Reply
  • Nov 3, 2022
    insertcoolnamehere

    But these don't even sound remotely the same.

    Like the cadence of "lady" don't sound like andre's "hey ya"

    This is a space jam reach sir lol

    Agreed

  • Nov 3, 2022

    YOOOO

  • Nov 3, 2022

    they dont call credits the greatest source of music knowledge oat for nothing. credits finds straight stimulate a part of my brain that cant be activated any other way

  • Don't even sound similar. Halo reach

  • Nov 3, 2022

    its not similar at all lol

  • Nov 3, 2022
    ·
    2 replies
    BRAVE

    It’s not close enough to be an interpolation exactly but it’s clearly a homage:

    • the title phrase (phonetically), the way it’s sung and its rhythmic placement are all the exact same; the only difference is notation (even then the melodic contour is the same)
    • both songs are in G major and employ a lot of modal interchange
    • both have a very uptempo groove
    • both are 70s soul and funk based songs

    Anyone who doesn’t hear it just isn’t listening. Also it’s just the hook refrain of the old song in OP that’s being used for Hey Ya btw (0:47-0:54)

    The difference in the two hook phrases is technically equal to this: https://voca.ro/1eEZl3AvxXKj

    @Beach_kneega @begin_again thoughts on this? not trying to get at u, figured its a good breakdown and wanna know what you think

  • Nov 3, 2022
    get up with me

    honestly never understood why they never had him on the track 2 begin with

    we were robbed

    I could be wrong but I know there is another version UGK did of INT playas anthem with other rappers instead of OutKast. I can’t remember if it was Pat or if it was 8Ball & MJG

  • Nov 3, 2022
    WRU fuk em up

    @Beach_kneega @begin_again thoughts on this? not trying to get at u, figured its a good breakdown and wanna know what you think

    i still dont hear it

  • WRU fuk em up

    @Beach_kneega @begin_again thoughts on this? not trying to get at u, figured its a good breakdown and wanna know what you think

    Imma be real witchu, I'm really paying attention but it still sound like a reach to me. Anyways, could be legit but I don't hear it

  • Nov 3, 2022

  • Nov 3, 2022

    I don’t think that’s
    What happened at all but enjoy your fan theory

  • Nov 3, 2022
    ·
    1 reply

    Tbh even without the thread pointing it out, if I heard this for the first time and it got to that 47-54 second mark I woulda instantly went “WTF THATS HEY YA”

    Idk how y’all not hearing it

  • Nov 3, 2022
    vagabonds

    i can kinda hear it idk why niggas saying it's the biggest stretch lol

    They in denial

  • goretex 💁🏽‍♂️
    Nov 3, 2022

    man who tf cares they made it better!!!!!

  • Nov 4, 2022

    @OP rn

  • Nov 4, 2022

    Underrated post

  • Justin 😼
    Nov 4, 2022

    op a fool

  • Nov 4, 2022
    BRAVE

    Tbh even without the thread pointing it out, if I heard this for the first time and it got to that 47-54 second mark I woulda instantly went “WTF THATS HEY YA”

    Idk how y’all not hearing it

  • Nov 4, 2022

    I guess sort of? Melody isn't close enough imo

  • Dec 31, 2022

    a reach. Dumb ass thread

  • Dec 31, 2022
    ·
    1 reply

    op really thought he had one
    L

  • Dec 31, 2022
    WRU fuk em up

    ill peep later but using same melodies hooks and motives across southern rap is very very well-established as kinda its own thing imo. the entire three six discography including affiliates could probably be traced to a certain number of 'first-ever' tracks. not a bad thing at all either

    Not a sample, literally same beat, different mix. Was originally pat's song but pimp c heard the song while in jail and loved it so much he reached out to DJ Paul when he came home

  • Dec 31, 2022
    ·
    1 reply
    Fries

    Well dang! I still don't hear too strong of a resemblance but that's crazy, OP really uncovered a secret here

    Post I'm replying to is deleted but basically the composers of the song in OP were credited on an early test pressing of Hey Ya!, OP is legit

  • Dec 31, 2022
    ty4nothing

    op really thought he had one
    L

    I still think I do

  • Dec 31, 2022
    Fries

    Post I'm replying to is deleted but basically the composers of the song in OP were credited on an early test pressing of Hey Ya!, OP is legit

    wondering why that got deleted, dre really pulled up