer i would give you otherwise you’d dismiss. You said it was impossible but a talented enough writer could make it possible

Not at all lol. TLJ set it on track for a more exciting conclusion. TFA set the series on track to be an original trilogy remake since day 1.

JJ had to do some unexplained Palpatine resurrection to get the movie back to his original ROTJ remake vision

killed snoke and lads couldnt see the rest of the movie because of the tears

there isn't even anything to retcon

Everytime i don’t wanna think disney ruined star wars this video seemingly always pops up in my suggested tab

What has JJ done anyway ? His best movie is Lost pilot

lmao yall really wanted boring ass Snoke to be the big bad of this trilogy? Cmon

TLJ set up Kylo as the main villain, a far more interesting character played by one of the best actors of this generation, a character that initally idolised Vader then managed do surpass him by doing what he could never do and overthrowing his master and taking control of the entire galaxy.

It set up the force moving past the binary viewpoints of just Jedi or Sith, and moved past it just being limited to people from "chosen" bloodlines, something that could actually bring genuine permanent balance to the force rather than repeating the light side dark side cycle for eternity.

I'm sorry yall care more about lore than story and demand every Star Wars movie tick the same boxes and never make any attempt to move past the same formula it's used for over 40 years but it baffles me how you don't see the potential for interesting storylines there