Thread was locked by
a moderator
  • Feb 12, 2024
    JeffersonSteelflex

    As a music critic I did. He had a lot of knowledge to me and put me on to music outside of the genres I f***ed with. I enjoyed that he kept it at the music but in the last few years he’s kind of strayed away from that

    That’s valid but u dont need music critics to learn more about and put u onto music

  • Feb 12, 2024
    ·
    2 replies
    JeffersonSteelflex

    Where was this energy when he gave Ye and KSG 8 & 10s when Kanye disrespected black people?

    pretty sure he only gave KSG a 10, but to answer your question

    you might’ve been living in a bubble of kanye stans during that time period because there were a lot of people very vocally against kanye for what he said back then as well. that group of vocal people has only grown since.

  • Feb 12, 2024
    ·
    1 reply
    JeffersonSteelflex

    You stan a man that got a bbl

    Kanye got lipo too man

  • Feb 12, 2024
    ·
    4 replies

    It's so weird how much of a disconnect there is with critics and listeners on this album. Everyone I've talked to IRL is pretty indifferent to positive about the album, but critics are treating it like it's the worst album they've heard in their life. I understand not liking Kanye and by extension not enjoying the album because of its lyrical content, but critics are having these wild ass complaints as if the entire album is Kanye shouting over a single 808 note for 55 minutes.

    I'm not even a Kanye fan like that anymore, but I don't understand how these same critics who use Yeezus and Pablo as examples as when "Kanye was good" are claiming this is the worst s*** they've ever heard.

  • Feb 12, 2024
    ·
    1 reply

    Fantano has never reviewed music well. He’s a clown.

  • Feb 12, 2024
    ·
    1 reply
    Fax My Brother

    he too p**** to talk about the album cus he knows he'll secretly like it if he drops the act

    but he's not wrong about anything he says about ye or his fans himself - but it's not really a hot take either to call either of them cancer at this point

    so the only reason i can think of to upload this video is purely for attention

    Why is he even listening if he is just going to talk about ye and his fans and not the music? He can post on shaderoom if he cares more about the gossip than the music

  • Free YoungBoy

    Kanye got lipo too man

    I don’t stan Ye anymore lmfao

  • Feb 12, 2024
    Blainer93

    Fantano has never reviewed music well. He’s a clown.

  • Feb 12, 2024
    ·
    1 reply
    pussy bacon

    His major criticism of Hoodrat was that nobody would play it in a social setting

    Meanwhile he gave Scaring the hoes a 9/10

    I heard kingdom hearts key in a social setting but it wasn’t a social setting that I enjoyed so…

  • Feb 12, 2024
    Chickennugget

    It's so weird how much of a disconnect there is with critics and listeners on this album. Everyone I've talked to IRL is pretty indifferent to positive about the album, but critics are treating it like it's the worst album they've heard in their life. I understand not liking Kanye and by extension not enjoying the album because of its lyrical content, but critics are having these wild ass complaints as if the entire album is Kanye shouting over a single 808 note for 55 minutes.

    I'm not even a Kanye fan like that anymore, but I don't understand how these same critics who use Yeezus and Pablo as examples as when "Kanye was good" are claiming this is the worst s*** they've ever heard.

    Critics already made their minds up about the album when Ye announced it back in December lol

    In the real world, people love it lol

  • Feb 12, 2024

    I have no problems with his reviews or his banter but wow this is lame

  • Feb 12, 2024
    ·
    1 reply
    sab language 3

    pretty sure he only gave KSG a 10, but to answer your question

    you might’ve been living in a bubble of kanye stans during that time period because there were a lot of people very vocally against kanye for what he said back then as well. that group of vocal people has only grown since.

    I’m talking about Anthony Fantano

  • Feb 12, 2024
    Fries

    Seeing people act like this album is better than even Donda is insane to me, it's uninspired nonsense with Ye's worst verses ever

    donda has more awful moments to me

  • Feb 12, 2024
    ·
    1 reply
    pussy bacon

    His major criticism of Hoodrat was that nobody would play it in a social setting

    Meanwhile he gave Scaring the hoes a 9/10

    You could say that about the entire catalogue of s*** he loves. Bro listens to death grips unironically

  • Feb 12, 2024

    Finally a good review

  • Feb 12, 2024

    Even if you don’t like what Ye is doing on there Ty is absolutely going crazy on that album man

  • Feb 12, 2024

    Crazy
    Bipolar
    Antiyemite

  • Feb 12, 2024
    ·
    2 replies

    The album is solid

    It’s better than donda

  • Feb 12, 2024
    ·
    3 replies

    Jon Denton is the best YouTube reviewer we have now, Fantano has been trash for years now

  • pussy bacon

    His major criticism of Hoodrat was that nobody would play it in a social setting

    Meanwhile he gave Scaring the hoes a 9/10

    he comes off as a music sxn poster here when he's usually an in the mud RYM/4 chan poster

  • Feb 12, 2024
    Chickennugget

    It's so weird how much of a disconnect there is with critics and listeners on this album. Everyone I've talked to IRL is pretty indifferent to positive about the album, but critics are treating it like it's the worst album they've heard in their life. I understand not liking Kanye and by extension not enjoying the album because of its lyrical content, but critics are having these wild ass complaints as if the entire album is Kanye shouting over a single 808 note for 55 minutes.

    I'm not even a Kanye fan like that anymore, but I don't understand how these same critics who use Yeezus and Pablo as examples as when "Kanye was good" are claiming this is the worst s*** they've ever heard.

    It's not shocking that reviewers would pan an album from a guy who used to be a self proclaimed nazi

    No review of this album has been in good faith

  • Feb 12, 2024
    ·
    1 reply

    I can't see people listening to this thing in 5 years man, Kanye's just washed at this point

  • Feb 12, 2024
    ·
    1 reply
    americana

    The album is solid

    It’s better than donda

    easily

  • Feb 12, 2024
    ·
    2 replies

    he's buggin this is not worse than JIK lol his worst albums remain JIK and Donda 2

  • Feb 12, 2024
    americana

    The album is solid

    It’s better than donda

    Easily

1
...
3
4
5
...
19
Thread was locked by
a moderator