We all know CD, LR, MBDTF, Grad, 808s and Yeezus way too good to be compared to these 2 albums. ye and JIK are not good enough to be compared to them tho. So which one of these 2 is better?

Ultralight Beam vs Jail --> ULB wins
FSMH pt 1 vs God Breathed --> FSMH wins
Pt2 vs Off The Grid --> OTG wins
Famous vs Hurricane --> Famous wins
Feedback vs Praise God --> Praise God wins
Low Lights vs Jonah --> Jonah wins
Highlights vs Ok Ok --> Highlights wins
Freestyle 4 vs Junya --> Freestyle 4 wins
Waves vs Believe What I Say --> BWIS wins
FML vs 24 --> FML wins
Real Friends vs Remote Control --> Real Friends wins
Wolves vs Moon --> Moon wins
Frank's Track vs Heaven and Hell --> Heaven and Hell wins
30 hours vs Donda --> 30 Hours wins
No More Parties in LA vs Keep My Spirit Alive --> KMSA wins
Facts vs Jesus Lord --> Jesus Lord wins
Fade vs New Again --> Fade wins
Saint Pablo vs Lord I Need You --> Saint Pablo wins

... vs Pure Souls wins
... vs Come To Life wins
... vs No Child Left Behind wins

10 wins for TLOP vs 8 wins for Donda (11 wins if the last 3 tracks without an opponent count too). And they honestly count cause they are the 3 strongest tracks on Donda, so Donda wins but it's close

NMPILA >>>>> KMSA

TLOP > Donda.

Was thinking that too but NMPILA has 0 replay value for me

Probably my most played song off TLOP, great verses from 2 of the goats, prod by one of the greatest producers. Has endless replay value for me.

Yeah it's one of my most played from the album as well. Why wouldn't it have replay value?

Never seen anyone say that song lacks replay value lol.

Maybe it's just me liking more melodic songs over hard rap

Scary

Scary

TLOP is easily better IMO

The highs on DONDA are def elite but TLOP a better album overall imo

Better production and I enjoy the songwriting on Ye verses more

Less of a task to play the whole thing too, a fun album to listen to fr

TLOP > Donda in every way

Fade is not better than new again.

New Again couldve been better but it sounds kinda unfinished

TLOP

Right now I'll say Donda

But I know a few months down the line I'll probably say TLOP

I’ll say TLOP because it has Saint Pablo, NMPILA, Real Friends, and 30 Hours.

DONDA wins in every category

DONDA better than TLOP in every way

Literally leagues ahead of it

Could judge it best after the tour starts i guess. I didnt like TLOP at first, coming off MBDTF, WTT and YEEZUS but after the tour i got way more appreciation for it
Donda i like from the beginning but maybe also since we just had ye and JIK and its amazing compared to that. Feel it will be even better w a tour/visual experience tho

Can’t believe ppl see Saint Pablo as anything outside of a bonus track, don’t even consider it a part of TLOP cause it got added 6 weeks later

Fun thread. I get why you're having to split tracks (that are already split on the tracklist, lol) since Donda has a few more real songs than TLOP, but I think it skewers things a bit. FSMH 1 and 2 should go up against God Breathed, leaving Famous to face off against Off the Grid, Feedback against Hurricane, etc. Low Lights should pretty much just go up against Donda, Wolves and Frank's track should be combined. But then you'd run out of tracks for TLOP. So I get it.

I'd like to see how the best vs. the best of each album and the worst of the worst of each album rank in a head-to-head, too, rather than just going down the tracklist this way. Compare openers and closers, too, or similarly purposed tracks together (Saint Pablo vs Come to Life?). Donda is just devised as a different type of album, which makes trackbytrack comparisons difficult.

Donda

FOH

I think Donda wins just off the fact that I didn’t realise it was 3 song’s longer than TLOP interludes and all.

27 songs and it’s an easy listen.