I made a thread similar to this on Ktt 1, but that was 9 years ago. It’s time to rehash it. The premise is simple. Jay Electronica is the best rapper of all time, and all of the arguments otherwise are simply too weak to consider. Previously, it was the idea that he didn’t have enough songs, which was as complete nonsense then as it is now. He probably has close to 150 unique songs and feature verses, more than enough to make a full judgment. The other primary argument was that he didn’t have an album. Well now he arguably has 2, despite one being an unfinished leak, so that argument is out the window.
What makes him the best is simple. All you need to do is listen to the song knights of the roundtable, and hear what Hov is saying on the vocal sample. It’s all about human emotions. There is no rapper past or present that has so deftly been able to speak to the shared emotional experience of humans. Love, pain, loss, anxiety, wanting to be accepted etc., are feelings that we can all relate to in some form or another, and Jay Elect encapsulates them better than anyone. He gets a bad rep from some trolls as a lyrical/miracle/spiritual rapper, but this has never been true. His rhyme schemes, delivery, and words are often simple, to the point and rely much more on appealing to emotion than they do to confusing the listener or making them want to look some s*** up on rapgenius.
However, that’s not to say that that is the extent of his skill as a rapper. On a bar for bar basis, his wordplay, storytelling, metaphors/similies and whatever other lyrical device you might choose are, at his peak compared to the peak of other rappers, superior.
If you aren’t familiar with his music at this point and are itching to write this off as nonsense, I can show you exactly what songs and verses to check out in order to change your mind. If you have listened to his music and don’t agree, I need to hear your argument against it show I can show you why you’re wrong
this isn't even an argument you didn't say anything at all in this long winded quarter assed post, like you said nothing constructive or of any value, nothing. ha u dumb ha, b****es really think they smart. I want an a***ysis not a synopsis.
I see this thread has resorted to trolling
I found synopsis friend
I loved Jay E when I was young and always hated the posthumous BIG projects. But there’s gonna be a day where you look in the mirror and ask yourself: “Do I want to listen to this 40 year old quoting Big lyrics mixed with the Quran? Or should I just listen to the albums of Big’s old vocals that Puff put over awful early 2000s beats?” And I have to think when you get there, you’ll reach the same conclusion I did
imagine disrespecting Jay ElecHanukka granada tramadol alhamdulillah Panama
Ironically OP invited disrespect onto his favorite artist by trying to say he’s objectively the best which is just completely false
i would replace Nas with KA
nas is a pioneer and legend but he not really crazy like that imo
he goes the hardest out of those and Lupe literally called him his master
As if Nas didn't wash Hov on Success with deeper bars, more raw flow, and a cooler presence on the track
Y'all stay underrating and disrespecting Nas
All our Santas carried them hammers
Our guidance counselors was talented scramblers
Spiritual leaders, ran a number hold
Tycoons moved in vests, and kept a money roll
We brought the noise, gun’ll bust, none of us altar boys
With army issue harm a tissue, we ain't walk with toys
The rawest from any war is one if New York deploys
Made Orphan Annies like all the families court destroys
It's the elder man, sold things pray I never sell again
Son trust, bum rush if they ain't let us in
The lepers infected us, said it was medicine
Where life's tribal, fight for survival, that's all it's ever been
Nothing blessed, even the bonds of friends are tested
Would you surrender if you did it but your man's arrested?
Our peacekeepers bust they guns repeated
Our caregivers stole everything we needed
It's D-Day, each week in BK you see us here grimacin'
Never marinate on beef you don't plan on finishin'
'Cause every effort's for the record, we ain't here scrimmagin'
Soon as son start shinin', they tryna diminish him
They nay behavior made us braver, thicker armor
Ain't kill who you aimed at, came back quick as karma
So par, so far haven't missed in the midst of drama
Now I notice 'em pick me up at they lowest, it's a honor
A monk swore a vow of silence to the jakes
Our yogis did stretches upstate
Our Sir Lancelot's at round tables cuttin' eighths
Our mogul just caught another case
Started with less, then progressed to bare minimum
Can't just happen upon no chips, gotta be here winnin' em
That's what food is for, hungry if you lose or draw
Every session I'm pressin' to press jewels galore
Used to violate tryin' make, that's what every move was for
The only particular mission of the crew was accruin' more
With impressive steel, dressed to kill, you know the lifestyle
Hit the curb to serve the early bird, and the night owl
To fix these broken pockets, had to break some hearts
Can't be bothered to hit your target, gotta make some marks
Quiet and frigid disposition, growin' up in the cold
Surprised I ain't get high from what I was low enough to behold
Like when Pops shot at the neighbor's shop, put one in his head
He knew how he grew me, threw me the gun, a hundred, and fled
Didn't play, 'fore po' arose dispose of exhibit A
How I was raised, I aged a few years in a day
If not elite, didn't eat if you didn't pray
As much as I heal, had to deal, all my scars are here to stay
Our senseis spent days peddling
Our heroes sold heroin
Tried the stove top to hop off the old block
None chipped in to save me
During my reign what I showered is gifts for the baby
Gears of war years before I enlisted with Navy
Too many struggling loved ones to ever sit in Mercedes
From that population where spread love's the obligation
For a good span my hood ran like a sovereign nation
But then D-Day planes dropped off 'caine to freeways
Them pounds made battlegrounds in tenements and PJs
