But if after the 5 year run you retire ?

So if Kanye retired after mbdtf he wouldn’t be a goat?

Hov only got 2 misses in 20+ years. That’s a real goat.

🤔 maybe

If Em retired after Encore he would still be considered a goat.

he was mid between 2007-2017 if u dont count WTT but ok

Kanye post 2010 haven’t been terrible tho

El oh el

i disagree. goat status is hinged on longevity although their are unusual cases where the work was of such quality where longevity is not a deciding factor.

wayne
eminem

these guys are still doing it after being legends. that's goat status to me. there a few goats in my mind. mac miller is an example of quality trumping longevity.

Gayest of all time? Yeah i agree with you!

i miss fetty wap being on top fam
his music takes me back to good times
cant believe 2015 was 5 years ago

Y’all really tryna tell me if a nigga drop mid music for over a decade after a small run of quality music they’re a goat? Just f*** the decade of mid? Lol. Y’all told me that___ isn’t a goat because he’s been mid for awhile now. Y’all pick and choose when to stick with a narrative.

but he is a goat

If the run its long like 7/8 years long it doesnt matter if then you drop one decade of mid

agreed-ish

a lot of people had a large peak and that's when longevity comes into play too

the main thing is impact/influence above all else

YG a goat to me based off My Krazy Life and Still Brazy

Should be about both.

Longevity > peak

So Durk is the goat? I'm not mad.

Theres a difference between dropping a fantastic album and being one of the greatest artists of all time.

Without longevity AND high quality you cant be in the 'GOAT conversation'

going off just peak itd probably be 50 cent