Opinions. Mofos be hating.

Smells caccy itt

What instrument do they play

Rappers are rappers and that’s okay

Some of them

yes

Yup

I don't play any instrument. I wanna learn how to play the piano but I stayed off it for a year because of a life crisis.

Yes

Are singers musicians

I play the piano but I don't really consider myself a musician

Pretty horrible to say that ADELE/BEYONCE/MJ/THE WEEKND aren't msuicans because they don't play an instrument.

Yes. Your voice is an instrument. Rappers are vocalists. Therefore, rappers are musicians.

Lock thread

lol what in the ben shapiro type of question is that?
Rappers are musicians whether they understand music theory or not, can structure a song or not, even if they make no use of melody at all.
you don't need a degree to make a track. even the rap songs i hate, i still consider music.

Any respected musician knows that all forms of music are valid

You need rhythm to rap
Rhythm is a huge part of music

they’re singers. Singers can be the mfs in your church choir

semantics is boring

Yes. this is only debatable to ben shapiro viewers

yes. it’s dumb to think our voices aren’t instruments that take skill to control the way singers and rappers use them.

💯 I saw someone on Youtube saying some 💩 that rappers aren't musicians so I had to come on KTT2.

Musicians are people that make music

Without a rapper/singer the song would literally just be the instrumental

Your voice is an instrument

Pretty horrible to say that JAY-Z/KENDRICK LAMAR/NAS/LIL WAYNE aren’t musicians because they don’t “play an instrument” (even though they do; their voices)

Youtube

Without rappers/singers the instrumental would still be…music?

Without the instrumental the “song” would be spoken word

Which makes the producers the musicians, they make the music

Just my opinion though. I think the term y’all are looking for is vocalist or recording artist

yeah