Thread was locked by
a moderator
  • Sep 19, 2022

    Eminem post 8 mile

    50 cent post Massacre

    They took higher highs than ye ever had (GRODT era and MMLP-8 mile era) to lower lows than Donda or JIK

  • Sep 19, 2022

    Kanye goat, sorry

  • Sep 19, 2022
    ·
    1 reply

    !dream Post Punk Jung

  • Sep 19, 2022
    ·
    1 reply

    I understand you're probably just looking for attention, but I don't really get this stance. I don't think his new work is as good as his initial run, but it's also abundantly obvious that music is not his first priority right now.

    Donda was the last time he locked in on an album, and even then it was for a haphazard stretch of a few weeks - compare that to MBDTF being made over 180 days according to Mike Dean, and Power alone getting thousands of hours put into it.

    It doesn't make sense to talk about a "fall from grace" when the fall from grace has been borderline deliberate, I would think. The guy literally tells interviewers not to ask him about music

  • Sep 19, 2022
    pouringover

    !dream Post Punk Jung

    Never trust a kpop fans opinion of anything tbh

  • Sep 19, 2022
    ·
    1 reply
    PostPunkJung

    Donda was like Kanye & Friends, better than Ye and JIK but still not really a Kanye album.

    Donda 2 was a full on disaster.

    Imagine if you had heard Ye back when MBDTF dropped, and someone told you this is the level where Kanye will finally end up at.

    MBDTF was also Kanye & Friends … multiple full blown posse cuts on that album. If that’s your main takeaway from donda I’m afraid you’ll have to put MBDTF in the same lense. Donda 2 is pretty not good but still interesting …. Clearly unfinished & and feels like a response to the rabbid demo-it is the Ye community was plagued by.

    If I was given a glimpse into the current era of Ye’s music I’d only be disappointed if it wasn’t glaringly obvious he wanted to move beyond music since the Yeezy 2 came out

  • PostPunkJung

    Are people really saying that JIK, Ye and Donda etc. are on Yeezys/MBDTF level?

    Come on…

    unfair to compare his discog to two of the greatest albums ever released. he will most likely never top those albums again. its like expecting MJ to drop another Thriller after Invincible or Prince to make an album equal to Purple Rain or Sign of the Times in the 90s or 00s

    every artist has a peak they will never again reach

  • Mmm Hmm 😆
    Sep 19, 2022
    PostPunkJung

    What the f*** happened to him?

    It’s like all his talent got absolutely drained post 2015.
    He went from being a perfectionist to dropping some of the worst music ever.

    Did he fire all of his ghostwriters/producers or what?

    It's called being busy.

    • Having a wife
    • Having kids
    • Having other passions
  • Sep 19, 2022
    PostPunkJung

    Are people really saying that JIK, Ye and Donda etc. are on Yeezys/MBDTF level?

    Come on…

    Donda is his best album

  • Sep 19, 2022

    If you look at most famous movie directors, their later films are usually less well received compared to their early work. Why is that? Because they are not trying to please audiences anymore, they are making art to please themselves.. I see Ye in the same stage now. He not out there to make MBDTF again. He already did that. He wants to make what he wants to make. Not caring about perfection and things like that

  • Sep 19, 2022

    pablo and donda are good, especially pablo

  • Sep 19, 2022

    He didn’t fall off

  • Sep 19, 2022
    mctate

    Pablo is a near classic

    /thread

    i think enough time has passed to say that it is. one of his most iconic eras

  • I’ll give you the attention you wanted because you’re not entirely wrong. You could argue that the focus went from innovating and being a perfectionist in his music died after wanting to be hot (angry his songs weren’t getting radio play) and that’s why he’s chose to do albums the way he did Pablo onward.

    With that being said, his focus isn’t 100% music anymore and anyone can see that. He’ll get the itch to do music and lock in with the hottest artists just to do it rather than having a passion project that he wants to perfect. Donda, KSG, and Pablo are still dope projects imo

  • Sep 19, 2022

    OP needs a bigger resume for me to fall for this thread

  • Sep 19, 2022
    PostPunkJung

    It’s pretty good but also the beginning of the downfall.

    Shocking nosevide after that record.

    KSG is an incredible project

    Donda isnt on par with his early discog but compared to any of his contemporaries its an AOTY contender which is crazy to pull off when youre 40

  • Sep 19, 2022
    ·
    1 reply
    coltrup

    I understand you're probably just looking for attention, but I don't really get this stance. I don't think his new work is as good as his initial run, but it's also abundantly obvious that music is not his first priority right now.

    Donda was the last time he locked in on an album, and even then it was for a haphazard stretch of a few weeks - compare that to MBDTF being made over 180 days according to Mike Dean, and Power alone getting thousands of hours put into it.

    It doesn't make sense to talk about a "fall from grace" when the fall from grace has been borderline deliberate, I would think. The guy literally tells interviewers not to ask him about music

    Also, he has some of the best Spotify numbers in the world. Even if that's largely based on old catalogue, it objectively means he hasn't fallen from grace. Donda did well as an album too.

    A fall from grace is when no one plays your music new or old, you can't sell tickets, you've lost most of your fans and get no praise.

    Kanye's had a slight decline in music quality and said some stupid things. Pretty standard for an older artist in their third decade of music. He has better longevity than most artists

  • Sep 19, 2022
    ·
    3 replies

    Being on this site taught me how delusional Kanye fans can be

  • Sep 19, 2022
    Dealers In Paris

    Being on this site taught me how delusional Kanye fans can be

    What makes you say that in the context of this thread?

  • Sep 19, 2022
    PostPunkJung

    Donda was like Kanye & Friends, better than Ye and JIK but still not really a Kanye album.

    Donda 2 was a full on disaster.

    Imagine if you had heard Ye back when MBDTF dropped, and someone told you this is the level where Kanye will finally end up at.

    You want Kanye to be like every artist that when they have an album that does well they start cloning that album over and over

    It would’ve been mad boring if we just got MBDTF clones

    Kanye’s always gonna switch up his style

  • Sep 19, 2022
    ·
    3 replies

    his only bad album is donda

  • Sep 19, 2022
    ·
    2 replies
    madison beer guy

    his only bad album is donda

    Best album of 2021

  • Sep 19, 2022
    theDonandOnly

    Also, he has some of the best Spotify numbers in the world. Even if that's largely based on old catalogue, it objectively means he hasn't fallen from grace. Donda did well as an album too.

    A fall from grace is when no one plays your music new or old, you can't sell tickets, you've lost most of your fans and get no praise.

    Kanye's had a slight decline in music quality and said some stupid things. Pretty standard for an older artist in their third decade of music. He has better longevity than most artists

  • Sep 19, 2022
    madison beer guy

    his only bad album is donda

    Donda is much much better than the two that proceeded it

  • Sep 19, 2022
    ·
    1 reply
    Salad

    Best album of 2021

    a lot of great musical moments for sure just get can't fully behind it as a kanye album!

Thread was locked by
a moderator