Reply
  • Apr 25, 2022
    ·
    2 replies

    Call Me If You Get Lost

    Ima huge Tyler stan, but that album is a glorified mixtape

    It has its moments, but it’s not as consistent as any of his previous albums (sans Cherry Bomb)

  • The Darkest Angel

    Don't forget MDM, Its not on par with that. Abel still has it in him to make something special so personally I won't give up

    xotwod

    true lowkey

    its dead not on par with MDM when i think about it,

    but Dawn has MOMENTS of greatness like real greatness

    i think the reception that @op is talking about around Dawn, isn't that it's seen as bad

    he's always found success in finding a balance between pleasing his hardcore old fans and his new core audience that make up the bulk of his streams/merch sales/etc

    but i think Dawn was him trying to do that, while also making music for himself

    that's why i like it, but i think didnt resonate with everyone the way after hours did on release

  • Apr 25, 2022

    I thought everyone fw this pusha album, it’s dope af

  • Apr 25, 2022
    ·
    1 reply
    deleteduser2863

    Call Me If You Get Lost

    Ima huge Tyler stan, but that album is a glorified mixtape

    It has its moments, but it’s not as consistent as any of his previous albums (sans Cherry Bomb)

    i mean tyler literally presented it as a glorified mixtape, so i guess no one was surprised lol

  • Apr 25, 2022
    ·
    2 replies
    ch33zey

    An Evening With Silk Sonic should've been seen as a classic the moment it dropped
    Beyonce's Lion King soundtrack should've gotten more praise than it did
    More Life is Drake's second best project

    Things aren’t able to be considered classic until 7-10 years after they drop. Classic means standing the test of time

  • Mmm Hmm 😆
    Apr 25, 2022

    Negativity produces more dings

  • Apr 25, 2022
    ·
    1 reply
    JJThaJuiceman

    Pablo. People absolutely love it, so much so calling it top 3 ye. The whole era is iconic as f***, but the album itself was just so messy and all over the place, it’s never clicked with me. Some great moments, but also a lot of bad ones that if anyone else made, the reception wouldn’t be as positive.

    It’s not my least favorite ye project, but it’s the one I scratch my head and wonder how people say it’s better than his earlier work. (His stuff post- Pablo I could understand at least)

    a lot of ppl say this over and over again but its true

    pablo was a lot of pals first kanye release they got to be apart of, add that with this being the first of many to come "public" listening parties

    pablo kicked off a lot of s*** for the second half of his career, that are now seen as regular ye antics, but weren't really as much of a thing until that era

  • Mmm Hmm 😆
    Apr 25, 2022
    The Darkest Angel

    And keep in mind reception could change over time. Just give it a while and people might come around. I have a feeling Dawn FM is going to be like Views, hated on release but over time became a classic

    Who hated on DawnFM besides ktt?

    S*** is possibly aoty

  • Apr 25, 2022

    seeing people shift on WLR in real time was a sight to see

  • Apr 25, 2022
    ·
    1 reply
    El Nigga

    Yeah more so looking back, initial reaction was expected but its surprising how much KTT now loves that album. It's the new Yeezus around here(everybody's favorite Ye album)

    Pablo birthed a whole generation of new Ye fans tbh that’s why I see why people love it so much plus that era of life was perfect for a lot of us but as an album it’s just an 8/10 and the start of him being all over the place. There’s lots of eh tracks on there in hindsight

  • deleteduser2863

    Call Me If You Get Lost

    Ima huge Tyler stan, but that album is a glorified mixtape

    It has its moments, but it’s not as consistent as any of his previous albums (sans Cherry Bomb)

    nothing wrong with a mixtape, there's mixtapes that are hard as f***

    but feels like a step back from FB and Igor combo

    i love some songs on that record, but not listening to every song

    actually ur lowkey right, i feel like reception would be so insane if he just released it as a "mixtape" and did smaller shows the major cities, before going back to festival and arena circuit

  • Apr 25, 2022
    Cherrywine

    Things aren’t able to be considered classic until 7-10 years after they drop. Classic means standing the test of time

  • Apr 25, 2022
    ·
    1 reply
    JeffersonSteelflex

    Pablo birthed a whole generation of new Ye fans tbh that’s why I see why people love it so much plus that era of life was perfect for a lot of us but as an album it’s just an 8/10 and the start of him being all over the place. There’s lots of eh tracks on there in hindsight

    8/10 is still really damn good

  • Apr 25, 2022
    ·
    1 reply

    Could not understand the love Cudi got for MOTM 3. S*** was same old same old. Weak Cudi. Idk. At least it's basically forgotten at this point

  • Apr 25, 2022
    MoonMan

    Could not understand the love Cudi got for MOTM 3. S*** was same old same old. Weak Cudi. Idk. At least it's basically forgotten at this point

    was a pretty good first listen, but I can barely go back to that album if not at all

  • black hedi slimane

    8/10 is still really damn good

    Yeah don’t get me wrong it’s a good album. The messy style worked here but it’s honestly not better than KSG or Donda imo

  • Apr 25, 2022

    Dawn threw me waaaay off

  • Apr 25, 2022
    ·
    1 reply

    Dawn reception was weird

    I don’t get how some ppl really thought it was a crazy ass album

    Like I don’t hate it or anything, but some of y’all act like it blew After Hours or even Starboy out the water is wild to me

  • Apr 25, 2022
    ·
    2 replies

    Twigs did not drop her best work.

  • Apr 25, 2022
    ·
    1 reply
    best poster

    Twigs did not drop her best work.

    that s*** was garbage lmao

  • Apr 25, 2022
    Freight

    DAMN. General consensus seems to have come around though. Most opinions on it I see now are that it was a solid album rather than the masterpiece people were making it out to be.

    people who try to paint DAMN as his best project or a masterpiece are usually stans, or people coping because they don't like GKMC or TPAB as much as most people do

  • Apr 25, 2022
    ·
    1 reply
    cold mountain

    that s*** was garbage lmao

    Tf

  • Apr 25, 2022
    ·
    1 reply
    Childhood

    Dawn reception was weird

    I don’t get how some ppl really thought it was a crazy ass album

    Like I don’t hate it or anything, but some of y’all act like it blew After Hours or even Starboy out the water is wild to me

    Definitely blew Starboy out the water

    AH its close but Dawn just edges it for me

  • Apr 25, 2022
    Mesaih

    Tf

    was the messiest most poorly composed album that i heard all year, i had no clue what you niggas were seeing in that project

    a blemish in an otherwise pretty spotless discography

  • Apr 25, 2022
    ·
    1 reply

    All of the big 3’s critical reception for the past few albums have been justified.

1
...
3
4
5
...
13