Communism Thread

Page 471 of 1355
Reply
  • Apr 24, 2022

    Thinking about how capitalism’s contradictions are exponentially increasing

  • Apr 24, 2022
    ·
    3 replies

    Also thinking about how someone critiqued Marx as overly idealists

  • Apr 24, 2022

    Like one of my favorite contradictions is the idea that communism is unnecessarily idealistic yet it’s subscribers are cold hearted pragmatists

  • Apr 24, 2022
    ·
    2 replies
    americana

    Also thinking about how someone critiqued Marx as overly idealists

    Are you referring to Althusser and his conception of an epistemological break in Marx’s thought between the “young” Marx and “anti humanist” Marx?

  • Apr 24, 2022

    Slogans are something you use for agitation but when people use them as a substitute to theory they just end up saying the dumbest simplistic s*** half the time no relation to socialism anyways

  • Apr 24, 2022
    ·
    1 reply
    MyBallsAndMyWord

    Are you referring to Althusser and his conception of an epistemological break in Marx’s thought between the “young” Marx and “anti humanist” Marx?

    Nah the liberal one where nice things aren’t possible

  • Apr 24, 2022
    ·
    1 reply
    americana

    Nah the liberal one where nice things aren’t possible

    oh word

    I’ve been reading For Marx by Althusser recently and highly recommend it. Don’t agree with all of it as he’s a pretty rigid structuralist but still think there’s a lot of great insights there

  • Apr 24, 2022
    ·
    1 reply
    MyBallsAndMyWord

    oh word

    I’ve been reading For Marx by Althusser recently and highly recommend it. Don’t agree with all of it as he’s a pretty rigid structuralist but still think there’s a lot of great insights there

    I see him championed by Anarchists so it turned me off reading him but does he have any interesting ideas? He's pretty prominent

  • Apr 24, 2022
    ·
    1 reply
    MyBallsAndMyWord

    Are you referring to Althusser and his conception of an epistemological break in Marx’s thought between the “young” Marx and “anti humanist” Marx?

    what you think of the break?

  • Apr 24, 2022
    ·
    1 reply
    the reds

    I see him championed by Anarchists so it turned me off reading him but does he have any interesting ideas? He's pretty prominent

    What anarchists you talking to lol? Not disbelieving you I have just never heard of a anarchist liking (or even knowing) Althusser lol

  • Apr 24, 2022
    ·
    edited
    ·
    1 reply

    @bopman i could write a very long essay about Althusser and what his contributions are, but I’m out with friends so can’t at this moment. I can provide a more detailed response later.

    But the long and short of it is I think Althusser details extremely well how capitalist ideology is reproduced through what he calls Ideological State Apparatuses. With that, we should think about how we can try to wage political struggles within and in counter to ISAs by attempting - through cultural struggles and creating independent organs of political power - to challenge the capitalist State’s hegemony. I think it ties into Gramsci’s thoughts really nicely in that regard as well

  • Apr 24, 2022
    MyBallsAndMyWord

    What anarchists you talking to lol? Not disbelieving you I have just never heard of a anarchist liking (or even knowing) Althusser lol

    Might be confusing him with another guy idk

  • Apr 24, 2022
    ·
    edited
    Womanpuncher69

    what you think of the break?

    I’m somewhat torn on that as someone who has an appreciation for Hegel but also sympathizes with Althusser’s “anti humanism” and his critique of Hegels idealist influence on Marx.

    I do think Althusser is absolutely right that social democrats and revisionists lean on Marx’s early works to justify their phony “Marxism”. That being said, I think those early works are really valuable in a lot of ways despite their problems, and I don’t think we should cast them aside entirely the way Althusser proposes

  • Apr 24, 2022
    GoldLink

    Hello friends, I have a question, apologies in advance if it's a stupid one, I kind of just started my journey into socialism this month.

    I'm struggling to understand how the rate of profit tends to fall when there's a decrease in surplus value. Wouldn't that work to their benefit?

    beautiful in depth explanation of the economics behind the tendency for the rate of profit to fall

    ive watched this video like 30 times

  • Apr 24, 2022
    ·
    1 reply
    MyBallsAndMyWord

    @bopman i could write a very long essay about Althusser and what his contributions are, but I’m out with friends so can’t at this moment. I can provide a more detailed response later.

    But the long and short of it is I think Althusser details extremely well how capitalist ideology is reproduced through what he calls Ideological State Apparatuses. With that, we should think about how we can try to wage political struggles within and in counter to ISAs by attempting - through cultural struggles and creating independent organs of political power - to challenge the capitalist State’s hegemony. I think it ties into Gramsci’s thoughts really nicely in that regard as well

    i think in this way his contributions to socialist thought and "anarchism" are important.

    developing dual power not just to "combat capitalism" through some economic warfare or some s*** but on a psychological level to develop dual power against capitalist realism

  • Apr 24, 2022
    americana

    Also thinking about how someone critiqued Marx as overly idealists

    i cant believe emu said marx never thought about having finite natural resources

    i dont mean to be mean but what the f***

  • Apr 24, 2022

    carbonbrief.org/chinas-2060-climate-pledge-is-largely-consistent-with-1-5c-goal-study-finds
    the only country actually hitting the paris climate agreement accords

  • deadacc

    i think in this way his contributions to socialist thought and "anarchism" are important.

    developing dual power not just to "combat capitalism" through some economic warfare or some s*** but on a psychological level to develop dual power against capitalist realism

    Precisely

  • Apr 24, 2022
    ·
    1 reply

    Something to be said about how often attempts to "purge" end up killing everybody with principles and sparing all the people it was in theory supposed to get rid of. One of the worst specters of the French Revolution.

  • Apr 24, 2022
    Lein

    Something to be said about how often attempts to "purge" end up killing everybody with principles and sparing all the people it was in theory supposed to get rid of. One of the worst specters of the French Revolution.

    Systems of education, re-education, and material reinforcement are far more effective

  • Apr 24, 2022
    ·
    1 reply
    kiddash3r

    This an engaging read? Never read politics books but kinda interested in this one ngl

    @Scratchin_Bandit

  • Apr 24, 2022
    ·
    1 reply
    kiddash3r

    @Scratchin_Bandit

    Lmao my bad forgot to respond

    But it is for sure, easily the best historical account of US interventions post-WW2, definitely an engaging read in William Blum's writing style and you can of course choose about which intervention you wanna read so you can get to what interests you the most right away

  • Apr 24, 2022
    ·
    1 reply
    Scratchin Mamba

    Lmao my bad forgot to respond

    But it is for sure, easily the best historical account of US interventions post-WW2, definitely an engaging read in William Blum's writing style and you can of course choose about which intervention you wanna read so you can get to what interests you the most right away

    just hit libgen up

    also happy easter orthodox brother

  • Apr 24, 2022
    kiddash3r

    just hit libgen up

    also happy easter orthodox brother

    And happy easter to u my orthodox brother

  • Apr 24, 2022
    ·
    1 reply