Keep in mind this means the same producers. And in this hypothetical question it does live up to the hype.

Doggystyle easily.

Stillmatic?
A Snoop classic would be nice to see since Nas is currently dropping incredible albums

From this perspective - very true, i'd enjoy the s*** out of another g-funk style classic from Snoop

But as a Nas fan, it would be crazy to hear another Nas classic with Premier, Large Professor, Q-Tip beats

Blueprint 4

Doggystyle 2 with all the same producers and vibes.

Send snoop to his old hood for a year to get that feeling back.

Give him a jerri curl and s***

Doggystyle 2 by far

We already got an Illmatic sequel

Highkey this. It be nice to have snoop restore his own feeling

Doggystyle 2

Snoop rn is the worst best artist of all time

doggystyle 2

because it will be trash and illmatic doesnt need its reputation ruined by a trash sequel

I feel you, but in this context we treating stillmatic as something completely on its own cus producers and lyrics are arguably not as great as it was on illmatic. Illmatic 2 means 10 tracks with the same producers that live up to the hype

Not with the same producers we don't.

I understand this argument but I feel there’s a reason why stillmatic is a derivative to the title of Illmatic just in terms of topic and execution I don’t think it needs to have the same producers to be considered a sequel

Would listen more to Doggystyle 2, but woul prefer Illmatic 2 and in the end listen to it more over time

For some reason,with the right hype and Dre on the boards again,Snoop could probably get back in a certain headspace to make a more mature sequel to Doggystyle.

Neither tbh

"Stillmatic" already exists and is a classic and Snoop has 1 classic and 2 good albums, including the classic, to his name.

Snoop gotta have the worst discography of any legendary rapper, even worse than Em

Dude has a giant discography and other than "Doggystyle" and "The Blue Carpet Treatment" his catalog is mid as f***

Doggystyle isn't that good to me. Illmatic af

FYI Snoop is one of my fave rappers, Tha Last Meal > Doggystyle easily

Both are far past the point of working

Man stop lmfaooooooooooooooooooooo I hate that this is such a popular opinion. Snoop not that bad

Reincarnated alone makes him right lol

He's got hits on most of his solo albums but his albums from the top down are mostly kinda trash, the two mentioned notwithstanding

Em has way lower lows and doesn't even have quite as high highs but he does at least have 3 classics, Snoop has 1 over the span of a nearly 30 year career lol

Doggfather, Doggystle, No Limit Top Dogg, Tha Last Meal, R&G, Blue Carpet, Ego Trippin

All have amazing songs

Also It Was Written is pretty much illmatic 2