Hayley Williams posts on her IG story that she is now credited on Olivia Rodrigo’s “good 4 u”

Page 3 of 10
Reply
  • Aug 25, 2021
    ·
    12 replies
    Reply

    I can already smell the “YOU CANT OWN CHORDS” cop out from a mile away due to people’s only frame of reference for music theory related to crediting disputes being chords as if chords are the only component of music composition

    But the chorus in Good 4 U has not only the same chords but nearly identical: harmonic rhythm, tempo, melodic contour, vocal performance, vocal range, groove, subgenre, sound, and is only one semitone up from Misery Business - all simultaneously

    So yes, Paramore and Hayley Williams should absolutely get a credit on this song

  • BD32

    Sour is just an amalgamation of obvious millennial sounds from the early 2000s + Lorde it's actually crazy how well it did for solely relying on nostalgia

    Same I just find her music so boring it just doesn't add anything new

  • Aug 25, 2021
    Reply
    rhyming rhino

    Kanye gonna get 50% publishing for drakes entire catalogue

    you just opened whole new can of worms

    get ready to get bombarded

  • Aug 25, 2021
    Reply
    rhyming rhino

    Kanye gonna get 50% publishing for drakes entire catalogue

    like i said they dont do this for hip hop (yet)

  • Aug 25, 2021
    Reply

    good 4 her

  • Aug 25, 2021
    Reply
    csr

    good 4 u song of the year sorry

    not even top 3 on sour

  • Aug 25, 2021
    ·
    1 reply
    Reply
    decked

    Both songs trash.

    Dork

  • Aug 25, 2021
    Reply
    BD32

    Sour is just an amalgamation of obvious millennial sounds from the early 2000s + Lorde it's actually crazy how well it did for solely relying on nostalgia

    Zoomers biting the closest generation to theirs isn’t surprising we just take it more personal cause it was our era

  • BRAVE

    I can already smell the “YOU CANT OWN CHORDS” cop out from a mile away due to people’s only frame of reference for music theory related to crediting disputes being chords as if chords are the only component of music composition

    But the chorus in Good 4 U has not only the same chords but nearly identical: harmonic rhythm, tempo, melodic contour, vocal performance, vocal range, groove, subgenre, sound, and is only one semitone up from Misery Business - all simultaneously

    So yes, Paramore and Hayley Williams should absolutely get a credit on this song

  • BRAVE

    I can already smell the “YOU CANT OWN CHORDS” cop out from a mile away due to people’s only frame of reference for music theory related to crediting disputes being chords as if chords are the only component of music composition

    But the chorus in Good 4 U has not only the same chords but nearly identical: harmonic rhythm, tempo, melodic contour, vocal performance, vocal range, groove, subgenre, sound, and is only one semitone up from Misery Business - all simultaneously

    So yes, Paramore and Hayley Williams should absolutely get a credit on this song

    thank you

  • Tyler1999

    So does this

    !https://youtu.be/3Fzi4lBzqIg

    goated

  • Aug 25, 2021
    Reply

    Madonna needs 50% of Lady Gaga too
    we can play this game all day

  • Aug 25, 2021
    ·
    1 reply
    Reply

    50% of royalties? that's ridiculous

  • Aug 25, 2021
    ·
    2 replies
    Reply

    If anyone deserves a check from SOUR it’s Lorde

  • BRAVE

    I can already smell the “YOU CANT OWN CHORDS” cop out from a mile away due to people’s only frame of reference for music theory related to crediting disputes being chords as if chords are the only component of music composition

    But the chorus in Good 4 U has not only the same chords but nearly identical: harmonic rhythm, tempo, melodic contour, vocal performance, vocal range, groove, subgenre, sound, and is only one semitone up from Misery Business - all simultaneously

    So yes, Paramore and Hayley Williams should absolutely get a credit on this song

    Exactly. Music is art and art shouldn't be policed too much but there's also a science behind it and that part should have rules that protect creators or else everyone would steal everything without consequences.

  • Aug 25, 2021
    Reply

    been known o-rod has zero originality

    anyway, PINK PANTHERESS out now

  • i figured this was like a direct reference or an homage

    now idk how to feel

  • Aug 25, 2021
    Reply
    Tyler1999

    So does this

    !https://youtu.be/3Fzi4lBzqIg

    lol why did i never know it was Simple Plan behind this theme

    makes so much sense

  • Aug 25, 2021
    Reply
    BRAVE

    I can already smell the “YOU CANT OWN CHORDS” cop out from a mile away due to people’s only frame of reference for music theory related to crediting disputes being chords as if chords are the only component of music composition

    But the chorus in Good 4 U has not only the same chords but nearly identical: harmonic rhythm, tempo, melodic contour, vocal performance, vocal range, groove, subgenre, sound, and is only one semitone up from Misery Business - all simultaneously

    So yes, Paramore and Hayley Williams should absolutely get a credit on this song

    Ok this some effort posting, I like it

  • Aug 25, 2021
    Reply

    Nah thats wack, no way she should get 50%

    Credit sure, even a percentage but 50% is robbery

  • BRAVE

    I can already smell the “YOU CANT OWN CHORDS” cop out from a mile away due to people’s only frame of reference for music theory related to crediting disputes being chords as if chords are the only component of music composition

    But the chorus in Good 4 U has not only the same chords but nearly identical: harmonic rhythm, tempo, melodic contour, vocal performance, vocal range, groove, subgenre, sound, and is only one semitone up from Misery Business - all simultaneously

    So yes, Paramore and Hayley Williams should absolutely get a credit on this song

    -BRAVE

  • Aug 25, 2021
    Reply

    good 4 u is like a copy and paste of Misery Business, so yes Paramore should get credit.

    More than just chord structure.

  • Aug 25, 2021
    Reply
    BRAVE

    I can already smell the “YOU CANT OWN CHORDS” cop out from a mile away due to people’s only frame of reference for music theory related to crediting disputes being chords as if chords are the only component of music composition

    But the chorus in Good 4 U has not only the same chords but nearly identical: harmonic rhythm, tempo, melodic contour, vocal performance, vocal range, groove, subgenre, sound, and is only one semitone up from Misery Business - all simultaneously

    So yes, Paramore and Hayley Williams should absolutely get a credit on this song

    King

  • Aug 25, 2021
    Reply
    air

    If anyone deserves a check from SOUR it’s Lorde

    Lard doesn’t even deserve pay for her recent album lmao

1
2
3
4
...
10