rvi 🐸Oct 31, 2019·1 reply
ChildhoodBauhaus, Siouxsie, and Cure is like Gothic s***
Smiths and Echo are Jangle Pop
New Order is New Wave
Talking Heads are just bad
just because they fall into the gothic of new wave category or they changed styles later doesnt mean they arent post punk also
Siouxsie and The Banshees are one of THE seminal post punk bands. if you say they arent post punk its just objectively wrong. they will be mentioned in almost any article about the genre I'll bet
Smiths are definitely not post punk though lol.
- rvi 🐸Oct 31, 2019
also, post punk is one of those genres where there is a lot of overlap. so imo its very worth talking about bands that may not be 100% pure post punk
Oct 31, 2019·edited·1 replyrvijust because they fall into the gothic of new wave category or they changed styles later doesnt mean they arent post punk also
Siouxsie and The Banshees are one of THE seminal post punk bands. if you say they arent post punk its just objectively wrong. they will be mentioned in almost any article about the genre I'll bet
Smiths are definitely not post punk though lol.
It’s iffy about the smiths lol. I threw them in there cause ya know? Lol. They have some elements of it in some songs but I agree. Mostly alotta jangle/indie ish
- rvi 🐸Oct 31, 2019·2 repliescaptainrayy· edited
It’s iffy about the smiths lol. I threw them in there cause ya know? Lol. They have some elements of it in some songs but I agree. Mostly alotta jangle/indie ish
for a second i thought you meant you threw Eminem in there
- Oct 31, 2019rvi
for a second i thought you meant you threw Eminem in there
Lmfaoooo
Oct 31, 2019public image
pneu ❕Oct 31, 2019rvifor a second i thought you meant you threw Eminem in there
- Oct 31, 2019Childhood
Listen to Clan of Xymox and pretty much all of 80’s 4AD
80s 4AD
- Oct 31, 2019·1 replypneu
They all come under post punk lol.
Gothic Rock is an offspring of Post Punk.
A band can have multiple genre descriptions.
Only one I agree with here is The Smiths but they can still be classified as post punk. (Their first album anyways)
Gothic I’ll admit has a lot of overlap but like New Wave became a very distinctive thing outside of Post Punk.
New Order was really only that for their first album in transition from the end of Joy Division and with hints on PCL with songs like We All Stand. By the time Technique released, it was a very different thing from the majority of those artists origin.
If I was talking about origin then yeah, almost all these musicians came from a punk leaning background. That’s just something you can’t deny
Oct 31, 2019Television, Johnny Thunders, The Smiths
- Oct 31, 2019
Patti Smith a legend too
- pneu ❕Oct 31, 2019·editedChildhood
Gothic I’ll admit has a lot of overlap but like New Wave became a very distinctive thing outside of Post Punk.
New Order was really only that for their first album in transition from the end of Joy Division and with hints on PCL with songs like We All Stand. By the time Technique released, it was a very different thing from the majority of those artists origin.
If I was talking about origin then yeah, almost all these musicians came from a punk leaning background. That’s just something you can’t deny
Yeah but that's if we are talking about specific albums.
The bands mentioned are all Post Punk, It's such a broad genre with so many offsprings that it's hard to really say what is or isn't/
There's so many elements that make up post punk from the vocals, to the atmospheric production, drums and bass, Interweaving guitar lines.
Like the genre was constantly expanding from 70s to mid 80s.
New Wave took heavy influence from Post Punk so most just group them together.
I do see what you mean though, your not really wrong.
Oct 31, 2019
Lil ZayI’m listening to Siouxsie & the Banshees right now but I want some other s*** to check out
if you're looking for some crazy, contemporary s***:
black midi – schlagenheim
if you want to hear (what i think) is the best post-punk release of all time:
this heat – deceit