Thread was locked by
a moderator
  • Feb 12, 2024
    ·
    1 reply
    shaleirose

    Jon Denton is the best YouTube reviewer we have now, Fantano has been trash for years now

    JD’s videos became too reddit-core because of the people who pay for his patreon tbh

  • Abyss

    I feel bad for Ty. Every reviewer is treating it like a Kanye album and not giving the album even a chance

    I thought about this too lol it’s wack

  • Feb 12, 2024
    Tyla

    Why is he even listening if he is just going to talk about ye and his fans and not the music? He can post on shaderoom if he cares more about the gossip than the music

    gets him more followers and more people talking about him on twitter

  • Feb 12, 2024
    ·
    1 reply
    Chickennugget

    It's so weird how much of a disconnect there is with critics and listeners on this album. Everyone I've talked to IRL is pretty indifferent to positive about the album, but critics are treating it like it's the worst album they've heard in their life. I understand not liking Kanye and by extension not enjoying the album because of its lyrical content, but critics are having these wild ass complaints as if the entire album is Kanye shouting over a single 808 note for 55 minutes.

    I'm not even a Kanye fan like that anymore, but I don't understand how these same critics who use Yeezus and Pablo as examples as when "Kanye was good" are claiming this is the worst s*** they've ever heard.

    It’s because critics & publications at large have this holier than thou mentality and only review the person making the music, not the actual music itself. If this exact album was released in 2013 in its’ exact state, no changes, it would’ve received critical acclaim from everywhere

  • Feb 12, 2024
    ·
    1 reply
    notmyfirst

    I love when he talks generically about a songs booming sub bass and glistening keys

    Nah, he had depth to his reviews

    Wouldn’t have gotten to this point if he didn’t cmon now

  • Feb 12, 2024
    Kr0niic

    No clue

    https://twitter.com/theneedledrop/status/1757055269283004541https://twitter.com/theneedledrop/status/1757054653018051021

    Not even a Ye fan, but why does this ugly mfer (whose wife left him) thinks he can insult a (good looking) woman like that lol

  • Feb 12, 2024
    Zaywop

    I remember when y’all used to love Fantano

    used to? op literally posted this 5 minutes after fantano posted his video yall still love him

  • Feb 12, 2024
    provider

    if only

    Wiped from history

  • Feb 12, 2024
    Free YoungBoy

    You could say that about the entire catalogue of s*** he loves. Bro listens to death grips unironically

    death grips is really good though :(

    I hate him for making DG "fantano music" f*** that guy for that, same with swans

  • Feb 12, 2024
    ·
    2 replies
    Fax My Brother

    it's fine to not like the album but most of the criticisms i've seen are completely disingenuous and come off as people trying to dunk on the nazi which to be honest is pretty fair enough but don't try to act like you're really here to discuss the music in that case

    Fr, I don't really care if people dislike Kanye. I've fallen out of love with him myself. However, the world doesn't need people masquerading personal attacks as reviews of music.

    If you want to clown Kanye for bars like "I just f***ed a Jewish B****". Go ahead, but Fantano ranting about how much he argues with people on Twitter is so unnecessary.

  • Feb 12, 2024

    Legendary

  • Feb 12, 2024
    Abyss

    I feel bad for Ty. Every reviewer is treating it like a Kanye album and not giving the album even a chance

    Kanye didn’t even let Ty on the cover

  • Feb 12, 2024
    ·
    1 reply
    sab language 3

    JD’s videos became too reddit-core because of the people who pay for his patreon tbh

    I like him because he’s always honest and straight up on keeping it with the music. Even in the Vultures review he said he doesn’t agree with nor condone any of the Anti-Semitic comments Ye made in the past year, but he can’t deny that the music is still excellent (for the most part)

  • Feb 12, 2024
    ·
    1 reply

    Ngl....Seeing Drake and Ye stans on here uniting over Fantano is kind of a funny sight.

    Anthony also gave HNVM a "0."

    I lowkey think Drake, Ye, and Em burned too many bridges to ever get an acclaimed album ever again.

  • Feb 12, 2024
    JeffersonSteelflex

    Didn’t think me saying that would imply that I fully respected him tbh

  • Feb 12, 2024
    ·
    1 reply

    Ngl Ye stans did it to themselves, cus they be the ones hyping this clown up for the last years. Trying to clown Drake for calling him out lol

  • Feb 12, 2024
    ·
    1 reply
    Bobby_96

    Ngl....Seeing Drake and Ye stans on here uniting over Fantano is kind of a funny sight.

    Anthony also gave HNVM a "0."

    I lowkey think Drake, Ye, and Em burned too many bridges to ever get an acclaimed album ever again.

    what the f*** he gave hnm a 0?

  • Feb 12, 2024
    opium goblin

    regardless of ur opinion on this album fantano's behavior from the past 1-2 years has been so odd

    the weird personal digs just strike me as bitter hard to take this "review" serious

    yeah idc what he thinks about the album he could give it a zero and i couldn't care less but all this extra s*** he does and obvious fiending for reactions and some internet clout makes me sick and its just very sad given the following he has

    still probably the biggest/most widely-known music reviewer on the internet and he just does corny s*** like this nowadays and that’s it, used to be a somewhat serious and respectable reviewer like 5-ish years ago but now he’s just cancer and doing anything to hold onto some of his remaining relevance which is pretty much dead atp

    not that i’d be surprised but yea

  • shaleirose

    It’s because critics & publications at large have this holier than thou mentality and only review the person making the music, not the actual music itself. If this exact album was released in 2013 in its’ exact state, no changes, it would’ve received critical acclaim from everywhere

    Yup but you can’t say this or else you’re being a conspiracy theorist. Music journalism changed heavy after Trump got into office

  • Feb 12, 2024
    ·
    1 reply
    JeffersonSteelflex

    You stan a man that got a bbl

    That don't got nothing to do with me

    The music fire

  • Feb 12, 2024
    ·
    1 reply
    provider

    he's buggin this is not worse than JIK lol his worst albums remain JIK and Donda 2

    Do you have a link to finished Donda 2?

  • First bar on the intro track of his freshman album is basically telling all black people to stop pursuing higher education lmaoo but this is the line fantano draws I guess

  • Feb 12, 2024
    Abyss

    I feel bad for Ty. Every reviewer is treating it like a Kanye album and not giving the album even a chance

    Bro Ty numbers are flying up across the board

    I promise he’s ok

  • Feb 12, 2024

    So cringe lol this guy shoulda never been given a platform

  • Feb 12, 2024
    ·
    1 reply
    NeonNigga23

    U had respect for fantano?

    Losers relate

1
...
5
6
7
...
19
Thread was locked by
a moderator