Reply
  • Jun 17, 2020
    ·
    edited
    ·
    1 reply
    krishna bound

    you ever read some of marx & engels letters? they weren't racist as in the traditional sense of wanting to perpetuate systematic structures, but they believed in s*** like phrenology and believed in some ideas similar to social darwinism regarding racial differences. this doesn't invalidate anything else marx said, but a lot of modern characterizations of marx and engels (as well as what they actually believed) is super exaggerated

    I have read quite a few. They were not social darwinists, not at all.

  • Jun 17, 2020
    ·
    2 replies
    EMY

    Whites must be extinguished

    These type of posts are what make me cringe at KTT2, joke or not. If someone said this about any other race that dude would be banned for life. We’re better than this

  • Jun 17, 2020
    FlipFlop

    idek what is this whole thing about, I just listened to the song, is it just some kind of boomer moment from J Cole ? Because it seems like it

    Cole caught feelings over a Noname tweet and now he's pretending that 10 years of being a big brain conscious rapper never happened because he got humbled by a woman and can't handle it.

    Someone could try to make this a race thing, but it's really more about gender relations and not telling women, especially black women, to "be gentle" when they have a legitimate issue about something.

  • Jun 17, 2020
    ·
    1 reply
    ARCADE GOON

    I have read quite a few. They were not social darwinists, not at all.

    while they weren't out here saying "we should lynch blacks", they believed in distinct inequalities between races, and again, this manifested in phrenology among other things. It's a self-evident truth that one foundational aspect of Marxism is about repealing western egalitarianism; how this manifests in theory is up for debate though, sure. With this creates debates over what the exact differences are between people, which while not rooted in systematically oppressive facets, still lead to racism in a non-discriminatory sense. While the discussion of non-egailitarianism is not inherently racist ofc, the context of the time in which these discussions were had meant they typically came up in what would today be considered racist discourse; especially in regards to commments on blacks & jews.
    While Marx was against systematic oppression through things like slavery, it's revisionist to state that Marx believed in the sme post-60s form of intersectional action and types of oppression which is currently talked about today in that sense. It was far closer to a belief rooted in inevitable systematic accelerationism economically and socially and the effects of such. While yes, he believed this would result in shedding ideas of social-derivative racial and nationalist concepts inadvertently, they made distinctions in social-derivative "race" vs inherent (i.e. genetic) "race". People say Marx wasn't a Darwinist because he rejected the time-sensitive context of Bourgeois Social Darwinism, but Marx and Engels participated in Darwinian discourse - this is inarguable, it's just a fact of history. The fact we don't have a different word makes this discussion harder to have.

  • Jun 17, 2020
    ·
    1 reply

    White here.

    ahem

    F*** J Cole, f*** Noname, f*** anyone that says 'problematic' unironically, and f*** the ATF.

    That is all. Thank you for your time.

  • Jun 17, 2020
    ·
    edited
    ·
    1 reply
    krishna bound

    while they weren't out here saying "we should lynch blacks", they believed in distinct inequalities between races, and again, this manifested in phrenology among other things. It's a self-evident truth that one foundational aspect of Marxism is about repealing western egalitarianism; how this manifests in theory is up for debate though, sure. With this creates debates over what the exact differences are between people, which while not rooted in systematically oppressive facets, still lead to racism in a non-discriminatory sense. While the discussion of non-egailitarianism is not inherently racist ofc, the context of the time in which these discussions were had meant they typically came up in what would today be considered racist discourse; especially in regards to commments on blacks & jews.
    While Marx was against systematic oppression through things like slavery, it's revisionist to state that Marx believed in the sme post-60s form of intersectional action and types of oppression which is currently talked about today in that sense. It was far closer to a belief rooted in inevitable systematic accelerationism economically and socially and the effects of such. While yes, he believed this would result in shedding ideas of social-derivative racial and nationalist concepts inadvertently, they made distinctions in social-derivative "race" vs inherent (i.e. genetic) "race". People say Marx wasn't a Darwinist because he rejected the time-sensitive context of Bourgeois Social Darwinism, but Marx and Engels participated in Darwinian discourse - this is inarguable, it's just a fact of history. The fact we don't have a different word makes this discussion harder to have.

    "Labour cannot emancipate itself in the white skin where in the black it is branded."

    His theory was absolutely not racist and didn't have the subtle racism you claim. The last words of the manifesto are: Workers of the world unite. Not: Europeans unite or whatever.

