Mar 31, 2024F*** no Lmaooo
Mar 31, 2024·1 reply
BrandonMShe not touching R. Kelly, who is definitely up there with the ones mentioned but I think she is in his hemisphere somewhere so close.
???
Mar 31, 2024
e tIf the artists you mentioned are Tier 1, she’s Tier 1.5
More like Tier 2 because Taylor Swift is better
Mar 31, 2024
rvitbf its a lot harder for female artists to appeal to male fans on a broad level than vice versa
more black men love beyonce more than white men even liking Taylor (unless they're....yk)
- Mar 31, 2024·3 repliesXANTA
???
I'm saying I think r. Kelly is next after those ppl mentioned in the op and that she is below him, so I guess she is close to them but not quite.
Mar 31, 2024I feel like Prince and Stevie are on their own planet. It’s extremely difficult to compare them to other artists because it can become apples to oranges very easily.
Beyonce is a goat for sure and generational talent tho.
Mar 31, 2024Nah cmon lool
Mar 31, 2024No but MJ also isn’t in that league
It’s Stevie, Prince, Curtis, Marvin, and Teddy and then maybe Mike
Mar 31, 2024·1 replyLmfao
Mar 31, 2024Yes
Mar 31, 2024
bladeecityput any of those guys you listed in an empty room with a casio piano and they will put on an amazing show for you. idk if beyonce can do that
She can sing and dance her ass off in a really big room, aka stadiums so she’d probably do alright in an empty room
Mar 31, 2024
MidzyThread title still so crazy
Why is the former boy band member up there with Prince and Stevie..
Mar 31, 2024KozControlMen love Aaliyah, Sade Erykah, Lauryn Brandy etc
It’s all about the content.
Beyoncés music leans so feminist heavy it feels like it’s meant for men to not want to listen to it
Like it was engineered to turn men off to it
is beyonce scaring the bros music?
Mar 31, 2024Hypothetically If Beyoncé played instruments and wrote and produced all her songs, would she be considered the greatest artist of all time?
Mar 31, 2024Hell no
- Mar 31, 2024Plight
Lmfao
Mar 31, 2024KozControlMen love Aaliyah, Sade Erykah, Lauryn Brandy etc
It’s all about the content.
Beyoncés music leans so feminist heavy it feels like it’s meant for men to not want to listen to it
Like it was engineered to turn men off to it
nah her music is just not that good when compared to these artists.
Mar 31, 2024No
Mar 31, 2024·2 repliesLmfao she makes a faux country album like JT did with MOTW.
We try to put her up there with the greatest
Mar 31, 2024·1 replyvorioxprince and stevie don’t belong in this conversation at all because they are in an echelon entirely above like idek why those are the artists you chose lmfao like you’re grouping great musicians with pop stars, big difference. shows a fundamental misunderstanding of the stakes tbh. mj though? sure why not. not talking sales/commercial prowess here either, i’m talking about musicianship and artistry
What a groundbreaking revelation
A prince stan downplaying MJs ability as an artist.. because he didn’t play guitar?
“Musicianship and artistry” be fr
- Mar 31, 2024Midzy
Thread title still so crazy
Why is the former boy band member up there with Prince and Stevie..
Took you a year to come up with that
Yall gotta do better man. Miserable troll
Mar 31, 2024·1 replyPrince was a different beast. He dropped constant heat for more than a decade, like back-to-back generation defining 'definition of perfect' albums like Sign o the Times.
BEYONCÉ was an 8/10, Lemonade a 9/10, Renaissance a 10/10 and Cowboy Carter also seems to be an instant classic (ain't listened yet)
- Mar 31, 2024
No
- Mar 31, 2024·1 replyBrandonM
I'm saying I think r. Kelly is next after those ppl mentioned in the op and that she is below him, so I guess she is close to them but not quite.
Beyoncé below r kelly I'VE SEEN IT ALL
Mar 31, 2024She‘s dropping classics for over a decade now, after her commercial peak. That’s different from Prince, MJ and Stevie. Her run from 4 to Cowboy Carter is the best for a woman at least.