Reply
  • Oct 5
    ·
    1 reply
    shaleirose

    Nobody said I expected it to end like Game of Thrones

    “thank God this show didn’t end with a mindless CGI battle you’re dumb if you want them over grounded drama scenes”

  • Oct 5
    ·
    1 reply
    HaroldsChicken

    its all spectacle I posted the definition of spectacle

    You cant just change what words mean to convenience yourself

    Colloquially when people say spectacle they are referring to BIG and EPIC and FLASHY scenes that inspire awe

    Using a Green Lantern Ring to light a cigarette is not spectacle man

  • Oct 5
    Mac Wit Da Cheese

    Damn thought he was one of their species that joins the Justice League

    Cause doesn’t he also disguise as a human?

    Yeah he can but he’s not related at all lol

  • Oct 5
    ·
    1 reply
    HaroldsChicken

    “thank God this show didn’t end with a mindless CGI battle you’re dumb if you want them over grounded drama scenes”

    Yeah that’s a pretentious belief to have, serious drama is not inherently better than action

    That doesn’t mean I expected this show to end like Game of Thrones

  • Oct 5
    ·
    1 reply
    shaleirose

    Colloquially when people say spectacle they are referring to BIG and EPIC and FLASHY scenes that inspire awe

    Using a Green Lantern Ring to light a cigarette is not spectacle man

    you said you wanted more constructs throuhgout the show. I am saying even if they had 5 constructs every five minutes of the show that would not improve the writing and the drama of the show or make it more comic faithful

  • Oct 5
    ·
    1 reply
    HaroldsChicken

    you said you wanted more constructs throuhgout the show. I am saying even if they had 5 constructs every five minutes of the show that would not improve the writing and the drama of the show or make it more comic faithful

    I did not say that either

    I loved the first six episodes and there were constructs only some of the time

    I’m just saying that it’s crazy in the FINAL THREE EPISODES there were NONE AT ALL

    Don’t know how much clearer I can make this

  • Oct 5
    ·
    1 reply
    shaleirose

    Yeah that’s a pretentious belief to have, serious drama is not inherently better than action

    That doesn’t mean I expected this show to end like Game of Thrones

    For what this show is going for and its given plot yes Drama is the focus on the show not special fx battle. for the millionth time

    Damon Lindelof known for DRAMA wasnt hired to make an show that ended in an action battle

  • Oct 5
    ·
    1 reply

    Where would you even add constructs in at? Make Hal make a fork to eat in the diner scene? At that point I think you just want a whole new show. I just don’t get where people wanting constructs would add them in at.

  • Oct 5
    ·
    1 reply
    HaroldsChicken

    For what this show is going for and its given plot yes Drama is the focus on the show not special fx battle. for the millionth time

    Damon Lindelof known for DRAMA wasnt hired to make an show that ended in an action battle

    What does me thinking that’s a pretentious belief to hold in general have anything to do with my expectations of this finale?

    I never expected this finale to have a big battle.

    I simultaneously believe that thinking serious drama is inherently better than big action is pretentious.

  • Oct 5
    ·
    1 reply
    Fruit Fury

    Where would you even add constructs in at? Make Hal make a fork to eat in the diner scene? At that point I think you just want a whole new show. I just don’t get where people wanting constructs would add them in at.

    I mean the alien planet would’ve been a great place to start

  • Oct 5
    ·
    1 reply
    shaleirose

    I did not say that either

    I loved the first six episodes and there were constructs only some of the time

    I’m just saying that it’s crazy in the FINAL THREE EPISODES there were NONE AT ALL

    Don’t know how much clearer I can make this

    you started with no lantern elements

    then again @NobodyWins mentioned the planet

    you said the planet was ugly

    then we made clear discussing how the planet looks was spectacle

    then he posted lantern, sinestro and other lantern elements down to a lantern bat signal

    you switched your goal post to constructs

    now you are saying a light that emits from a ring to form whatever they imagine isnt spectacle

    the bird he forms is spectacle too

    but you never will admit it so whats the point in even discussing

  • Oct 5
    ·
    1 reply
    shaleirose

    I mean the alien planet would’ve been a great place to start

    Doing what though? Make a boat with the dying ring?

  • Oct 5
    ·
    1 reply
    shaleirose

    What does me thinking that’s a pretentious belief to hold in general have anything to do with my expectations of this finale?

    I never expected this finale to have a big battle.

    I simultaneously believe that thinking serious drama is inherently better than big action is pretentious.

    Brother you are pretentious. You do this in every single thread

    just because you do so why also loving spectacle, marvel movies, visual fx that some consider slop doesnt change that.