    If his racism and eurocentricism mattered, then his ideas wouldn't have been taken up by non-white people the world over.

  • Jun 17, 2020
    ARCADE GOON

    "Labour cannot emancipate itself in the white skin where in the black it is branded."

    His theory was absolutely not racist and didn't have the subtle racism you claim. The last words of the manifesto are: Workers of the world unite. Not: Europeans unite or whatever.

    If his racism and eurocentricism mattered, then his ideas wouldn't have been taken up by non-white people the world over.

    You're not understanding what I'm saying. Yes, he very obviously believed in the restructuring of systems which perpetuated racism because he believed social concepts of race held back progress for workers. This has nothing to do with what I'm saying, and I even acknowledge this, my point in saying that Marx believed in emancipation of labor being tied to social race. This has nothing to do with what I'm saying, nor anything I claimed.
    This is a separate. You have to make a distinction between racism in terms of materialism and racism in terms of cultural or abstract being. Marx did not believe in racial equality in the traditional sense of the word; i.e. he did not believe, holistically, a european, an african, and a jewish person were "equal" in the sense of only being different by genetic physique. While he believed that societally, arbitrary castes and identities were created and the perpetuation of these abstract identities led to material oppression, he made distinctions between material inequalities (that which spearheaded material dialectic theory, and thus lead to emancipation of labor), and societal inequalities (those not born from labor, but from inherent material being).
    Past these abstract identities, he did not actually believe that people were "equal" in the sense of being only differentiated by skin color. Again, while non-egalitarianism is not an inherently racist concept, the application by Marx & Engels more than typically tended to be .
    He more or less insinuated the desire for "equality" in the sense of social interaction was only a result of capitalism; in other words, that as long as systematic structures were elminated, it's not that racism would be gone, but rather racism wouldn't matter since it wouldn't effect anything. He very much implied "well just because some races are stupid doesn't mean they don't deserve to have their needs fulfilled". Engels's summaries of working class histories were literally tied to biological racialism as one reason capitalistic inequalities even existed in the first place. He basically formulated that inherent racial & cultural inequalities were one of the main reasons capitalism grew so out of hand to begin with.

  • Jun 18, 2020
    ·
    1 reply

    Interesting read

  • Jun 18, 2020
    ·
    1 reply
    Shaps

    how would white people commenting on it be problematic????

    Can we ban this guy please

  • Jun 18, 2020
    ·
    1 reply

    Crazy how the OP of this thread isn’t even black

  • Jun 18, 2020

    Yes it is. Period, no discussion to be had

  • Jun 18, 2020
    ·
    2 replies
    SHAQUILLE

    Crazy how the OP of this thread isn’t even black

    He can still self a***yze and question whether he should be participating in the convo or not

  • Jun 18, 2020
    ·
    1 reply
    Slingshot

    He can still self a***yze and question whether he should be participating in the convo or not

    not sure why he brought that up

  • Jun 18, 2020
    fmvp yzy vert

    not sure why he brought that up

    to some of these cats ktt is just a game show and whoever is the least white wins

  • Jun 18, 2020
    Slingshot

    He can still self a***yze and question whether he should be participating in the convo or not

    Nah. I’ve seen posts of his before on similar subjects.

    This is a classic s*** on white people post.

  • Jun 18, 2020

    OP isn't even white, let's lock the thread

  • Jun 18, 2020
    afterimage

    Can we ban this guy please

    you gon answer the question or not

  • Jun 18, 2020
    Prison Mike

    OP lets a white man tell him what to do everyday but not when it comes to Cole/Noname

  • Jun 18, 2020
    ·
    2 replies
    fmvp yzy vert

    Interesting read

    Great discussion in here

  • cozy

    Great discussion in here

  • Mmm Hmm 😆
    Jun 18, 2020

    Cole is half white.

    So.

  • Jun 18, 2020

    depends on what your take is tbh. if you're defending Cole/Kendrick just cause you like their music and it doesn't go deeper than that you should just stfu

  • Jun 18, 2020

    us white folk have a million other more important things to be speaking up about rn

  • Jun 18, 2020
    BIGSTEPPERDISNEY

    These type of posts are what make me cringe at KTT2, joke or not. If someone said this about any other race that dude would be banned for life. We’re better than this

    It ain’t that serious fam, this is KTT ffs