Reply
  • CGI Dog

    cole tried at least

    Terrible bait

  • Nayuta

    I never pressed play on The Fall Off.

    Casino I played twice and have never listened to again.

    I came out of listening to The Fall Off feeling "Yep. That was definitely a J Cole album" and never listened to it again, or felt any desire to return to individual tracks.

  • Don't Be Dumb and It's Been Awful >>>

    Two albums that also took forever to drop but still managed to deliver

  • ·
    1 reply
    Smacked Voodoo

    Don't Be Dumb and It's Been Awful >>>

    Two albums that also took forever to drop but still managed to deliver

    It’s Been Awful still my AOTY

  • i guess casino cos i had a lot of stock on it being great since i loved all of keems albums leading up to it + the five year wait but it was just whatever to me i didnt really revisit it at all

    the fall out im already iffy on cole so i already didnt expect much from it especially with it being 2 discs. if anything it only validated how large the gap was between him and kendrick is

  • ·
    1 reply

    It’s on you in 2026 if you had enough expectation in j cole to be disappointed by him.

  • Maximus

    Casino was a wonderful album anyone disappointed must be mad at their own expectations (lots of ppl expected a hit filled comeback album and not a personal unpacking)

    The Fall Off was one of the most disappointing first listens ever for me because it just felt like a bunch of good safe j cole songs and nothing like a retirement album but after sitting with it I kinda accepted it just feels like if Drake dropped FATD as his retirement album…

    I appreciate this thread because there are many parallels to be drawn especially the hype shared and the expectations diverted but we have to keep in mind that Casino dropped with zero rollout while Fall Off had like 8 years of hype and singles and 2 warm-up tapes.

    You were shocked that j cole made good safe songs?

  • I still bump Casino. Couldn't even finish the mid off

  • BlueDream

    It’s Been Awful still my AOTY

    I hate lights in the ceiling can we stay outside.

  • Ca$ino is a classic
    Haven't listened to a Cole album in full since like 2016

  • people gassed up that keem album for about a day and half before quiet quitting

  • Still bump Casino weekly, don’t listen to the fall off much unfortunately but I might go to the tour

  • Both mid

  • The Fall-Off was disappointing IMO but not because what we got was bad, instead what I really wanted to hear was the album that was really worked on for 10 years. The one with 1985, Lion King On Ice, Everybody Dies etc.

    I felt like the album we got was almost entirely post-beef, or at a minimum post-Off-Season.

  • both albums were great and have songs that stay on repeat. both albums did not need that long of a build but personal lives come first and it did not affect the music experience

    went to Casino tour 2 nights and the show was amazing. still tryna catch Cole on this tour in a different city hopefully or if he runs back a 2nd leg of US dates

  • ·
    1 reply

    While Disc 39 basically ass

    Ca$ino had me hype thinking I would get more than a sob story

  • Leftside

    While Disc 39 basically ass

    Ca$ino had me hype thinking I would get more than a sob story

    He says on TMB that his next album will be more personal?

  • the fall off bro it had 10 years of buildup and was gona be like a masterpiece then turned into his worst s*** like actual s*** from a butt casino iw as v dissapointed with at first but i like it now nad it only got one mediocre or bad song

  • first time im hearing casino was a disappointment

  • cole been teasing the fall off way before keem blew up so, the fall off

  • I liked both. I get the criticisms of The Fall Off with the buildup and being a bit bloated and directionless but it still was enjoyable to me to finally get it

  • ·
    1 reply

    Iceman

  • hold on let's think about this were they THAT bad?

  • 2nd half of both albums suck

  • Jim Halpert

    It’s on you in 2026 if you had enough expectation in j cole to be disappointed by him.

    You must have some sort of expectations of him to continue giving his every release a listen when you haven’t liked any of them