For economy many fought D's in the street disastrous
Ironically many bought a Jesus piece or a Lazarus
Even friends in the frenzy became ravenous
Brothers named universal, wise, supreme became savages
It's said the common thread with our enemies
Is we was all men in need with no amenities
Couldn't sit in peace, we each hit the streets for remedies
Through the hatred accumulated a hundred arms, we was centipedes
The stress of empty pantries kept us antsy
And all our essentials essentially in a shanty
Could give scripture but that big picture is what you can't see
Every grain I spelt is what helped enhance me
Went from gun waving to saving lives
Now I give sight to the blind just for the 85
That's what I was in the line of scrimmage
Lost some folks of course, that growth redefined percentage
Doomed in the womb, surprised I ain't see a hanger
Start questioning affection when all you see is anger
But now I'm in good hands
Surrounded by good women, good babies, good mans
I'm in good hands
Surrounded by good women, good babies, good mans
This took sacrifice, much loss before the gain
Paid a drastic price, misfortune and disdain
Framed a shattered life, the forfeits and the pain
All the saddest sights, the coffins and the stains
On days wish I could save the children that we was
Be there spare they eyes from all the killings and the d****
Steppin' and protectin' them from feelin' any slugs
Many ways mediate, the savior healin' any grudge
'Cause in and out the lab bouts was bad, so habits grew
The steel cold, you don't grow real old actin' new
And you can count from all my accounts, the stats is true
To think some was tickled pink when we was beat black and blue
A knave to say we show it sympathy cause I know essentially
All the dastard actions that was happenin', I was meant to see
Dug a lot of work when I was broke and inoperative
Felt a lot of hurt before I spoke this provocative
Heart was ice for that cream tryin' to scoop money
Now breathe for seeds, whether you throw dirt or root for me
Those three verses alone
You're lying, or wrong, or your argument is dumb, could also be not coherent enough. Pick one. Hella corny, but think about it.
You're lying, or wrong, or your argument is dumb, could also be not coherent enough. Pick one. Hella corny, but think about it.
that’s what I’m sayin, bro is definitely trolling
Lmao I was out of it for a while and came back
It’s the “objectivity” that dude tries to present that kind of gets to me and makes me want to keep arguing it. Plus dude been on here forever so I don’t think of him as a troll
You're def a troll tho
You're def a troll tho
Fam even if I am, this topic is serious to me and idk why you won’t offer a solid explanation of your point instead of these one liners. Between you and me I like to rustle the jimmies of drake stans every now and then, but my presence on this site isn’t strictly on some troll s***, I’ve been here since 07 and I’ve known of you and had respect for you for a decade. I definitely like to have fun on here but this isn’t really one of those times, I’m trying to understand your point and legitimately argue against it
I love Jay Elec’s body of work so much. Getting Act 2 was a really special moment for me and Real Magic in particular has really been helping me with my current mind state
I would never argue with someone saying he was their GOAT
The reason I’m arguing with you is because you’re saying so firmly that he’s the objective GOAT. And I have two issues with that because it’s very clear to me that 1. There is no GOAT and 2. If we are to try and use objective measurements to somehow determine a true GOAT, it cannot under any circumstances be Jay Electronica.
You really connect with dude and I respect that. The artist who connected with me most in the blog era was Charles Hamilton. I’ve spoken with him directly multiple times and to me, he put out at least 20 perfect classic albums in 2008 and 2009 alone. He has made more music than anyone in history besides Lil B and Viper (which are debatable) and in my opinion he has more classic albums than any other rapper has albums.
But am I going to make a thread saying he’s the objective GOAT just because I connect with him most, just because he saved my life on multiple occasions? No because I’m not delusional. Once you try to make it objective, all this “well this song is better” stuff goes out the window. The closest we can get to objectivity in music is mass subjectivity. That’s just the fact of the matter. You saying Better In Tune With The Infinite is better than Ice Ice Baby means less than nothing if we are attempting to take it into an objective place
Your desire to make art objective is understandable, but it’s also surprising to me that you don’t see how pointless and futile it is
If you think there’s an objective GOAT then that’s you
But then to think that the answer would be Jay Electronica, an answer clearly based on your feelings and no objective measures? Lmao maybe you are trolling me
Fam even if I am, this topic is serious to me and idk why you won’t offer a solid explanation of your point instead of these one liners. Between you and me I like to rustle the jimmies of drake stans every now and then, but my presence on this site isn’t strictly on some troll s***, I’ve been here since 07 and I’ve known of you and had respect for you for a decade. I definitely like to have fun on here but this isn’t really one of those times, I’m trying to understand your point and legitimately argue against it
I love Jay Elec’s body of work so much. Getting Act 2 was a really special moment for me and Real Magic in particular has really been helping me with my current mind state
I would never argue with someone saying he was their GOAT
The reason I’m arguing with you is because you’re saying so firmly that he’s the objective GOAT. And I have two issues with that because it’s very clear to me that 1. There is no GOAT and 2. If we are to try and use objective measurements to somehow determine a true GOAT, it cannot under any circumstances be Jay Electronica.