  • Oct 5
    Fruit Fury

    Doing what though? Make a boat with the dying ring?

    yes

  • Oct 5

    the show makes clear the ring has to be charged but you want them to waste it entertaining you with pretty colors

  • Oct 5
    ·
    3 replies

    john should've sniped Noah in the middle of the football game tbh

  • Oct 5

    I dont thnk people are dumb for wanting a suit and for him to have a green light around him. Using constructs randomly when that goes against the character and the writing of limited charge everything we have seen in the show so far. Which was a clear given reason for why characters would only use constructs when they needed to. Yeah what do you want me to call that ?

    Especially when we know we will get constructs in a upcoming movie with a much larger budget

    this is a tv show that they expected to do okay but not 19 million viewers good. Those viewers change the budget for the next season. This is always how television works. Many shows that are special fx heavy their first season with crazy budgets do not make it long at all.

  • Oct 5
    Mr Anderson

    john should've sniped Noah in the middle of the football game tbh

    I think if he thought Noah killed Hal then he killed Noah out of revenge with no " Hal wouldnt want me to turn you in ". Then she reacts knowing she did it . Would have actually worked better for me than what occurred. John would have operated on emotion just as she operated on emotion. Both costing them the people they care deeply about. With no way to go backwards

  • Oct 5
    ·
    1 reply

    you spent the last two days telling me that movies arent books, telling me that digger doesnt have a clear theme and that resident evil has no theme. While I said "your perspective is yours and mine is mine" you have said "I am right no that is silly you are dumb for thinking that"

    you are projecting pretentiousness. While deep down you love spectacle AND THAT IS A OKAY.

  • Oct 5
    ·
    3 replies

    It's funny how the discourse round this show is that people wanted lanterns to morph into a different show than the identity it established with its premise and the first few episodes. It's the opposite of what people wanted for wandavision. I dont think its bad to want more visual spectacle or grand shows from the show but using it as a knock on it isn't the right critique

  • Oct 5

    the show is called lanterns for a reason. Its the build up on a exponentially lower budget to get to where he is a developed character in the movies he cameos in and hopefully eventually his own movie not limited to television earth bound lantern or not.

    It was worth it for him to have a 8 hour origin vs just pop up in the movie for a quck cameo or a mr terrific one off scene of just spectacle

    the spectacle is coming in man of tomorrow brother chug that 5 hour energy its coming.

  • Oct 5
    ·
    1 reply
  • Oct 5
    ·
    1 reply
    HaroldsChicken

    you started with no lantern elements

    then again @NobodyWins mentioned the planet

    you said the planet was ugly

    then we made clear discussing how the planet looks was spectacle

    then he posted lantern, sinestro and other lantern elements down to a lantern bat signal

    you switched your goal post to constructs

    now you are saying a light that emits from a ring to form whatever they imagine isnt spectacle

    the bird he forms is spectacle too

    but you never will admit it so whats the point in even discussing

    The planet is not a Lanterns element. A random desert landscape has nothing to do with Green Lanterns. If they said that s*** was Arizona you wouldn’t think twice about it

  • Oct 5
    ·
    1 reply
    Oblivion X

    It's funny how the discourse round this show is that people wanted lanterns to morph into a different show than the identity it established with its premise and the first few episodes. It's the opposite of what people wanted for wandavision. I dont think its bad to want more visual spectacle or grand shows from the show but using it as a knock on it isn't the right critique

    https://twitter.com/PhelleAlt/status/2106570437245202632

    the show from the beginning said it wasnt going to be spectacle openly. They didnt lie to anyone. They didnt deceive anyone. They didnt ask for people to watch 8 hours of it expecting anything of it than what we got and in the podcast they said it would not be special fx heavy spectacle or heavy on constructs. They said that from the beginning

    so yes people watching 8 hours of a show and the finale then saying "YOU TRICKED ME"

    is a little goofy

    i get again the suit and green light around him would have helped but more constructs unnecessarily when the ring has a charge tied to a hologram of a dead character he wants to see?

    Is kind of goofy. If anything focus on the lack of the MYSTERY in a DRAMA show landing

  • Oct 5
    shaleirose

    The planet is not a Lanterns element. A random desert landscape has nothing to do with Green Lanterns. If they said that s*** was Arizona you wouldn’t think twice about it

    Sinestro
    Manhunters
    the Lantern he literally holds
    Guy Gardner discussion

    there are plenty of lantern elements in the final 3 episodes

    you wanted constructs in a show that perfectly lays out why there are limited constructs with charge tied to something that allows him to see his dead mentor