Reply
  • Oct 17
    ·
    2 replies
    maxxing

    I’m just saying re9 isn’t niche at all

    It seems like gta6 will win though which is kinda depressing but it just feels inevitable because of the hype

    Niche maybe the wrong word, that game was popular and that's why I singled RE9 out to explain what I meant about why it won't be as popular as GTA VI when people are deciding their GOTY. Plenty of gamers also have a "more = better" mindset and focus on value for money, that gives a 50+ hour open world sandbox like GTA an advantage over a 20 hour linear experience

    I believe that GTA winning will maybe feel like it's because it's the biggest entertainment product ever but I do also think the game will be doing things we've never seen before and genuinely deserve the award. And I think that's going to be the consensus, the game is going to be that good

  • Abyss

    GTA will outsell any game ever the day it drops besides Tetris or something. RE is not niche at all and I don’t think the sales comparison between Zelda and RE9 will be as clear cut as you think.

    Yeah, not really fair to compare GTA because its outperforming anything RE9 should be outselling Zelda, RE9 dropped on all consoles and PC vs just the Switch 2

  • Will Simp

    Niche maybe the wrong word, that game was popular and that's why I singled RE9 out to explain what I meant about why it won't be as popular as GTA VI when people are deciding their GOTY. Plenty of gamers also have a "more = better" mindset and focus on value for money, that gives a 50+ hour open world sandbox like GTA an advantage over a 20 hour linear experience

    I believe that GTA winning will maybe feel like it's because it's the biggest entertainment product ever but I do also think the game will be doing things we've never seen before and genuinely deserve the award. And I think that's going to be the consensus, the game is going to be that good

    yeah gta 6 does seem revolutionary and they really raised the bar from red dead to red dead 2, so there’s no reason to think 5 to 6 won’t make a similar leap. it’s too bad we won’t have more time to digest it before voting opens, but I guess ultimately player vote barely moves the needle, I think like 90% of the votes that count are publications/organizations who will get early access. It’s a weird situation for sure.

  • Oct 17
    Will Simp

    Niche maybe the wrong word, that game was popular and that's why I singled RE9 out to explain what I meant about why it won't be as popular as GTA VI when people are deciding their GOTY. Plenty of gamers also have a "more = better" mindset and focus on value for money, that gives a 50+ hour open world sandbox like GTA an advantage over a 20 hour linear experience

    I believe that GTA winning will maybe feel like it's because it's the biggest entertainment product ever but I do also think the game will be doing things we've never seen before and genuinely deserve the award. And I think that's going to be the consensus, the game is going to be that good

    Mechanically and design I feel I would likely give to Phantom Blade 0 but story, amount to do, tech , world , accessibility to a larger audience goes to GTA VI . You remove GTA VI from the situation i still think there are cases where Phantom Blade Zero or another game beats RE9

  • Oct 17
    maxxing

    re9 is the best selling game of the year

    Sold well doesnt change its still niche especially when you break down players who actually beat the game . S*** many have never beaten Grand Theft Auto V but the amount of time they have spent in the world whether they have beaten it or not is exponentially larger than those who played RE9

  • Oct 17
    ·
    1 reply

    I haven’t played any of those games but just from what I’ve seen I would like Control Resonant to win. RE9 seems like more of the same but very well executed. GTA6 is too big to fail tho

  • Oct 17
    Abyss

    I haven’t played any of those games but just from what I’ve seen I would like Control Resonant to win. RE9 seems like more of the same but very well executed. GTA6 is too big to fail tho

    after Phantom Blade Zero review embargo drops I am hoping to come back to this thread

  • Lol GTA 6 vs WHO?

  • Oct 18
    ·
    1 reply
  • Oct 18
    ·
    1 reply

    ah yes my favorite niche series resident evil

  • Oct 19
    hayabusa

    ah yes my favorite niche series resident evil

    lol

  • ASAKI 🫈
    Oct 19
    HaroldsChicken
    https://twitter.com/goldenjoysticks/status/2111804599627833488

    Lowkey I'm choosing Forza Horizon 6

  • Kr0niic ☘️
    OP
    Nov 4

    Updated OP. Locking in my final guesses for GOTY

  • nominees next week??

  • Nov 9
    ·
    2 replies

    gonna be a super boring awards ceremony awards-wise due to GTA6, so Geoff better have some actual good stuff for announcements - esp after last year

  • ThomFork

    gonna be a super boring awards ceremony awards-wise due to GTA6, so Geoff better have some actual good stuff for announcements - esp after last year

    Sucks as without GTA 6 it would be a pretty interesting category this year.

  • Nov 9
    ·
    2 replies

    007 should not make it

  • Nov 9
    Drezo

    007 should not make it

  • Nov 9
    Drezo

    007 should not make it

  • Nov 10

    007 in the same sentence at GTA6, OOT, RE9:

  • 1 month left now guys!!!

  • Nov 10
    ·
    2 replies

    Zelda vs GTA is crazy, both fanbases crazy as hell

  • Nov 10
    Nute

    Zelda vs GTA is crazy, both fanbases crazy as hell

    they all going to be talking crazy on twitter. I will just be watching them fight because I dont care who wins.I just want to see Judas, Gen Atas, Splinter Cell Remake gameplay

  • Nute

    Zelda vs GTA is crazy, both fanbases crazy as hell

    Literally had this argument with my old roommate earlier, told him comparing the games and frame rates are apples v. oranges

    no point in pitting them together i feel unless for GOTY but lets be real for a second

  • ThomFork

    gonna be a super boring awards ceremony awards-wise due to GTA6, so Geoff better have some actual good stuff for announcements - esp after last year

    More headlines if they don’t give it to GTA tbh

    Game has gotten more than enough press let’s wind people up a bit

1
...
4
5
6
...
11