It's not a top 5 mc list tho

How attractive do you find your cousins?

Art is art, that's the logic.

You cant claim art is corny. If its well written its well written.

Take "Kim" for example, it might be disturbing and woman demeening, but it's still a very very well written song that paints an emotional picture not alot of songs does.

That goes for movies as well, you dont see movie fans trash genres within movies just because the content is "edgy" nah man, its either well written or its not.

My favorite rapper is Playboi carti so no he wouldn’t

Let's pretend Eminem hasnt written relatable songs and all he does is write incest music lol.

Real

Hmmmm,Eminem still isn’t a better artist than BIG tbh. Some of his duds out weighs his accomplishments

Ppl try to undersell Em’s early work to impress others

Some of the most captivating story telling in hip hop for sure

Em has 11 albums and 3 classics and been doing this for decades, he's not in my top5 but it's easy to see why people would have him over big who only has 2 albums

i love it when you call me big poppa

“Jay-Z... I’d argue his discog is mid...”

“Eminem... Seminal works...”

Cauc confirmed

Nah saying he "would rap circles around your favorite" is VERY debatable. Ppl give him too much credit in that regard. he only has gone against bozos. I'm pretty sure Kendrick would wash him (without sounding grating to the ears in the process).

Jay
Drake
50
Wayne
Durk

I'd take Pac off before I take the actual lyricist off

Em outrapped Jay so bad on Renegade it became a verb

“You got renegaded on your own track”

Kanye West doesn’t write his rhymes, that’s like putting Dre up there

something tells me biggie woulda gone down the same path as the game

early classics then turned into a weirdo over time

you’re right, he thinks them

True, but not a fair comparison. Had Em and Jay been involved in a beef, I'm pretty sure Jay would hold his own.

Fact is Big did more with those 2 albums more than almost every rapper has done with their whole discographies

Both are classics and he's undeniably one of the best rappers in terms of flow, lyrics. He was also hugely popular while alive, and his music and it's impact still being felt 2 and a half decades later

Not only one of the best technical rappers ever he also one of the most popular and influential

How the hell he not top 5 greatest . Maybe not your personal faves but Its like saying Jordan, LeBron not goats. His body of work and legacy cements itself

Pac a lyricist

Yes the f*** you can ☠️

We cant argue hypotheticals, we can only argue what we have seen and from what we have seen we know that Em could out rap most people’s favs

imagine putting literally anyone else on op’s list above biggie

I'm tired of the Scarface disrespect. He's undoubtedly one of the GOATS.