Jan 28, 2021·1 reply
aaaaaaaaaaruined st vincent
ruined lana
ruined taylorsad
You forgot ruined lorde
Jan 28, 2021aaaaaaaaaalmao stop
no you
Jan 28, 2021
UIPJack Antonoff ruined: Masseduction, Melodrama, and Dedication Side B with his bland ass production
mass education was ass bc of saint vincent
if u don’t like melodrama then that’s on you
don’t listen to taylor swift
- Jan 28, 2021
y’all just saying s***
safe 🪩Jan 28, 2021·2 repliesamorydon’t understand why youre trying to discredit to his work on these albums?
the artists he collab with are already great but he def is a great pop producer
I’m saying that I don’t think he deserves to be put in the conversation for being one of the best songwriters of the decade when every project that puts him in that conversation was with an artist who was already renowned for their songwriting and artistry
He’s a great producer and a great writer
I’m not willing to say he’s THE reason for these projects being so good- Jan 28, 2021Mr Sting
You forgot ruined lorde
was gonna say but didn't want to rile up the lorde stans
- Jan 28, 2021Vega
yeah he's basically this generation's Quincy Jones tbh
this post obvious troll but ppl itt acting like op said this
- Jan 28, 2021safe
I’m saying that I don’t think he deserves to be put in the conversation for being one of the best songwriters of the decade when every project that puts him in that conversation was with an artist who was already renowned for their songwriting and artistry
He’s a great producer and a great writer
I’m not willing to say he’s THE reason for these projects being so goodi feel you i feel you my bad
Jan 28, 2021·1 replyFirst TakeJack WHO off??
Jack off a ton
Jan 28, 2021Op's punctuation game is SORELY lacking
Jan 28, 2021·1 replythe endLiterally top 5 producer of the 2010s
you know I only give him credit for melodrama
Jan 28, 2021Prosecco PapiJack off a ton
- Jan 28, 2021
about to listen to taylor swift just so i can give this more pages than the ti thread
- Jan 28, 2021Childhood
you know I only give him credit for melodrama
- Jan 28, 2021
he made venice b****
- Jan 28, 2021·1 reply
like fundamentally this guy should be good, but something doesn't click some of the times for me
like that kevin and st vincent album don't really work at all. along with the lana s*** too, but that's because I think if he's not making some taylor swift synthpop s*** it doesn't work
Jan 28, 2021·1 replysafeI kinda think he’s overrated
His bleachers stuff was so so
The fun stuff was mid apart from Some Nights which had Jeff Bhasker attached who’s incredible1989 is amazing but reputation is awful and lover is so so plus both folklore and evermore were also driven by The National and Bon Iver
Melodrama is incredible but Pure Heroine was too
Arizona Baby was eh
NFR is great but again he’s working w an artist who’s already incredible
I think he’s good and has great chemistry w people but I haven’t really seen any evidence of him being the driving force behind any of the classics he’s had a hand in
Lana Del Rey is incredible outside of NFR
How is he not a driving force in NFR or Melodrama if he produced damn near the entirety of the albums
Also he didn’t even produce most of Reputation, he had 2 songs where he was the main producer and 5 credits in general out of 15
Also on Arizona Baby Kevin and Romil laid the blueprint of what that album was, Jack Antonoff just helped them flesh the ideas they already had
He’s given Lana, Lorde, and Taylor their best work along with also being impressive on his own. Jack is not overrated
- Jan 28, 2021safe
how?
To me he’s been very hit or miss unless he’s working with people who are exceptional talents on their ownwhat producer takes a mid artist and makes them amazing?
S*** if anything Jack did that w Taylor and Lana
- Jan 28, 2021·1 replysafe
I’m saying that I don’t think he deserves to be put in the conversation for being one of the best songwriters of the decade when every project that puts him in that conversation was with an artist who was already renowned for their songwriting and artistry
He’s a great producer and a great writer
I’m not willing to say he’s THE reason for these projects being so goodIf 2 people make a project, the project is good because of the both of them thats how its supposed to be
- Jan 28, 2021·1 reply
Had to triple quote 3 stupid ass SAFE post in a row
- Jan 28, 2021
Anyways Jack is a legend in pop music with multiple classics under his belt.
- Jan 28, 2021·1 replyChildhood
like fundamentally this guy should be good, but something doesn't click some of the times for me
like that kevin and st vincent album don't really work at all. along with the lana s*** too, but that's because I think if he's not making some taylor swift synthpop s*** it doesn't work
i be forgetting that it was max martin who produced the songs i liked on 1989 instead of jack so i'm not giving him credit for that lol
- Jan 28, 2021·1 replyChildhood
i be forgetting that it was max martin who produced the songs i liked on 1989 instead of jack so i'm not giving him credit for that lol
which ones
- Jan 28, 2021mr get dough
Had to triple quote 3 stupid ass SAFE post in a row
tell em
- Jan 28, 2021·1 replythe end
which ones
blank space, style, and wildest dreams