Reply
  • Aug 6, 2021

    Punch just gonna say a bunch of glib and pseudointellectual bullshit and dusthead twitter will eat it up.

  • Aug 6, 2021
    ·
    1 reply

    Fantano gonna shred dude to pieces

  • Aug 6, 2021
    americana

    I swear like this man’s job is to review the music and if he doesn’t like it so what

    Fr like wtf was the point of throwing around racial accusations

  • Aug 6, 2021
    ·
    1 reply

    such a tired take. he didn't like it. his opinion. move on.

  • Aug 6, 2021
    ·
    1 reply
    dotM

    Fantano gonna shred dude to pieces

    when he actually makes good arguments in the punch interview

  • Aug 6, 2021
    RTH

    such a tired take. he didn't like it. his opinion. move on.

  • Aug 6, 2021
    ·
    1 reply
    Twist Your Cap

    I don't like music reviews or fantano at all but he obviously just listens to it and gives his opinion like any music he listens to. to me it's lame to just sit there and comment on what other people do your whole life

    pretty lame of punch for adding some nonsense race dimension though

    Though he is one of the biggest ones. Music Reviews had always impact on perception of music. Especially in america. Those reviews were make or break for artist back in the day. Now its very different because music is available for everyone but i believe this relic of injustice from white reviewers in those early days maybe what punch remembers is playing into wanting to make Fantano an exemple that times changed.

  • Aug 6, 2021
    ·
    edited
    ·
    2 replies

    I hate this “not black enough to have an opinion on black artist’s music” narrative.

    If Fantano loved the album it wouldn’t be any of that energy from Isaiah & Punch, it would be “Thanks dog, all love” back on the bird app.

    Rappers and their management even getting on social media and complaining about bad reviews is an embarrassment no matter how you look at it. Just take your L and keep it moving, if your album rollout was really as successful as you say it’s been, you wouldn’t even have time or energy to debate s***.

  • Aug 6, 2021
    kiddash3r

    when he actually makes good arguments in the punch interview

    People talk down on fantano for a lot of stuff, but I seriously think he does it to entertain a wider audience.

  • Aug 6, 2021
    CKL TML

    Lowkey fantano makes some good points from what ive seen even about albums i really like like the last dave album

    he is pretty well spoken and genuinely has dropped great reviews,even when I havent agreed with them

    Its just that recently he has become so obsessed with some stuff(drake,that whole mavi controversy etc etc) and he seems so cocky and condescending at times

  • Aug 6, 2021

    tired of the convo being asymmetrical bro what it’s always gonna be asymmetrical ur white and made urself into an internet media giant like whaaattttt

  • Aug 6, 2021

    the less we interact with fantano the better

  • Aug 6, 2021
    ·
    2 replies
    DKomamura

    Though he is one of the biggest ones. Music Reviews had always impact on perception of music. Especially in america. Those reviews were make or break for artist back in the day. Now its very different because music is available for everyone but i believe this relic of injustice from white reviewers in those early days maybe what punch remembers is playing into wanting to make Fantano an exemple that times changed.

    so what's the alternative? not being critical with an opinion because it MAY turn some listeners away? this is the risk that you take as an artist when releasing a project, some critics aren't going to like it. it's not some deep seated issue that needs to be corrected. i love the zay album and i'm ok that fantano doesn't like it. hits every one differently

  • Aug 6, 2021
    ·
    2 replies
    RTH

    so what's the alternative? not being critical with an opinion because it MAY turn some listeners away? this is the risk that you take as an artist when releasing a project, some critics aren't going to like it. it's not some deep seated issue that needs to be corrected. i love the zay album and i'm ok that fantano doesn't like it. hits every one differently

    he could still say what he say but give that album a 6-7 imo

    context is a thing and a 5 is so brutal. i don't even rock with the album like that but there was no need of that

  • Aug 6, 2021
    ·
    1 reply
    uhh

    he could still say what he say but give that album a 6-7 imo

    context is a thing and a 5 is so brutal. i don't even rock with the album like that but there was no need of that

    You want him to give it a completely different score

  • Aug 6, 2021
    ·
    1 reply
    uhh

    he could still say what he say but give that album a 6-7 imo

    context is a thing and a 5 is so brutal. i don't even rock with the album like that but there was no need of that

    But what if he doesnt think the album is a 6-7 worthy tho

  • Aug 6, 2021
    Oblivion X

    But what if he doesnt think the album is a 6-7 worthy tho

    it's all just arbitrary bullshit anyways. all of these scores, anywhere you look

    man i just really hate this review score s*** and wish people didn't put any stock in it

  • Aug 6, 2021
    ·
    1 reply
    HFM

    You want him to give it a completely different score

    "scores".... who cares or knows REALLY what the difference between a 5 an a 6

    he coulda said the same thing in the body of his review slapped a 6 on it and it wouldn't have really hurt anybody's feelings here

  • Aug 6, 2021

    damn fantano said.. pull up then

  • The state of the music industry

  • They all loved him when he was d***riding Kendrick but now he doesn't like Isaiah Rashad's music they're going at him 😂😂😂

  • Aug 6, 2021
    ·
    1 reply
    Maccaveli101

    I hate this “not black enough to have an opinion on black artist’s music” narrative.

    If Fantano loved the album it wouldn’t be any of that energy from Isaiah & Punch, it would be “Thanks dog, all love” back on the bird app.

    Rappers and their management even getting on social media and complaining about bad reviews is an embarrassment no matter how you look at it. Just take your L and keep it moving, if your album rollout was really as successful as you say it’s been, you wouldn’t even have time or energy to debate s***.

    its true though

  • Aug 6, 2021
    HFM

    People that throw tantrums over Fantanos opinions try to dress it up as everything but what it is, a tantrum cause someone has a different opinion

  • Aug 6, 2021

    Kendrick next album getting a 6

1
2
3
...
9