Reply
  • Tito Ninety Four ✝️
    Mar 26, 2021
    ¡
    1 reply
    worthit

    Partially but I don't think you're giving our brain enough credit

    We're only using what... 14% of our brain?

    There are so many conditions we have no idea about that simply steer our actions

    Take weather as an example. With every year we're able to collect more and more data to PREDICT how the weather is going to behave. We make complicated models containing data about winds, temperature, pressure etc. and we're able to calculate how many degrees will there be next Friday and if it's going to rain

    Same way we could create an extreeemely complicated model of our brain. And if we could take into account all the incentives we could predict someone's actions.

    You wake up one day and you feel like drinking Tea instead of your morning coffee. You think it's your FREE choice. But you cannot explain the origin of that thought. You just woke up and felt like drinking tea instead of coffee. We call it free will bc we can't comprehend the fact we're not really controlling our own mind. We call the moment a thought appears in our head "free will" bc we're simply not able to comprehend from where and why did this thought appear in our brain

    Thoughts are not will. Will is the decision you make to carry out actions

  • Mar 26, 2021
    ¡
    3 replies

    How the f*** did that “we use 10-14% of our brain” s*** become so commonly accepted there’s no truth to that at all lmao

  • 2005hondacivic

    How the f*** did that “we use 10-14% of our brain” s*** become so commonly accepted there’s no truth to that at all lmao

    Remember that every night you eat 100 spiders one

  • Mar 26, 2021
    ¡
    edited
    ¡
    2 replies
    Tito Ninety Four

    Thoughts are not will. Will is the decision you make to carry out actions

    "A man can do as he wills, but he cannot will what he wills." - Arthur Schopenhauer

  • Mar 26, 2021

    Genetics plays a huge part

  • Mar 26, 2021
    2005hondacivic

    How the f*** did that “we use 10-14% of our brain” s*** become so commonly accepted there’s no truth to that at all lmao

    Morgan Freeman said it in some action movie and people ran with it. I also think "Limitless" had a bit in there about only using a small percentage of brain cells

  • Mar 26, 2021
    ¡
    edited
    coltrup

    very thought provoking article.

    so what its suggesting is that this "power" representing free will is the "power to do otherwise".

    and one interpretation of modern physics implies multiple possible futures for a given present. we make a different choice in each possible future, suggesting that we DO have the "power to do otherwise".

    Yeah I guess

    If we twist the definition of free will to just not being sure where your present leads you and having a possibility to "do otherwise" than yeah "Free Will" exists

    But if we want to go by the popular definition I don't think you could count some random quantum fluctuations in your brain as a full conscious developed free decision making. It still sounds like you have no control over your destiny difference is that you just can't be sure that if you start at A you'll always end up in B

    That's why I guess Alex Garland in that video says that if you could rewind time and you then went back you could end up in slightly or completely different places

  • Mar 26, 2021
    2005hondacivic

    How the f*** did that “we use 10-14% of our brain” s*** become so commonly accepted there’s no truth to that at all lmao

    Yeah it might be bullshit but this wasn't the point. Point is we cannot comprehend 100% of the incentives our brains process and that's what I wanted to communicate by saying we use X-% of our brain

  • Tito Ninety Four ✝️
    Mar 26, 2021
    ¡
    2 replies
    worthit

    "A man can do as he wills, but he cannot will what he wills." - Arthur Schopenhauer

    Entirely different concept tbh

  • Mar 26, 2021
    ¡
    1 reply
    Tito Ninety Four

    Entirely different concept tbh

    How so?

  • Mar 26, 2021
    worthit

    "You are free to do whatever you think
    But you're not free to chose what you think"

    Do you believe the free will is real?

    Or do you see how our actions are just results of all other past and present conditions having affect on us?

    Are you asking a question or just trying to start a discussion?

  • Mar 26, 2021
    Tito Ninety Four

    Entirely different concept tbh

    Not really

  • Tito Ninety Four ✝️
    Mar 26, 2021
    ¡
    1 reply
    worthit

    How so?

    If will is making your decision to carry out an action...

    That's not even in the same philosophical ballpark as "where do our thoughts come from?"

    You gonna think what you want. Or your brain. But the free will doesn't come into play until you choose a course of action. Which is always your choice. A thought is not a forceful action, no matter where it comes from.

  • Mar 26, 2021
    ¡
    1 reply
    worthit

    "A man can do as he wills, but he cannot will what he wills." - Arthur Schopenhauer

    This isn’t related to your point about “thoughts” though

  • Mar 26, 2021

    Freedom, Free doom - Kanye West

  • Mar 26, 2021

    I was gonna make a thread about this

  • Mar 26, 2021
    ¡
    1 reply
    Tito Ninety Four

    If will is making your decision to carry out an action...

    That's not even in the same philosophical ballpark as "where do our thoughts come from?"

    You gonna think what you want. Or your brain. But the free will doesn't come into play until you choose a course of action. Which is always your choice. A thought is not a forceful action, no matter where it comes from.

    Yeaah I recommend reading the whole thread bc I went deep into this stuff here

    You saying "which is always your choice" shows that you're not that deep into it yet and you're operating on a level of disproving that theory by ignoring it

    I argue there's no such thing as "your choice"

    I've posted couple interesting links in here give them a go when you have time

  • Mar 26, 2021
    ¡
    1 reply

    I'm pretty sure it doesn't but I guess it doesn't matter in a way. Kinda like even if we were in a simulation it wouldn't matter at the end of the day. So I try not to think about it. If you overthink i, it can kind of f*** with you

  • Mar 26, 2021
    ¡
    1 reply
    laudi

    This isn’t related to your point about “thoughts” though

    Yeah okay I'm talking about thinking as will like you think about drinking tea and it aligns with your will

    Picking this apart at this level doesn't lead to anything

  • Kenig 💭
    Mar 26, 2021

    I am the only one with a free will you‘re all just sheep in my world

  • Mar 26, 2021
    GIO GIO

    I'm pretty sure it doesn't but I guess it doesn't matter in a way. Kinda like even if we were in a simulation it wouldn't matter at the end of the day. So I try not to think about it. If you overthink i, it can kind of f*** with you

    True

    It changes completely nothing to how we operate and how we feel

    If you love someone that love is true no one is going to take it away from you by saying "you didn't really chose to love her"

    It's all still completely real

  • Mar 26, 2021
    ¡
    1 reply
    worthit

    Yeaah I recommend reading the whole thread bc I went deep into this stuff here

    You saying "which is always your choice" shows that you're not that deep into it yet and you're operating on a level of disproving that theory by ignoring it

    I argue there's no such thing as "your choice"

    I've posted couple interesting links in here give them a go when you have time

    This is the 66th post in the thread
    Each new person ain’t gonna read everything

  • CKL TML 🌺
    Mar 26, 2021

    Free Will till its backwards

  • Mar 26, 2021
    laudi

    This is the 66th post in the thread
    Each new person ain’t gonna read everything

    66 posts where 10 of them were actually insightful rest was just "I have free will bc I can f*** you up"

    I get it If you don't have time to read the whole thing but we went super deep into this stuff yesterday and the day before and I'm not gonna repeat it just bc 3 pages of posts is too much reading...

  • Mar 26, 2021
    ¡
    1 reply
    worthit

    Yeah okay I'm talking about thinking as will like you think about drinking tea and it aligns with your will

    Picking this apart at this level doesn't lead to anything

    Not really understanding that example but I will add I only believe in science and “known unknowns”
    Things like the power of suggestion and the desperate need for canonization to feel relevant