Yes. This is the question every gamer Dreads being asked! Its so hard to answer.

My question?

You have 3 games to pick for your favorites of all time. What do you say? Lets talk about it

For me? Its

Vagrant Story
Death Stranding 2
FF6

off the top

dark souls 1
max payne 1
ico

Red Dead Redemption 2
Mass Effect 2
Bioshock

The Witcher 3
Disco Elysium
Splinter Cell: Chaos Theory

Splatoon
Sekiro
Cuphead

Mass Effect
Snake Eater
RE4

Final Fantasy 7

Cyberpunk

Elden Ring (could go to any Fromsoft game tho tbh... except DS2)

rdr2
gta 4
Ghost of Tsushima

Ocarina Of Time/Majora's Mask
Mario Galaxy 2/Odyssey
Fallout/Elder Scrolls in general

HM to Half Life/Portals

RDR2
Bloodborne
Smash Bros Ultimate

I am sorry but you just listed so many games thats more than 3.. post is revoked as of now

1. Smash Bros Ultimate
2. Breath of the Wild
3. The World Ends With You

3 is too hard

Bro named 8 games real for ocarina and majora

finally got around to Ghost of Tushunga + the Iki Island dlc last summer mastapiece game

Silent Hill 2
The World Ends with You
Super Smash Bros. Melee

HMs:
Mother 3
Okami
Persona 4 Golden
Pokemon Mystery Dungeon: Explorers of Sky

F*** I forgot about TWEWY lmao just edited my list

kotor 2

skyrim
new vegas

True we need a top 10 in every genre

Tushunga killing me

halo 3
counter strike source
castlevania sotn

Metal Gear Solid (1998)
Final Fantasy X (2001)
Shenmue (1999)

All came out in the span of 4 years at the turn of the century and games out now can't even compete

just 3 is evil man f*** op