@shaleirose

You asked me “be up there how” and I responded see above post

Nah, Lupe >>>>

Even Words I Never Said Lupe >>>

Eminem is still the highest-selling rapper ever, he's never cared about awards, and his fans respect him a ton

You haven’t added to the discussion at all

But he’d be up there way more if he cared like Jay did after the L to nas

The Taylor Swift and Maroon 5 points were responding to @Aisosa saying that millions of people like Eminem's recent music

Even if that was true who cares

And yes i have you must be blind or stupid or both

He's still up there though, I'm confused. Eminem is regularly rated and respected as a Top 5 rapper of all-time

Shut up white girl

Her music can't be terrible if she has millions of people listening to it

Its a dumb discussion anyways

The thread was originally about eminem and i havent barely seen his name mentioned in like 5 pages

Barely these last couple years. This thread is proof he’s not up there according to hip hop fans

Nice reply

cuz jay fans came in here trying to give him participation award classics for dropping mid

2026 and you think that popularity equates to quality in art

Guess that means NBA 2K is the best video game in the world then since it's among the highest-selling every year!

Fallacies in this thread

Yeah because people think he fell off creatively a long time ago, my point is that more albums of bullshit wouldn't have changed that

Prime eminem is lyrically better than jayz

Jayz is overrated as a lyricist

Jayz makes better music than eminem

Jayz always "understood the assignment"

He makes great music. Hes a great rapper. He doesnt over do it

Eminem is some weird psycho genius when he really tries. Hes basically kenny or nas level

How is anything I'm saying a fallacy?

1. Popularity has no bearings on quality when it comes to art

2. Eminem's status in contemporary rap wouldn't be different if he dropped more albums throughout his prime, because the problem for people wasn't the quantity, it was the quality of everything after The Eminem Show

No, you dunce.

There's no such thing as good or bad music, only music you like or dislike.

I would rather die than listen to a Kate Busb album but some niggas think that s*** is the best thing on the planet

not sure about better music but i like his topic more than Em's (which doesn't say much because i don't care for either of their topics)

If he dropped in his prime like Jay did it wouldn’t have been ass compared to his newer stuff
Jay dropped 8 albums compared (collab albums included) to ems 4 albums
Re-Up wasn’t a collab album just a compilation