You really connect with dude and I respect that. The artist who connected with me most in the blog era was Charles Hamilton. I’ve spoken with him directly multiple times and to me, he put out at least 20 perfect classic albums in 2008 and 2009 alone. He has made more music than anyone in history besides Lil B and Viper (which are debatable) and in my opinion he has more classic albums than any other rapper has albums.
But am I going to make a thread saying he’s the objective GOAT just because I connect with him most, just because he saved my life on multiple occasions? No because I’m not delusional. Once you try to make it objective, all this “well this song is better” stuff goes out the window. The closest we can get to objectivity in music is mass subjectivity. That’s just the fact of the matter. You saying Better In Tune With The Infinite is better than Ice Ice Baby means less than nothing if we are attempting to take it into an objective place
Your desire to make art objective is understandable, but it’s also surprising to me that you don’t see how pointless and futile it is
If you think there’s an objective GOAT then that’s you
But then to think that the answer would be Jay Electronica, an answer clearly based on your feelings and no objective measures? Lmao maybe you are trolling me
The objective measure is his rapping ability.
The objective measure is his rapping ability.
Please enlighten me on how you objectively measure rapping ability. Oh that’s right, you f***ing can’t, and you’re not going to offer an explanation on how you can, you’re going to give another one liner that you think is clever
You're lying, or wrong, or your argument is dumb, could also be not coherent enough. Pick one. Hella corny, but think about it.
He has the same amount of albums as Biggie
Biggie’s albums reached a worldwide audience and were huge commercial successes with actual hit singles. Also,both of his albums are 100% complete with one of them being a classic double album. Not the same
Nah he lacks emotion in his delivery tho
Andre gotta be the best hip hop artist of all time rapping and singing hands down
jay is nice and I mean like top 10 nice for me personally but shiny suit theory he rapped his ass of but hov washed him off delivery alone
Please enlighten me on how you objectively measure rapping ability. Oh that’s right, you f***ing can’t, and you’re not going to offer an explanation on how you can, you’re going to give another one liner that you think is clever

This is only funny because it’s true
Please enlighten me on how you objectively measure rapping ability. Oh that’s right, you f***ing can’t, and you’re not going to offer an explanation on how you can, you’re going to give another one liner that you think is clever
dam.
Please enlighten me on how you objectively measure rapping ability. Oh that’s right, you f***ing can’t, and you’re not going to offer an explanation on how you can, you’re going to give another one liner that you think is clever
I got into an argument with Lupe on Twitter about the same thing. People who are convinced there is one way to rap well will never get it
Lol why he sum that nigga whole life up in one post
it really does describe his post history, legendary exposal.
it really does describe his post history, legendary exposal.
The fact he found a way to use f***ing Jay Electronica to self-validate is amazing tbh
Fam even if I am, this topic is serious to me and idk why you won’t offer a solid explanation of your point instead of these one liners. Between you and me I like to rustle the jimmies of drake stans every now and then, but my presence on this site isn’t strictly on some troll s***, I’ve been here since 07 and I’ve known of you and had respect for you for a decade. I definitely like to have fun on here but this isn’t really one of those times, I’m trying to understand your point and legitimately argue against it
I love Jay Elec’s body of work so much. Getting Act 2 was a really special moment for me and Real Magic in particular has really been helping me with my current mind state
I would never argue with someone saying he was their GOAT
The reason I’m arguing with you is because you’re saying so firmly that he’s the objective GOAT. And I have two issues with that because it’s very clear to me that 1. There is no GOAT and 2. If we are to try and use objective measurements to somehow determine a true GOAT, it cannot under any circumstances be Jay Electronica.
You really connect with dude and I respect that. The artist who connected with me most in the blog era was Charles Hamilton. I’ve spoken with him directly multiple times and to me, he put out at least 20 perfect classic albums in 2008 and 2009 alone. He has made more music than anyone in history besides Lil B and Viper (which are debatable) and in my opinion he has more classic albums than any other rapper has albums.
But am I going to make a thread saying he’s the objective GOAT just because I connect with him most, just because he saved my life on multiple occasions? No because I’m not delusional. Once you try to make it objective, all this “well this song is better” stuff goes out the window. The closest we can get to objectivity in music is mass subjectivity. That’s just the fact of the matter. You saying Better In Tune With The Infinite is better than Ice Ice Baby means less than nothing if we are attempting to take it into an objective place
Your desire to make art objective is understandable, but it’s also surprising to me that you don’t see how pointless and futile it is
If you think there’s an objective GOAT then that’s you
But then to think that the answer would be Jay Electronica, an answer clearly based on your feelings and no objective measures? Lmao maybe you are trolling me
post way too real
he the best at connecting with the human experience yet his human reach is so limited