Yall kind of exaggerating with how much the anime misses the mark with CSM. The manga is pretty brutal at a certain point and has tid bits of humor to give it some breathing room.
I like the dark and grounded atmosphere the studio gave us for the series It matches the art style nicely.
So would you say that csm anime still isnât quite doing the manga justice despite it being good?
Was gonna consume this via anime but I might just read the manga
We're in the first episodes so its hard to say, and the manga at this point still hadnt shown its potential, but i will say that after episode 2, i find it hard for mappa to match the batshit insane s*** that happens later on. The best way i can say this is that the anime most probably wont be a worthy alternative to the manga, but at best a good anime adaptation of csm, if you get what im saying. So yeah, id say read it. I suggest reading goodbye eri too to get a better idea of fujimoto's style if you havent. its a short story, around 180 pages or so and his best work yet imo
The anime is good. Some people are cooming too hard for it. That's about it. Ignore the fandom lol as with any other Shonen fandom
Yea I feel itâs definitely getting gassed. Itâs high quality s*** tho and I usually hate shonen
We're in the first episodes so its hard to say, and the manga at this point still hadnt shown its potential, but i will say that after episode 2, i find it hard for mappa to match the batshit insane s*** that happens later on. The best way i can say this is that the anime most probably wont be a worthy alternative to the manga, but at best a good anime adaptation of csm, if you get what im saying. So yeah, id say read it. I suggest reading goodbye eri too to get a better idea of fujimoto's style if you havent. its a short story, around 180 pages or so and his best work yet imo
I love short condensed stories, will definitely check out the other one. Thanks
So would you say that csm anime still isnât quite doing the manga justice despite it being good?
Was gonna consume this via anime but I might just read the manga
I think you should form your own opinion because there will be people that so far disagree with him as much as some might agree . I personally think the anime medium is amazing so far and fleshed out elements that the manga medium didnât , but vice verse the manga also has experiences exclusive to that medium
Seeing folks on twitter talking about csm anime as if it were the pinnacle of cinema overanalyzing and overhyping every shot is funny ngl, you have denji and aki walking down a street shot from the side with some ppl blurred on a backrgound mfs think its some top 5 quentin tarantino shot. Not that the anime is mid, but id say some of my biggest fears are coming to fruition, those being that the charm and craziness of the manga is being diluted in the anime. The op and the eds are the only times i felt that fujimoto trademark tbh
I also feel like itâs easier for us to have this perspective as manga readers but in every forum or people i personally know . They are having the exact same âwtfâ is happening response i had when i first read it, it just happens to be directed beautifully as well . I think those elements are still sticking with the vast majority of watchers .
I think you should form your own opinion because there will be people that so far disagree with him as much as some might agree . I personally think the anime medium is amazing so far and fleshed out elements that the manga medium didnât , but vice verse the manga also has experiences exclusive to that medium
You right, ima get that manga for sure
I have never seen people so consumed with others opinion of an anime . I am glad I didn't read the manga yet because there is so much constant comparison here
I have never seen people so consumed with others opinion of an anime . I am glad I didn't read the manga yet because there is so much constant comparison here
Lol this YouTuber literally got death threats from manga readers about a joke of shipping a couple. Itâs really personal for some groups outside of just the quality of the adaptation
Makima and Denji
Lol this YouTuber literally got death threats from manga readers about a joke of shipping a couple. Itâs really personal for some groups outside of just the quality of the adaptation
Makima and Denji
yeah I was like why all this mofos taking this one so serious . I am focused on Golden Kamuy though
I also feel like itâs easier for us to have this perspective as manga readers but in every forum or people i personally know . They are having the exact same âwtfâ is happening response i had when i first read it, it just happens to be directed beautifully as well . I think those elements are still sticking with the vast majority of watchers .
I mean, that's why i said its a good adaptation. For all intents and purposes it does a very good job at translating the manga into an animated form. Mine were the considerations of someone who is so enamoured with the author's style that is being a bit harsher on the anime, but that's not to say the anime is bad or even just alright. Its geniunely good and of course it should, they spent a ton of resources on it and they got lots of amazing freelance animators working on this. Also i wasnt trying to sound definitive on my judgement so if i did i apologize for that, we're on episode 2 and there's lots to go still. Also it all started in jest, i wasnt appalled at twitter opinions, i never am, just found them hilarious that's all
Lol this YouTuber literally got death threats from manga readers about a joke of shipping a couple. Itâs really personal for some groups outside of just the quality of the adaptation
Makima and Denji
Reminds me of the dudes woofing at makima's va, weirdo s***
I mean, that's why i said its a good adaptation. For all intents and purposes it does a very good job at translating the manga into an animated form. Mine were the considerations of someone who is so enamoured with the author's style that is being a bit harsher on the anime, but that's not to say the anime is bad or even just alright. Its geniunely good and of course it should, they spent a ton of resources on it and they got lots of amazing freelance animators working on this. Also i wasnt trying to sound definitive on my judgement so if i did i apologize for that, we're on episode 2 and there's lots to go still. Also it all started in jest, i wasnt appalled at twitter opinions, i never am, just found them hilarious that's all
Got ya, Your worry is still 100% valid and people are legit doing it unironically. My statements in general was more so just bringing the other half of it for a people not hip to both sides of the discourse. Also your prediction is def reasonable . Itâs a good chance that the bat devil s*** for example could be awesome but not give the same eye raising experience as the manga . That panel of its reveal is legit terrifying . We are all in prediction mode but the discourse is fun week to week to see how they handle these moments we love so much
is eminence in shadow good?
Any Junji Ito fans? Went down a uzumaki rabbit hole last night.
Whatâs yâallâs favorite work by him?
I mean the anime has a near 9.0 rating on MAL with 700k users logging scores for it. Thatâs a pretty good marker for the real world opinion.
I donât think anime adaptations need to be 1:1 with the manga but if that many people are rating this that highly, itâs clearly a great adaptation, differences or not.
all the media says is "chainsawman, jujutsu kaisen, demon slayer, my hero academia", i just wanna grill for god's sake
Any Junji Ito fans? Went down a uzumaki rabbit hole last night.
Whatâs yâallâs favorite work by him?
Tomie for sure
Who was there when we were talking about MAPPAâs Terror in Resonance
Times are different nowâŚ