Since we are very close to the end of the PS4. I thought I would ask you guys what your top 5 games of all gen are. Mine:

1) Red Dead 2
2) The Witcher 3
3) God of War
4) Bloodborne
5) Horizon Zero Dawn

1. God of War
2. Last of Us Part II
3. Final Fantasy 7 Remake
4. Destiny
5. Breath of the Wild

#5 can be interchangeable with Red Dead 2

persona 5 royal
kh3 + remind
bloodborne
yakuza 0 (like a dragon too, even though it's on ps5/series x)
nier automata

13 sentinels is a very honorable mention

1. Red Dead 2
2. Rainbow Six Siege
3. Risk of Rain 2
4. Breath of the Wild
5. Sekiro

#5 can be interchangeable with Hollowknight

1 Persona 5/Royal
2 Devil May Cry 5/SE
3 Sekiro
4 Witcher 3
5 Overwatch

1) Last of Us 2
2) God of War
3) Rocket League
4) Fall Guys
5) Super Mario Odyssey

(do Switch games even count lol? if not MGSV at 5)

1A: Witcher 3
1B: Red Dead 2
3: Breath of the wild
4: God of War
5: Persona 5 Royal

Just a f***ing fantastic Generation. I could list 5 more perfect games easily

Sakura Wars
Persona 5 Royal
Xenoblade Chronicles 2
Ni No Kuni 2
Apex Legends

Mgsv was on last last gen tho

Ah I gotta get on 13 sentinels at some point

I only played 4 games this gen so this my top 4

God of war
The last of us 1
Cyberpunk
Red dead 2

1) rdr2
2) persona 5
3) witcher 3
4) destiny
5) god of war

Impossible to rank but:

1) Breath of The Wild

4-5) Super Mario Odyssey
Persona 5 Royal
Bloodborne
Nier Automata

Or something like that

damn it was on PS3 huh. I'd still consider it PS4 gen tho

1. Last of Us Part II
2. Red Dead Redemption 2
3. Bloodborne
4. God of War
5. Spider-Man

I'll put my top 10 then try to narrow it down to 5.
In no order.

1. MGSV
2. Dark Souls 3
3. Bloodborne
4. Red Dead Redemption 2
5. Final Fantasy XV
6. The Last Of Us Part II
7. Uncharted 4
8. Death Stranding
9. Persona 5
10. God of War

1. Resident Evil 2 Remake
2. Zelda BOTW
3. Hollow Knight
4. Witcher 3
5. Smash Bros Ultimate

the last of us 2
bloodborne
rdr2
hollow knight
death stranding

1 God of war
2 Witcher 3
3 Overwatch
4 Mario Odyssey
5 Red Dead 2

A lot of games I haven't played yet though

1. Final Fantasy 15
2. Spider-Man
3. Black Ops 3
4. Naruto Storm 4
5.

Top 5:
1. The Witcher 3
2. Red Dead Redemption 2
3. Bloodborne
4. Disco Elysium
5. Hitman Season 1&2

HM(s):
6. The Last of Us pt. II
7. Legend of Zelda: BOTW
8. Divinity: OS2
9. Persona 5: Royal

Most Underrated:
10. Prey

prey, metro exodus and deus ex MD some underrated gems. Immersive sims

1. Tlou2
2. God of war
3. Bloodborne
4. Mario Odyssey
5. RDR2

Rocket League
Apex Legends
Sekiro: Shadows Die Twice
Yakuza: Like a Dragon (this one was a next gen launch title but it still came out on last gen so i’m including it)
Red Dead Redemption 2

1. God of War
2. Bloodborne
3. Uncharted 4
4. RDR 2 (would be third if the gameplay was designed better)

Nothing else I've played comes as close to perfect as those four do, so I'm leaving my fifth spot blank for now. Still have to play a bunch of games like TLOU 1+2, Sekiro, RE2, GoT