Which unreleased/scrapped album had more classic potential? So Help Me God or Yandhi?

For me its SHMG. All Day ft Kendrick, Can U Be, Fall Outta Heaven would’ve been unbeatable

Not to mention the McCartney contributions

shmg 100000000%

apparently 2chainz is naming his next album so help me god

SHMG is the ultimate great album that never was.

I think about what that album could have been at least once a week.

TLOP rollout was so chaotic i kinda think All Day is the last time he released something and it wasn’t a painful process.

All day was a painful process

Yandhi. Not to d***ride it or anything but I think we have a more comprehensive idea of what we could expect and tbh the album slaps

SHMG seemed like it lacked direction. But who knows

Yandhi would've been bottom 2 in ye's discog

don't forget about i feel like that

Turbo g16

True, and JIK replacing it did not change that.

Ye has not put his full attention into music since TLOP + Daytona beats

Both doodie

Pablo is literally so help me god but with fully fleshed out ideas lmao

and you got yandhi so this debate is redundant

Yandhi was last decade of smile (beach boys)

God getting All Day was like pulling teeth do not miss that

Yandhi because of City in the Sky, Last Name, and Hurricane

By that logic we got Yandhi thru JIK, we all know scrapped albums change. Pablo didn't have McCartney, Country/rock influenced tracks (All Day, FourFiveSeconds, OG Grave) or even the same concept outside of Christianity.

This is a better matchup than ppl know

A fleshed out Last Name wouldve been MBDTF level

it's hard to answer this because at what point of each album's making do you consider the question

yandhi at the original release date was going to be terrible, but a lot of its later tracks would've been incredible at completion.

mid, good, and mid

we already have it at completion

Jut like how there was a version of SHMG that got scrapped for Swish and that sounded mid too

So I'd imagine every album not at a specific time but at it's peak potential before the concepts were removed/changed or censored in Yandhis case.

ban anyone who says Yandhi

wash us in the blood out now