Best songwriter that decade?
F*** idk
fierce competition
Apparently that is yet another lost gem from 1968 I somehow just heard for the first time
i still kinda hear some roots and if that is "pure" then I feel something like Louie Louie is on the same level. and even then its 1 or 2 songs like that surrounded by the rest of their output in the earliest era which is different
honestly i just gotta go with the explanation of Beatles being the main ones to take it from rock and roll -> just rock and solidify it. i cant think of anything before Rubber Soul really that has less obvious influence from the R&B,rockabilly,blues side.
yes i know What Goes On exists but that feels like more of a country excursion than a country influenced rock and roll song like Buddy Holly or something
not a fan of the "pure" discussion though and shouldnt have used that word in the first place, its too hard to define

F*** idk
fierce competition
Apparently that is yet another lost gem from 1968 I somehow just heard for the first time
It’s either him or the Liverpool Boys for me
Ray Davies in 1981:
“I hated my contemporaries. I hated the lifestyle of Paul McCartney. I didn’t want to be like Elton John or Rod Stewart.... There’s only one person who’s more insecure than I am, and his name is Pete Townshend. When I did have a meaningful chat with Pete, he said, ‘We never talk.’ And I said, ‘Why start now?’ ”
No Bob or Brian?
Bob’s kind of a given. I should’ve said I meant other than him.
Ray Davies in 1981:
“I hated my contemporaries. I hated the lifestyle of Paul McCartney. I didn’t want to be like Elton John or Rod Stewart.... There’s only one person who’s more insecure than I am, and his name is Pete Townshend. When I did have a meaningful chat with Pete, he said, ‘We never talk.’ And I said, ‘Why start now?’ ”
Larry Davies
Bob’s kind of a given. I should’ve said I meant other than him.
Yeah wasn't sure if you were regarding him as a "lyricist" instead or something
Liverpewl lads were a 2 headed (sometimes 4) songwriting monster so it's not even fair to compare them to Ray and Bob who wrote everything alone. I don't think I would put any Beatle by himself over them.
What are you going to do to celebrate?
I'm working
But going out for some food this evening and have a little surprise trip planned for me this weekend
Yeah wasn't sure if you were regarding him as a "lyricist" instead or something
Liverpewl lads were a 2 headed (sometimes 4) songwriting monster so it's not even fair to compare them to Ray and Bob who wrote everything alone. I don't think I would put any Beatle by himself over them.
I’d put Brian below Bob and Ray but the MoTown writers below Brian
I’d put Brian below Bob and Ray but the MoTown writers below Brian
Yeah Dylan would put Smokey above everybody probably
Yeah Dylan would put Smokey above everybody probably
Smokey, Marvin, Norman, HDH, A&S
I wish Gordy took them on a retreat in the ‘60s so they could make a psych album together
Smokey, Marvin, Norman, HDH, A&S
I wish Gordy took them on a retreat in the ‘60s so they could make a psych album together
Spector/Barry/Greenwich ran the first half of the decade
Ray davies s***s on pauls granny songs
About tied with Lennon's caustic slovenly d***face jams tho